Conflict Resolution Peace Education
Running head: Appraising 20 years of reconciliation-aimed encounters
Does contact work in protracted asymmetrical conflict? Appraising 20 of reconciliation-aimed encounters between Israeli Jews and Palestinians
Ifat Maoz
Department of Communication and Journalism
Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel
Reference: Journal of Peace Research, Revised and Resubmitted
Abstract
In the past few decades, planned contact interventions between groups in conflict have played an important role in attempts at improving intergroup relations and achieving peace and reconciliation. This article focuses on such reconciliation-aimed intergroup encounters between Israeli Jews and Palestinians that seek to reduce hostility and increase understanding and cooperation between the two nationalities. Like other contact interventions conducted in settings of intergroup conflict, encounters between Israeli Jews and Palestinians represent a paradoxical project: this is a project that aspires to generate equality and cooperation between groups that are embedded in a protracted, asymmetrical conflict. Though existing research teaches us valuable lessons on the effectiveness of contact conducted under optimal conditions, little is said about contact between groups involved in asymmetrical protracted dispute. The goal of this analysis is to examine the evolution of reconciliation-aimed contact interventions between Israeli Jews and Palestinians in the past 20 years. The research method is qualitative, relying on ethnographic data assembled during the relevant period of time. The findings identify and trace the evolution of four major models used in Jewish-Palestinian planned encounters: The Coexistence Model, the Joint Projects Model, the Confrontational Model and the Narrative-Story-Telling Model. The strengths and limitations of each model in transforming intergroup attitudes in asymmetric conflict are discussed.
Does Contact Work in Protracted Asymmetrical
Does contact work in protracted asymmetrical conflict? Appraising 20 of reconciliation-aimed encounters between Israeli Jews and Palestinians
Ifat Maoz
Department of Communication and Journalism
Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel
Reference: Journal of Peace Research, Revised and Resubmitted
Abstract
In the past few decades, planned contact interventions between groups in conflict have played an important role in attempts at improving intergroup relations and achieving peace and reconciliation. This article focuses on such reconciliation-aimed intergroup encounters between Israeli Jews and Palestinians that seek to reduce hostility and increase understanding and cooperation between the two nationalities. Like other contact interventions conducted in settings of intergroup conflict, encounters between Israeli Jews and Palestinians represent a paradoxical project: this is a project that aspires to generate equality and cooperation between groups that are embedded in a protracted, asymmetrical conflict. Though existing research teaches us valuable lessons on the effectiveness of contact conducted under optimal conditions, little is said about contact between groups involved in asymmetrical protracted dispute. The goal of this analysis is to examine the evolution of reconciliation-aimed contact interventions between Israeli Jews and Palestinians in the past 20 years. The research method is qualitative, relying on ethnographic data assembled during the relevant period of time. The findings identify and trace the evolution of four major models used in Jewish-Palestinian planned encounters: The Coexistence Model, the Joint Projects Model, the Confrontational Model and the Narrative-Story-Telling Model. The strengths and limitations of each model in transforming intergroup attitudes in asymmetric conflict are discussed.
Does Contact Work in Protracted Asymmetrical
References: Abu-Nimer, Muhamad, 1999. Dialogue, Conflict Resolution and Change: Arab-Jewish Encounters in Israel. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Abu-Nimer, Muhamad, 2004. 'Education for Coexistence and Arab-Jewish Encounters in Israel: Potential and Challenges '. Journal of Social Issues 60(2): 405-422. Allport, Gordon, 1954. The Nature of Prejudice. Reading. MA: Addison-Wesley. Amir, Yehuda, 1969. 'Contact Hypothesis in Ethic Relations '. Psychological Bulletin 71: 319-342. Aronson, Elliot & Shelley Patnoe, 1997. The Jigsaw Classroom (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Longman. Bar-On, Dan., 2000. Bridging the Gap. Hamburg: Koerber. Bar-On, Dan, 2002. 'Conciliation through Storytelling: Beyond Victimhood ', in Gavriel Salomon & Baruch Nevo, eds., Peace Education: The Concept, Principles and Practices around the World. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum (109-116). Bar-On, Dan, 2006. Tell Your Life Story: Creating Dialogue Among Jews and Germans, Israelis and Palestinians. Central European University Press. Bar-On, Dan, 2008. The Others within Us: Constructing Jewish-Israeli Identity. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press. Bar-On, Dan. & Fatma Kassem, 2004. 'Story Telling as a Way to Work through Intractable Conflicts: The German-Jewish Experience and its Relevance to the Palestinian-Israeli Context ', Journal of Social Issues 60: 289-306. Bar-Tal, Daniel, 2000. 'From Intractable Conflict through Conflict Resolution to Reconciliation: Psychological Analysis ', Political Psychology 21: 351-365. Bar-Tal, Daniel, 2001. 'Why Does Fear Override Hope in Societies Engulfed by Intractable Conflict, as it Does in the Israeli society ', Political Psychology 22: 601-627. Bar-Tal, Daniel, 2002. 'The Elusive Nature of Peace Education ', in Gavriel Salomon & Baruch Nevo, eds., Peace Education: The Concept, Principles and Practices around the World. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum (27-36). Bar-Tal, Daniel, 2004. 'Nature, Rationale, and Effectiveness of Education for Coexistence ', Journal of Social Issues 60(2): 253-271. Bekerman, Zvi, 2002. 'The Discourse of Nation and Culture: Its Impact on Palestinian-Jewish Encounters in Israel ', Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology 8: 259-276. Bekerman, Zvi, 2007a. 'Collective Memory and Obstacles to Reconciliation Efforts in Israel. In Smita Tewari Jassal & Eyal Ben-Ari, eds., The Partition Motif in Contemporary Conflicts. London, GB: SAGE (323-343). Bekerman, Zvi, 2007b. 'Rethinking Intergroup Encounters: Rescuing Praxis from Theory, Activity from Education, and Peace/co-existence from Identity and Culture. Peace Education, 4(1), 29-41. Bekerman, Zvi., 2009a. 'Education Programs for Improving Intergroup Relations between Palestinians and Jews in Israel ', in James Banks, ed., The Routledge International Companion to Multicultural Education. New York, NY: Routledge (210-222). Bekerman, Zvi., 2009b. 'Identity Work in Palestinian-Jewish Intergroup Encounters: A Cultural Rhetorical Analysis ', Journal of Multicultural Discourse 4:205-219. Dixon, John; Kevin Durrheim, & Colin Tredoux, 2005. 'Beyond the Optimal Strategy: A 'Reality Check ' for the Contact Hypothesis ', American Psychologist 60: 697-711. Dixon, John; Kevin Durrheim, & Colin Tredoux, 2007. 'Contact and Attitudes towards the Principle and Practice of Racial Equality ', Psychological Science 18: 867-872. Glaser, Barney & Anselm Strauss, 1967. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago IL: Aldine. Halabi, Rabah. & Nava Sonnenschein, 2004. 'The Jewish-Palestinian Encounter in a Time of Crisis ', Journal of Social Issues 60(2): 375-387. Helman, Sarit., 2002. 'Monologic Results of Dialogue: Jewish-Palestinian Encounter Groups as Sites of Essentialization ', Identities: Global Studies of Culture and Power 9: 327-354. Kelman, Herbert, 1998. 'Social-psychological Contributions to Peacemaking and Peacebuilding in the Middle East ', Applied Psychology: An International Review, 47(1): 5-29. Maoz, Ifat, 2000a. 'Power Relations in Intergroup Encounters: A Case Study of Jewish-Arab Encounters in Israel ', International Journal of Intercultural Relations 24: 259-277. Maoz, Ifat, 2000c. 'An Experiment in Peace: Processes and Effects in Reconciliation Aimed Workshops of Israeli and Palestinian Youth ', Journal of Peace Research 37(6): 721-736. Maoz, Ifat, 2001. 'Conceptual Mapping and Evaluation of Jewish-Arab Coexistence Activities in Israel (1999-2000) - Summary Evaluation Report ', submitted to the Abraham Fund. Jerusalem, Israel. Maoz, Ifat., 2004. 'Coexistence is in the Eye of the Beholder: Evaluating Intergroup Encounter Interventions between Jews and Arabs in Israel ', Journal of Social Issues 60: 437-452. Maoz, Ifat, 2005. 'Evaluating the Quality of Communication between Groups in Dispute: Equality in Contact Interventions between Jews and Arabs in Israel ', Negotiation Journal January: 131-146. Maoz, Ifat., 2006. 'Between Coexistence and Conflict: Jewish-Arab Encounters in Israel ', in Elie Podeh & Asher Kaufman, eds., Arab-Jewish Relations: From Conflict to Resolution?. GB: Sussex Academic Press (319-341). Maoz, Ifat., 2010. 'Educating for Peace through Planned Encounters between Arabs and Jews in Israel: A Reappraisal of Effectiveness ', in Gavriel Salomon & Edward Cairns, eds., Handbook of Peace Education. New York, NY: Psychology Press (303-314). Maoz, Ifat, & Dan Bar-On, 2002. 'The Link from Working through the Holocaust to Current Ethnic Conflicts: Describing and Evaluating the TRT Group Workshop in Hamburg ', Group 26: 29-48. Maoz, Ifat; Shoshana Steinberg; Dan Bar-On, & Mueen Fakhereldeen, 2002. 'The Dialogue between the ' 'Self" and the "Other": A Process Analysis of Palestinian-Jewish Encounters in Israel ', Human Relations 55: 931-962. Maoz, I .; Dan Bar-On, & Sihan Yikya, 2007. '“They Understand Only Force”: A Critical Examination of the Eruption of Verbal Violence in a Jewish-Palestinian Dialogue ', Peace and Conflict Studies 14(2): 27-48. Niens, Ulrike & Edward, Cairns, 2005. 'Conflict, Contact, and Education in Northern Ireland ', Theory into Practice 44(4): 337-344. Pettigrew, Thomas, 1998. 'Intergroup Contact Theory ', Annual Review of Psychology 49: 65-85. Pettigrew, Thomas, & Linda Tropp, 2006. 'A Meta-Analytic Test of Intergroup Contact Theory ', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90(5): 751-783. Ron, Yiftach; Ifat Maoz, & Zvi Bekerman, 2009. '"Jewish-Democratic" or "of All its Citizens"? The Effect of Jewish-Arab Dialogue Programs on Jewish-Israeli Ideological perspectives ', Unpublished Manuscript. Ross, Marc, 2000. '‘Good-Enough’ isn’t So Bad: Thinking about Success and Failure in Ethnic Conflict Management ', Journal of Peace Psychology 6: 27-47. Salomon, Gavriel, 2002. 'The Nature of Peace Education: Not All Programs are Created Equal ', in Gavriel Salomon & Baruch Nevo, eds., Peace Education: The Concept, Principles and Practices around the World. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum (3-14). Salomon, Gavriel, 2004. 'Does Peace Education Make a Difference in the Context of an Intractable Conflict? ', Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology 10(3): 257-274. Salomon, Gavriel, 2006. 'Does Peace Education Really Make a Difference? ', Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology 12(1): 37-48. Saunders, Harold, 1999. A Public Peace Process: Sustained Dialogue to Transform Racial and Ethnic Conflict. New York: St. Martin 's Press. Sherif, Muzafer, 1966. In Common Predicament: Social Psychology of Intergroup Conflict and Cooperation. Boston: Houghton-Mifflin. Stephan, Walter & Cookie Stephan, 2001. Improving Intergroup Relations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Steinberg, Shoshana. & Dan Bar-On, 2002. 'An Analysis of the Group Process in Encounters between Jews and Palestinians Using a Typology for Discourse Classification ', International Journal of Intercultural Relations 26 (2): 199-214. Strauss, Anselm & Juliet Corbin, 1998. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Suleiman, Ramzi., 2004. 'The Planned Encounter between Israeli Jews and Palestinians: A Social-Psychological Perspective ', Journal of Social Issues 60: 323-337. Tajfel, Henri & John Turner, 1986. 'The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behavior ', in Stephen Worchel & William Austin, eds., Psychology of Intergroup Relations. Chicago: Nelson-Hall (7-24). Zemach, Mina., 1986. Political and Social Attitudes of Israeli Youth, Tel Aviv, Israel: Dahaf Research Institute [Hebrew]. Zuabi, Baha. (2008). The Influence of Participation in Bi-national Soccer Clubs on the Perception of "the Other Side" among