Contradictory Argument Analysis
Titze (2015) makes a contradictory argument based on flow phonation treatment being used for those with muscle tension dysphonia. Titze (2015) suggests that increasing acoustic output if the air column is restrictive would be useful in using flow phonation exercises. Unfortunately, air column output is rarely restrictive. According to Titze (2015) flow phonation is counterproductive because it does not allow for a single breath to produce a long phrase. Titze (2015) expressed his concern for using this technique on singers because it would restrict their breath support. Taking this into consideration while treating a patient would be of upmost importance. A person’s hobbies or career would need to be discussed to determine if this treatment