Brandy Robbins
Post University
Comprehensive Sex Education – An Unbiased Approach
Concern for public health and safety have resulted in regulations of medical practices to standards of living enforced by social services and so on; sex education for today’s youth should be based on this same premise, to control the risks that are involved with the sexual activity of youth in the U.S. which are a potential threats to public health and safety. Among these concerns for youth who become sexually active outside of the context of marriage are the threat of STI’s and HIV and unwanted pregnancy. Looking at sex education from the perspective of public health and safety, it is clear that the most logical approach to effective sex education for today’s youth is the comprehensive approach which address several options for protecting oneself from the risks of sexual activity, as opposed to the abstinence only approach which has a biased “one solution for all” approach that does not address youth who are at a high risk for negative outcomes of sexual activity.
Public Health and Safety Concerns
STI’s & HIV According to Collins, Alagiri, & Summers (2002), nearly four million youth will be infected with a sexually transmitted infection (STI) and there are approximately 10,000 new cases of HIV in individuals ages 22 and under each year (p.11). The numbers clearly show that some young Americans have had sex outside of the context of marriage and have done it unsafely or used protection incorrectly. It is a public health and safety concern to make sure that young Americans are not only educated about STI’s and HIV but that they are also taught how to properly protect themselves if they do engage in sexual activity.
Unwanted Teen Pregnancy Another risk for young Americans who become sexually active without proper education is teen pregnancy. Teen pregnancy can cause emotional and physical stresses to the teen mother and father as well as the baby and another issue with youth who become parents is that it lowers their chances of finishing school (Center for National Disease Control, 2013). Babies who are repeat births are more likely to have a low birth weight which puts the baby’s health at risk and for some teen parent’s, parenthood can be a source of emotional, physical, and financial stress which can cause developmental issues as teens mature and move through the life stages. There are many reasons to educate youth on how to prevent pregnancy and it is a public health and safety concern to do so.
Abstinence Only vs. Comprehensive Sex Education
Abstinence Only Sex Education
Abstinence only education only provides one option for protecting against STI’s/HIV and pregnancy and that is abstinence, it does not address the subject of contraception, abortion, or condom use. Abstinence only programs are based on the premise that the only acceptable context for sexual activity is in the confines of marriage (Collins, Alagiri, & Summers, 2002, p. 11), but this overlooks the gay and lesbian population of youth who even as adults, are not allowed to marry in many states. Abstinence only education does not teach today’s youth how to protect themselves if they do become sexually active and discriminates against the minority of youth who are gay and lesbian by stating that the only acceptable context for sexual activity is in the confines of marriage, which is not even possible for many gay and lesbian couples. According to Goodwin & Mosher (2010), 28% of men and women had lived together before marriage and 15% had lived together and never married, because so many couples are choosing to cohabitate before and sometimes instead of marrying, it is important to have a sex education program that considers the possibility of sexual activity outside of the context of marriage and educate youth on how to protect themselves in those situations.
Comprehensive Sex Education Comprehensive sex education promotes abstinence but also educates youth on STI’s/HIV, teen pregnancy, condoms, abortion and stresses the importance of protection against the risks associated with premarital sex. With hundreds of thousands of new cases of sexually transmitted diseases each year it is in the best interest of public health and safety to educate youth on the importance of safe sex practices to try to prevent as many new cases as possible. Because comprehensive sex education offers options to those who want to abstain from sexual activity outside the context of marriage and options to those who do not wait until marriage, it is the most logical and effective method of sex education for today’s youth.
Conclusion
Many couples today choose to cohabitate instead of marrying and gay and lesbian couples are not allowed to marry in some states, therefore choosing a sex education program based on the idea that the only acceptable context for sexual activity is in the confines of marriage is an unrealistic and ineffective method for educating today’s youth on sex and it’s risks and the ways to protect themselves against those risks. Comprehensive sex education addresses all of these issues and provides more than one option for protecting oneself against the risks of premarital sex and accordingly is the more logical method for educating young Americans about responsible sexual behavior.
References
Center for National Disease Control. (2013, 04 25). Breaking the cylce of teen pregnancy. Retrieved from Center for National Disease Control: http://www.cdc.gov/features/vitalsigns/TeenPregnancy/index.html
Collins, C., Alagiri, P., & Summers, T. (2002). Abstinence Only vs. Comprehensive Sex Education: What are the arguments? What is the evidence? San Fransisco: Progressive Health Partners.
Goodwin, P., & Mosher, C. A. (2010). Marriage and cohabitation in the United States: A statistical portrait based on Cycle 6 (2002) of the National Survey of Family Growth. Washington: National Center for Health Statistics.
References: Center for National Disease Control. (2013, 04 25). Breaking the cylce of teen pregnancy. Retrieved from Center for National Disease Control: http://www.cdc.gov/features/vitalsigns/TeenPregnancy/index.html Collins, C., Alagiri, P., & Summers, T. (2002). Abstinence Only vs. Comprehensive Sex Education: What are the arguments? What is the evidence? San Fransisco: Progressive Health Partners. Goodwin, P., & Mosher, C. A. (2010). Marriage and cohabitation in the United States: A statistical portrait based on Cycle 6 (2002) of the National Survey of Family Growth. Washington: National Center for Health Statistics.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Soaring rates of sexually transmitted diseases among teens are adding urgency to the debate over sex education. Conservatives claim the alarming statistics illustrate why abstinence should be the single mantra when it comes to sex ed. Liberals counter that the increase in disease is the strongest case for more detailed information. Caught in the middle are America’s kids, who are more vulnerable than ever to potentially deadly diseases.…
- 1245 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the average teenager engages in sexual intercourse by the age of seventeen, but do not marry until the mid-twenties (citation). This means that young adults are at an increased risk for unintended pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections for nearly ten years or longer. The numbers of students engaging in sexual activity of ages thirteen to twenty-four continues to grow each year, as does the number of unplanned pregnancies and HIV infections due to not being fully educated about the risks. Today, the duty of educating students and teenagers about sexual intercourse and the risks involved is left to the government and public school system. Abstinence education programs in public…
- 637 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The increase of teenage pregnancy has placed a burden upon the argument for non-abstinent-only education. As indicated by the National Family Planning and Reproductive Health Association, every year an estimated 850,000 teenagers become pregnant. These statistics also conclude that more than one-third of girls will become pregnant before the age of twenty, and that 78 percent of these pregnancies are unintended. Comprehensive sex education helps delay sexual intercourse between teens by offering them the tools they need to avoid unintended pregnancy.(Berne 91) “Research done by Douglas Kirby for the National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy shows that programs that provide teenagers with comprehensive sex education that includes a discussion of…
- 1295 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
There are two broad techniques used to provide sex education, comprehensive sex education and abstinence based sex education (Mezey, 2011). The abstinence-based avenue explains to children that it is morally wrong to have sex prior to a heterosexual marriage, which leads to many problems such as higher rates of unplanned pregnancy, sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), sexually transmitted infections (STIs), and a lack of knowledge on all subjects related to sex and healthy relationships (2011). This is especially true amongst LGBTQIA+ and people with disabilities because they are left to find out sex and sexually related experiences through trial and error, and the Internet. Comprehensive sex education on the other hand, is when students are presented with every possible contraceptive option, their benefits and risks, statistical safety from preventing pregnancy and STDs/STIs (2011). Students also learn about what a healthy relationship is and how to effectively communicate their wants, needs, and limits in a sexual relationship. Comprehensive sex education is essential for students to grow into functioning adults, and thus participating members of a democracy (2011). Historically, sex education was not viewed as a necessary aspect for students until the 1960s and the demand for evidence-based education began in 1964. During this time period, Planned Parenthood established the Sexuality Information Education Council of the United States (SIECUS) to effectively education the younger population on sex and sexuality (2011). SIECUS founded the National Guidelines Task Force in 1990 who’s mission was to make sex education a promotion of sexual health and providing a positive view on sex, in comparison to the immoral view that abstinence-based sex education provided…
- 1641 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Each of us deserves medically accurate and thorough information in order to make informed decisions about our health. Teenagers who are exposed solely to abstinence-only sexual education programs are not experiencing this right to information. Abstinence-only sexual education programs preach abstaining from sex until marriage, often omitting conversations about other significant topics of sexual health – such as contraception, STIs, etc. Although practicing abstinence is the only sure way to avoid STIs and unwanted pregnancy, it is not realistic to expect all adolescents to remain abstinent until marriage. Research suggests that implementing comprehensive sexual education programs – those that include information on an array of sexual health…
- 606 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Since the first sex education video, "Human Growth" was shown in public schools in the 1940's, sex education in school has remained a controversial subject (Bellafante 9.1). In the present however, it is no longer disputed whether or not sex-ed should be taught, but what should be taught in a sex education program. Conservatives and Liberals both agree that sex education in public schools is important but, their views on what should be taught differ dramatically. Despite the various monikers to describe different sex education programs and curricula, there are really only two types: abstinence-until-marriage and comprehensive (Sex Education Programs: Definitions & Point-by-Point Comparison). In present day society, it is apparent that a comprehensive sex education program should be required and promoted.…
- 989 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Many sexually active teens are never educated on the dangers of unprotected sex, because their schools do not teach this kind of education. Could changing this lead to less sexually transmitted infections or teenage pregnancy? Teaching options could ensure more safety to teenagers. Should sex education be taught in public schools in the United States, and if so, what kind of education is the best choice for today’s teenagers?…
- 270 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The issue of sex education has long been a controversial one. The two basic types of sex education in the United States are abstinence-only and comprehensive. While comprehensive education advocates abstinence as the primary defense against unwanted pregnancy, sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), and HIV/AIDS, it also addresses the inevitability that some adolescents have or will engage in sexual behavior. Twenty-one of the fifty states have school districts which provide condom availability programs (Brown, Pennylegion, & Hillard, 1997). Providing information about contraception and how to have “safer” sex is an integral part of comprehensive sex education. Providing condoms in schools is a much debated aspect of some comprehensive programs. In contrast, abstinence-only programs discuss abstinence, or refraining from sex until marriage, as the only guarantee of protection from the growing epidemics of teenage pregnancy, STDs, and HIV/AIDS. Although published surveys report 68% to 75% of adults have supported distributing condoms in schools (Fanburg, Kaplan, & Naylor, 1995), more than half of students in the United States are being taught abstinence-only curricula, according to a website dedicated to adult sex education, (http://www.eroticuniversity.com/articles/sexed1.htm). Both types of education seek to diminish the growing rate of these problems among adolescents. Advocates of either program have strong opinions on having condoms available to students in school.…
- 2605 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Whether its safe sex practices or even abstinence, all of these issues must be dealt with in an educational setting, because when we look at teen pregnancy rates, sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS, it only makes sense to have as much education as possible. This allows them to make more informed choices about engaging in sexual intercourse. The youth do not always consider the consequences of having sex, but with well educated instructors informing them, they can learn the dangers that come with having sex. If someone has no prior information about STD’s and they engage in sexual intercourse, they not only put themselves at risk but…
- 1188 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The issue of teen pregnancy and sexual health is no secret. The rates in the United States of teen pregnancy and STDs is very high (Kirby, D. 2007). There are different strategies in the fight to reduce te numbers of teens with pregnancies of sexual health issues. Most are centered around education, but there are give general classifications: “curriculum-based programs, clinician-patient interactions in clinic settings, video- and computer-based programs, programs for parents and their families, and multicomponent programs (Kirby, D. 2007). “ The most popular of these groups are the impact of sex education programs and it is the group that is the most measured.…
- 267 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Each year, U.S. teens experience as many as 850,000 pregnancies, and youth under age 25 experience about 9.1 million sexually transmitted infections. By age 18, 70 percent of U.S. females and 62 percent of U.S. males have initiated vaginal sex (McKeon). Comprehensive sex education is effective at assisting young people to make healthy decisions about sex and to adopt healthy sexual behaviors. No abstinence-only-until-marriage program has been shown to help teens delay the initiation of sex or to protect themselves when they do initiate sex. (McKeon). That’s why safe sex should be taught to teenagers at school because of the rising STDs and pregnancies rates.…
- 1124 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Sex education in public schools should involve all aspects of protective measures regarding sex and our youth, including contraceptives as well as abstinence. No matter how abstinence is emphasized, there will always be young people who choose to be sexually active. Kids are becoming more sexually active at an earlier age. Sixty-six percent of high school students in America have done it by their senior year (Masland n.d.). Schools should take an active role to educate and inform students about the risks involved in becoming sexually active and provide resources for students who choose to be.…
- 1544 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Teenage pregnancy is a universal problem that accompanies the beginning of sexual activity at increasingly younger ages. Surprisingly, only one in 5 youth do not have intercourse before the age of 20, and in the United States alone, annually, almost one million teenagers between the ages of 15 19 becomes pregnant (Rector, 2007). Sexual activity among adolescents is a major problem confronting the nation and the world. Consequently, this has led to a rising incidence of sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), emotional and psychological conflicts, and out-of-wedlock childbearing. As a result, sex education should be taught at an early age as a preventative measure. Teaching abstinence and sex education at an early age is not only very popular; it also makes sense. Social science data shows that teens who abstain from sex do substantially better on a wide range of outcomes (Rector and Johnson, 2005). For example, teens who abstain from sex are less likely to be depressed and to attempt suicide; to experience sexually transmitted diseases; to have children out-of-wedlock; and to live in poverty as well as become welfare dependents as adults. The earlier children become sexually active the more detrimental it is to the health of the mother and child. Teenage pregnancy is a problem that affects nearly every society -developed and developing alike. In essence, it is a common public health problem worldwide. Finally, those who delay sexual activity are more likely to have stable and enduring marriages as adults. Therefore, there are vitally important efforts aimed at reducing out-of-wedlock childbearing among young adult women, improving children 's well-being, and increasing adult happiness over the long term.…
- 2350 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Ku, L. C., Sonenstein, F. L., &. Pleck, J. H. (1992). The Association of AIDS Education and Sex Education with Sexual Behavior and Condom Use among Teenage Men. Family Planning Perspectives, 24(3), 100-106. Retrieved on May 9, 2009 from Jstor database.…
- 2935 Words
- 12 Pages
Best Essays -
Sex education is taught to every young person in virtually every school across the country. In the majority of these sex education programs, physical anatomy and safe contraception are the main focuses of the programs, telling young people what the physical rewards and consequences may be but avoiding some of the key issues relating to mental, emotional and spiritual effects. Proponents of these programs feel that we must educate our youth on "safe sex." It 's no wonder that premarital sex is so prevalent in our world today. As a result of this, physical problems of sexually transmitted diseases, psychological and emotional effects, and spiritual implications all tie together to create a vortex of consequences that have a deep and lasting impact. These consequences are not being addressed in these programs and that is why they are failing to have an impact on the decline of premarital sex.…
- 836 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays