“A Valediction forbidding mourning” and “Atlas” both effectively include the use of conceit in their exploration of love. They discuss love from different angles, portraying different views of the role that love plays in life. Although the poems have very different structures, similarly both poets choose to use unexpected objects as the subjects of their metaphors.
John Donne explains the love between him and his partner through the image of a compass. This effective use of conceit explains that just like the legs of a compass they are connected, “As stiff twin compasses are two…” Donne compares himself to the fixed point of the compass; always there for the one he loves wherever she wanders. This implies his love is firm and set in stone. In comparison Fanthorpe implies in “Atlas” that the love in her relationship is fixed, “The permanently rickety elaborate structures of living…” as they go through the problems that arise in everyday life.
Donne refers to “gold” which can connote to its alchemical symbol, a circle with a point in the center. He is therefore explaining she is the center of his world. In contrast Fanthorpe uses the mythical character of Atlas, who holds up the world to similarly express how her partner holds up her world. Donne’s reference to “gold” is also contrasting to the objects that Fanthorpe mentions in “Atlas.” Gold is very precious, just like Donne’s love whereas Fanthorpe includes much less valuable objects such as the “WD40.” “Atlas” does not romanticize love in the way Donne does but in contrast portrays its presence in a much more mundane and practical sense, “…maintenance is the sensible side of love…”
“A Valediction forbidding mourning” conveys the indescribable and abstract feeling of love. Donne uses inspiration from the metaphysical school of thought. Comparable to this is the supernatural sense Fanthrope depicts through the metaphorical use of “Atlas.” Donne also touches on the idea of love being supernatural as he mentions discoveries about the universe and “trepidation of the spheres.” (Once again circular imagery) He also says their love is like no other, “But we by a love, so much redin’d.”
Both poets use conceit to depict their complex and personal views on love. Donne includes the use of conceit from nature and science while explaining his love is connected by the mind, “inter-assured on the mind…” In contrast Fanthorpe portrays love in a more everyday sense and although she does not romanticize it she implies its strength through the way they support one another. The poems are comparable in some ways such as the force and strength of love but contrast in the effects they give.
Georgia Gee
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Through the comparative study of John Donne's poetry and Margaret Edson's play W;t we are shown the individual context of both writers and their perspectives on relationships and death. Donne represents his assurance of life after death in his Holy Sonnets. Additional to this in his earlier poetry, his valuing of deep relationship being critical to the human experience is reflected by his renaissance belief. Edson's individual post-modern context is apparent in the appropriation and rewriting of Donne's ideas to reflect her own perspective. This is further emphasized in the choices made by each composer to represent their ideas in different textual forms.…
- 786 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
A text is essentially a product of its context, as its prevailing values are inherently derived by the author from society. However, the emergence of post-modern theories allows for audience interpretation, thus it must be recognised that meaning in texts can be shaped and reshaped. Significantly, this may occur as connections between texts are explored. These notions are reflected in the compostion of Edson’s W;t and Donne’s poetry as their relationship is established through intertextual references, corresponding values and ideas and the use of language features. Edson particularly portrays key values surrounding the notions of the importance of loved based relationships, and death and resurrection: central themes of Donne’s Holy Sonnets and Divine Poems. The purpose of these authors distinctly correlate as each has attempted to provide fresh insight into the human condition by challenging prevalent ideals. Thus, Edson incorporates Donne’s work to illuminate both explicit and implicit themes, creating an undeniable condition.…
- 940 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In your answer you should consider the ways in which Donne and Jennings use form, structure and language to present their thoughts and ideas. You should make relevant references to your wider reading in the poetry of love (40 marks).…
- 2003 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Shakespeare’s sonnet 130, “My mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun” and Pablo Neruda’s “My ugly love” are popularly known to describe beauty in a way hardly anyone would write: through the truth. It’s a common fact that modern lovers and poets speak or write of their beloved with what they and the audience would like to hear, with kind and breathtaking words and verses. Yet, Shakespeare and Neruda, honest men as they both were, chose to write about what love truly is, it matters most what’s on the inside rather than the outside. The theme of true beauty and love are found through Shakespeare and Neruda’s uses of imagery, structure, and tone.…
- 1124 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Consider the ways in which Donne and Jennings use form, structure and language to present their thoughts and ideas. You should make relevant references to your wider reading in the poetry of love.…
- 1834 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
Donne’s poems are interesting in the way they often present an ongoing thought process, rather than a story with a distinct beginning and end. Donne being from the literary culture; many of his poems reflect this mid-way change of heart, as he is comfortable dealing in ongoing reflection and experience, rather than static facts. One of Donne’s love poems, ‘The Sunne Rising’ centres around Donne, in bed with his lover, annoyed at the sun for disturbing their slumber. “Busie old foole, unruly Sunne” he writes. Donne, in personifying the sun, and describing such a thing in paradox (“unruly sun”), supports the idea that literary culture places more emphasis on emotion and description than logical fact. The structure of ideas throughout the poem thereafter is fluid. Donne is initially annoyed at the sun for its punctuality, saying that a love like his knows no time, and the sun would be better off chastising late schoolboys. As the poem progresses, Donne goes from annoyance, to mocking the sun's supposed power (“Thy beames, so reverend… I could eclipse then with a winke”), to then feeling content, and almost bad for the sun. Donne writes “Thou sunne are halfe as happy’as wee, in that the world’s contracted thus”, in which he is stating that the poor, old sun must have an easier job shining down on him and his lover, as their entire world is confined to each other. It is this notion of fluidity of ideas that further reflects the literary culture of Donne’s poems. He uses his writings, not to record tangible fact and feeling, but to support the idea that both his thoughts, and the subjects of his writing, can easily be written flexibly, as they are both…
- 2452 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Donne’s poetry attempt to answer the mere impossible questions of life, death and love in eccentric and unexpected chains of reasoning, his complex figure of speech, elaborate imagery and bizarre metaphors creates a sense of vibrancy for the reader as they become enthralled in the emotions and meanings behind his poems.…
- 582 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The erotic and the religious are confused immediately, as the poem begins with the warlike phrase “batter my heart”1. The verb ‘batter’ could refer to a battering ram, conveying the urgency that Donne requires God to act, as though he is in the middle of a conflict of faith of such magnitude his desperation makes it akin to a siege. Erotically, a battering ram can be seen as a phallic symbol involving rape, as it forces its way into the kingdom through the doors which were meant to only allow desirable people through. The sonnet is written according to Petrarchan custom, with 14 lines in iambic pentameter. However, this line begins with a stressed syllable as opposed to an unstressed one, creating a trochee. While this plosive does reflect the ferocity of the act commanded, beginning with a stop could also symbolise how he knows should not command acts from God, as though he is forcing it out in order for it to bypass his bane, “reason”2. As a result, this strongly demonstrates how Donne is reliant on force in order to overcome his qualms and anxieties.…
- 1196 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Edson uses many different characters, in particular the protagonist, Vivian Bearing, to conceptualise ideas of Donne poems. This is by drawing relations from Donne’s poetry and Vivian’s life events such as through job prospects as well as relational and death issues encountered. This is then use in order to trivalise the study of Donne but drawing different meanings from the initial intended notions. Donne uses poems such as Death Be Not Proud, Hymne to my God, my God in my Sicknesse (Hymn to God), The Valediction: Forbidding Mourning (The Valediction), If Poysonous Mineralls and My Playes Last Scene in order to portray his views upon the themes of death and relational values as well as the significance of religion. The manipulation of meaning in different contexts is prominently showcased in W;t in various ways.…
- 1284 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
While Donne appears to hold a holistic, unified view of love, undivided by the physical and made whole by the spiritual, the body of the woman is ironically the real obstruction of the abstract. Donne discards human bodies for celestial figures: “..free spheres move faster far than can/Birds whom the air resists…” (Lines 87-88). Air is yet another element that taints and obstructs the ‘free sphere’, yet it is vital to note the similar inhumanity of the poet in being described as a bird. Instead, both lovers described as celestial ‘spheres’ denotes transcendence from earthly ties, advancing instead along an “empty and ethereal way” (Line 89). Love, in its emptiest form, also appears at its purest. However, transformation of the poet, framed as the epic hero, prevents Donne from having a firmer grasp on pure…
- 1309 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
[E] Donne wants the reader to be able to understand how the lover sees the image of marriage to his lover.…
- 745 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This poem presents a bleak and mournful image as Donne mourns the death of a beloved. It is said to be about Lucy, the patron saint of the blind, however, as many of Donne’s poems cannot be dated with certainty, the ‘beloved’ remains ambiguous. The stanza form is traditional and the use of rhyming couplets can suggest that the poem is to be spoken, almost like an epitaph for the deceased beloved.…
- 514 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
John Donne’s poetry conveys the message that metaphysical poetry is dependent on unpredicted imagery and symbolism. This is expressed through A Valediction: Forbidding Mourning and The Canonization. The usage of Sexual ecstasy, the microcosmic and macrocosmic and odd connotations with love are the main characteristics of John Donne’s metaphysical poetry.…
- 759 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The two main themes covered by these two writers are love and death. The poems which use love as the main theme inspire the reader and offer hope that true love exists and is not a fragment of their imagination. The feelings that are discussed in these poems are feelings that all people can experience but are difficult to describe and put into words. This is what makes the poetry so worthwhile to read, to see how the feelings that relate to love are expressed and how they are shown with images and other writing styles.…
- 598 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
He compares their separate souls with the feet of a compass while his lover’s soul is the fixed foot in the…
- 2473 Words
- 10 Pages
Good Essays