Preview

Comparisons and contrasts between the Movie "Smoke Signals" and the story "This is what it Means to say Phoenix, Arizona"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
456 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparisons and contrasts between the Movie "Smoke Signals" and the story "This is what it Means to say Phoenix, Arizona"
Compare & Contrast of Smoke Signals and This is what it means to Say Phoenix, Arizona

The stories of Smoke Signals and “This is What it Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” are built around the same narrative with a few dissimilarities here and there. Smoke Signals is the film version based from the short story “This is What it Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona.” Throughout the duration of the film there are recognizably a few alterations as compared with the short story; however, there are still a lot of similarities as well. An example of contrast would be the house fire scene in the beginning of the film, and comparisons being the overall journey of Victor and Thomas heading towards Phoenix. Inclusively, the short story and the film have a correspondent plot: two Native Americans on a prodigious and agonizing journey to Phoenix, Arizona in search of the ashes of Victor’s deceased father. Both the film and short story portray familiar characterization, such as Victor’s and Thomas’ dreadful memories from their childhood which primarily affect their personalities. Also, both show the uncooperative relationship between Victor and Thomas; for example, the rude behavior Victor displays towards Thomas for the remainder of the film and short story. The theme of family and loyalty is portrayed in a complicated manner, however becomes ultimately evident in between the falling action and conclusion. Symbolically, the excruciating journey represents the loyalty it entails between the two Native Americans in order to embark in such a difficult voyage together, and in due course their friendship is found in the ruins of everything.
The film didn’t necessarily alter the overall plot from the short story, but more so just accumulated on to the story while possessing an identical storyline. One of the more significant differences presented was the house fire scene shown in the beginning of the film, which was a flashback from when Victor and Thomas were mere infants. Thomas’

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Despite plenty of pleasant descriptions—White’s father comically rolling over in a canoe, the reverence for the silent lake in the early morning, the young waitresses, the walk to the farmhouse for dinner, the pleasures of boating and fishing, the taste of soda, the laughter of other campers clowning around in the rain—little hints of melancholy and uncertainty emerge as the essay develops, and lead toward the chill of death at the end.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The stories are frequently about or concerning Victors father. The stories hit a nerve for Victor, and I don't think Thomas notices it. Victor is angry and resentful of his father, for being a terrible parent and for leaving him and his mother. He is also jealous of Thomas because Thomas has better memories of his father than he dose. He thinks that his father treated Thomas better, the way he should have done his own son. All of these sort of under running problems are spelled out in the flashbacks.…

    • 326 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In both the movie and the story, Victor’s father leaves and in the film Victor seems to resent his father for doing so, more so than in Alexie’s short story. In Eyre’s film Thomas asks Victor about his father and Victor responds with,” What about him” (Smoke). Victor says this not only in front of Thomas, but a couple of his friends and when he says that he just smiles and shakes his head. This shows that Victor does not care about his dad that much because he made his statement in a sarcastic tone of voice. Through out the short story Victor refers to his father as dad and father, where as in the movie Victor only refers to his father as father. This shows that Victor was really upset with his dad in the movie for leaving, but it is hard to determine how mad Victor was at his dad in the short story. Victor’s feelings for his father in the short story remain hard to determine throughout the story, but in the movie Victor shows that he forgives his dad toward the end. That is shown after Victor and Thomas get out of the Police Station when Victor tells Thomas,” Let me hold Dad” (Smoke).…

    • 685 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This helps to show how each of these characters differ. The two points of view also run parallel to each other, which exemplifies how the two are very similar, and have faced many of the same issues in life. This memoir is used to show how two people can be of different races, ages, and genders, but also deal with the same things in life, and embrace the life they live however odd it may…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Smoke Signals is a movie based on the book The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven. The film begins when infants, Thomas Builds-the-Fire and Victor Joseph, were saved from a house fire in the middle of the night on Fourth of July. Victor’s dad, Arnold Joseph, was the hero that saved the boys. His dad threw Thomas from the window of the burning building. Eventually, his wife kicked him out of the house, where he then moved to Phoenix, Arizona. Years after he left, Victor hears of his father’s death and needs to find a way to get to Phoenix to retrieve his fathers ashes. For financial reasons, his only option is to take…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first difference between the movie and novel is directly at the beginning. While the novel tells us that there is a guest house where a few couples are staying, the movie shows a difference scene. In the movie, there are people sitting on the beach drinking. While drinking, the man notices a woman, named Chrissie, who he approaches. She then takes off running down the beach. The man follows after her, both yelling at each other and undressing as they run, and they arrive at the shore. The girl dives in and yells for the man to join her while she continues swimming. While he is still undressing, he passes out on the shore. This results in him being safe from what is about to occur. Still waiting on the man, Chrissie is attacked and killed by the shark. Now, in the novel, this scene appears to be much different. The man and Chrissie both walk out of a guest house and lay on the beach. Chrissie decides she wants to go for a swim, trying to tempt the man into going with her, but he refuses and falls asleep. She slowly wades out, calling one last time for the man to join her, who ignores due to the fact that he is asleep. While Chrissie is in the water, the shark attacks her and she is killed. This is where the next difference comes in.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main concepts this short story depicts is perseverance and strength in hardship. Phoenix Jackson displays bold courage, fortitude, and persistence as she faces the extensive trail into town. She comes across a strong hunter which could be highly dangerous as the setting is directly at the end of the Civil War. Jackson…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the film there is flashback to the past, where Arnold was a drunken father but at the same time a loving father although he didn´t know how to express it very good. In this movie especially we can see details of a desperately missed past where Victor had a father. This comes when a fire killed Thomas´s family. The good moments comes when they arrive to Arizona to meet…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The characterization of the main characters differs between each of the texts. In Branagh’s appropriation, he tries to illustrate both the good and evil qualities in each of the characters and give purpose to Victor’s actions. In the film, although being on a quest for knowledge and power Victor is very passionate and romantic; however Branagh stays true to the novel by making him sometimes selfish, ignorant and curious. Through characterization both Branagh and Shelly comment on the theme of man playing god. They show…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The difference between the film and the novel is that Nathaniel never got to meet Yo-Yo Ma. While reading the novel I wanted to see what actor would play Yo-Yo Ma. It was a disappointment to see that they did not play the scene where Nathaniel sees Yo-Yo Ma for the first time since…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There were a few changes that were made to make a smooth transition from stage to film, but there were many things that stayed the same. The plot of both versions was basically the same. The play and film centers on Father Flynn, Sister James, and Sister Aloysius. Sister Aloysius is convinced that Father Flynn has acted inappropriately around the male students at the school, and Sister James is the naïve young teacher that wants to see the best in everyone and tries her hardest to believe that the allegations are not true. The plot of both stories shows how Sister Aloysius tries to find out whether or not Father Flynn has been inappropriate with one boy in particular, Donald Muller, who also happens to be the only black student at the school.…

    • 1761 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For starters, the major differences. The biggest difference in the short story and the movie, was the relationship between Charlie and Miss Kinnian. In the short story, they have a friendly teacher-student relationship. Charlie, as he is growing smarter, realizes that he is in love with Miss Kinnian. In the movie, Charlie thinks she is the smartest teacher in the world. After Charlie has the operation, he…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The characters had been very much different. From the novel and to the movie, they had not even included the character under the name of Reuven. As well as, Rivka was introduced at the beginning instead of when they had met her at the camp in the novel. As well as, in the movie, the rabbi spoke out much more than in the novel. In the novel, the rabbi faded out of the novel as it went on. The plot from the novel and the movie was very different too. In the novel, the people caught escaping were shot, yet in the movie they were hung. In the movie, they had a Seder in the camp yet in the novel, they did not. As well as, in the movie, they had put pellets into the chamber to kill people, yet they didn't do that in the novel. They had other smaller details included that were different, yet they did not have any impact on the story, such as how they had to dig instead of doing their special jobs like in the…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Legends of the Fall

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The film focuses on the lives and loves of an early 20th century family who live in the mountains of Montana. It is narrated by Decker, an Indian man who lived with, and was practically a part of the family. He lives with the family, along with his wife and daughter Isabelle Too, who is named after the departed Mrs Ludlow.…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many similarities and differences between the novel and the movie. Both capture the feeling of the new generation of the rich in the 1920’s. The novel breaks everything down into a lot more detail than the movie. The movie just gives the vast over watch of the novel with some differences. You can see the change in setting, character traits, and the difference in the parties.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays