by Aristotle, a Greek philosopher, or those of Arthur Miller
who is a twentieth century playwright. A tragedy, in Aristotle's
view, usually concerns the fall of an individual whose character is
good but not perfect and his misfortunes are brought about by the
tragic flaw. This flaw is the part of the character that personifies
him as being tragic. Miller uses this definition of a tragedy but
also broadens it including the common man. All of these
characteristics are seen in the plays Julius Caesar, Death of a
Salesman, and Oedipus Rex.
Although the title of the play Julius Caesar focuses on
Caesar, the play itself is really based on Brutus. 'Brutus had
rather be a villager than to repute himself a son of Rome.'(Act I,
scene II, line 172). This was said by Brutus after Cassius told him
how Caesar had become a towering figure over Rome and how
Caesar controls Rome. Notice the good in Brutus, and the
extremes he will go to in order to protect democracy in Rome
even if it means killing the one he loves, Caesar. Brutus possesses
one of the most tragic flaws. He is too nice of a person and
therefore he gets taken advantage of. He lets Cassius persuade
him into killing Caesar for the good of Rome. Because he does
for others more than himself he makes a fatal mistake, he lets
Antony live. Brutus says to the conspirators, 'For Antony is but a
limb of Caesar'(Act II scene I line 165) meaning that if Caesar is
killed Antony will die off too. Brutus clearly does not regard
Antony as being a threat, but little does Brutus know that
Antony will stir up the town to seek revenge after the
assassination of Caesar. This mistake will cost him his own life.
When he dies he becomes a prime example of tragedy because not
only did he bring about his own death he dies by his own hand.
In Death of a Salesman, Willy Lowman's tragic flaw is that
he is a dreamer who is unable to face the realities of
a modern day society. Willy builds his whole life around the
philosophy that if a person is well liked and good looking then
he will be successful. Willy says to Biff , 'I thank Almighty God
that you are both are built like Adonises.'(Act I page 33) Later,
Willy makes the comment, 'Be liked and you will never
want.'(Act I page 33) His need to be well liked is so strong that
he often lies about his success; at times he even believes his own
lies. Willy always thinks his sons will always be successful
because they are good looking and good at sports, but in reality
they are failures just like Willy. At the end when Biff tries to tell
Willy that he is just a commoner and that he cannot live up to his
father's expectations, that they are 'a dime a dozen.' Willy thinks
he is just saying this to spite him. Willy says, 'I am not a dime a
dozen! I am Willy Loman and you are Biff Loman!'(act II page
132). After this Willy decides to commit suicide so Biff can get
the twenty thousand dollar insurance money and he will finally
make something of himself. 'He had the wrong dreams'(requiem
page 138) states Biff at Willy's funeral, but Charley, Willy's best
friend, says 'A salesman is got to dream, boy. It comes with the
territory.'(requiem page 138) Unfortunately, Willy never realized
that his dreams and values were flawed and he died for it.
In Oedipus Rex Oedipus has a flaw that is unavoidable and
also uncontrollable. His flaw is fate. The plot juxtaposes
Oedipus's ignorance to his own identity with his tragic despair as
he learns that he has killed his father and married his mother.
Oedipus refuses to believe all of the prophecies until his prophet
finally discloses the truth. He knows that he is the one who
killed his father because he is the one who murdered Laius who
in fact turned out to be his father that tried to get rid of him.
After his wife, Jocasta, finds out that Oedipus knows the truth she
commits suicide. 'How could I bear to see when all my sight was
horror everywhere?'(ode 4 line 1289) This is said after Oedipus
punishes himself by digging his eyes out. Oedipus then wanders
the land a beggar guided by his daughter, Antigone.
Clearly, then, all of these stories represent a great example
of tragedy. They follow the rules preset by Aristotle and also the
rules of Arthur Miller. We have sympathy for the protagonist in
each play but at the same time we know that their down fall is
brought about by their own ignorance. Even though the character
is tragic he is also a great man because they suffer for the well
being of others.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the book “The Crucible”, by Arthur Miller, Deputy Danforth is more to blame for the trials continuation than Abigail Williams because he always believed whoever had been accused a witch, refused any evidence showing that the accused were innocent, and was more concerned with the court’s image than justice being served.…
- 352 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The fabliaux, "The Reeve 's Tale" and "The Miller 's Tale" of Geoffrey Chaucer 's The Canterbury Tales, express similar characteristics yet simultaneously express differences. "The Reeve 's Tale" is far more perverse than "The Miller 's Tale", which is expressed as a story of slapstick humor and ignorance. Both "The Reeve 's Tale" and "The Miller 's Tale" coincide on the topic of deception. Both of these tales express the theme of revenge. "The Reeve 's Tale" concentrates on the theme of sin more than "The Miller 's Tale" does. Both "The Reeve 's Tale" and "The Miller 's Tale" possess the common topic of lust. Both these fabliaux manifest their narrator 's motive for reciting these tales. Nevertheless, the clear victor between the conflict…
- 1244 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Finally in end Brutus died thinking that his part in the assassination of Caesar was worth something, he also died thinking that people in Rome did not like Caesar but in reality they really did. Brutus was a tragic hero because he was willing to give it all for his country and in the end even gave his life and his best friends life thinking that it was for the better of Rome. Brutus sacrifice is even more tragic because in history, the Roman leaders after Caesar were nowhere as good as he was and after him Rome’s glory days were…
- 792 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In The Crucible by Arthur Miller, John Proctor is referred as a tragic hero. While written to the audience that is reading the play Miller uses the fatal flaw of Proctors to show how he is a tragic hero. The purpose is to recognize how Proctor is the tragic hero in this play. Miller relies on past events of Salem Witch Trials to create the Crucible. The Author esteemed playwright, expresses his own frustration with the US legal system which has transcended since our country beginnings. Using the character John Proctor provides us a powerful tone shift from prideful to shameful in order to create the tragic hero.…
- 302 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Aristotle was not only a scientific genius, but someone who carved the path for the way we depict plays and furthermore, how we write them. Aristotle made it a mission to read the plays of his era, while doing so he discovered many similarities among them, creating a tragedy. A tragedy is a form of drama that is composed of three basic parts: values, characters, and a conclusion. A value is what will determine the fate of the tragic character in the play, usually the value is represented by a supernatural power. While the character has to display certain characteristics like nobility either by birth or action, it is most noted for the characters downfall. The downfall occurs either by limitation of knowledge or by a tragic flaw within…
- 1043 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
When we are born, the nature intent of humans is to feel like they are in control of themselves and where their decisions will lead them in life(confusing).We like to believe that the work of our decisions is not influenced by our fate or chances(try to connect this sentence with the previous one).However, sometimes fate cannot be changed no matter what choices we make or how hard we try to avoid our fate.On the contrary, sometimes fate(use a thesaurus to find different term for “fate”)also can(“can also”)be the work of chances in our lives(rephrase).For instance, in Oedipus Rex, Oedipus cannot change his fate no matter how hard he tries to avoid killing his father and marrying his mother. Therefore, fate is something that unavoidably befalls…
- 162 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Before the play begins, Julius Caesar wins a very important battle against his rival Pompey. This leads to a celebratory parade in Rome signifying the end of a long fight and Caesar’s emergence from battle. Not everyone sees Caesar as an ideal ruler for Rome though. In the first scene, two men express their distaste for Caesar by berating citizens and stripping statues that honor Caesar of their decorations. While they’re doing this Caesar enters Rome a hero.…
- 1238 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Society teaches us that heroes are usually superhumans. Batman, Superman, Supergirl, Elsa in Frozen and even Belle in Beauty and the Beast do heroic deeds to make the average person think they must possess superhuman powers. John Proctor, Susan Jordan and the men of Flight 93 all prove that any life could be taken by anyone at any time.…
- 330 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Okonkwo from a strict African culture and Oedipus from a Grecian society in 400 B.C. are oddly not too different from each other. Through Oedipus and Okonkwo’s downfall both represent the qualities of a tragic hero and the show their process of self-actualization. Things Fall Apart written by Chinua Achebe depicts the life of Okonkwo and the honor he has strived for in his village is quickly falling apart. In Oedipus Rex written by Sophocles is ended by complete tragedy in Oedipus knowing his fate. A tragic hero’s journey is like an ocean wave; the waves become rougher at the end of the day and calms by morning. At the ending of both Things Fall Apart and Oedipus Rex it is clear that both have achieved…
- 1227 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Homer, an ancient Greek epic poet, influenced many writers in the ancient Greek and Roman culture, particularly Virgil. Virgil, most famous for his epic poem The Aeneid demonstrates Homer’s influence through similar characters, mythology, and ideals. Homer in both his most famous works the Iliad and The Odyssey weaves poetry based on centuries worth of oral stories handed down and uses a sophisticated style of writing that is still recognized today. Although the tragic hero is defined slightly differently in modern text than ancient Greek and Roman works, Aristotle defined a tragic hero in his work Poetics as “the character between these two extremes,-that of a man who is not eminently good and just,-yet whose misfortune is brought about not by vice or depravity, but by some error or frailty. He must be one who is highly renowned and prosperous” (Aristotle). Aristotle outlines that a tragic hero must be great and virtuous yet not perfect because the character must be relatable, their downfall is partly brought on upon themselves, their punishment is not entirely deserved, and the misfortune brings about awareness in the character. Both Homer and Virgil skillfully identify their tragic hero’s, Achilles in the Iliad and Aeneas in the Aeneid, according to Aristotle’s ideals. Both Achilles and Aeneas are famed warriors during the Trojan War and both characters appear in the Iliad and the Aeneid. Achilles fought for the Greeks while Aeneas fought for the Trojans during the war. Homer’s Iliad centers on Achilles and his time during the war whereas Virgil’s the Aeneid began after the fall of Troy and the hardships Aeneas faced after his escape. Virgil and Homer’s tragic heroes have similarities and differences in their greatness and relatability, their tragic flaws brought upon themselves, and their punishment that leads to their awareness and self-discovery.…
- 1895 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The Miller is a heavyset man, who has wide facial features, and a large wart on his nose. It is stated that his nostrils a very large and full of hairs, but that they match his face and large mouth. He has a red beard and wears a blue hood with a white coat. The Miller also carries a sword and shield showing that he is ready for a fight at all times. The Miller is truly built for battle and fighting, which explains his favorite hobby, wrestling. The Miller is also described as having a hard head, this is stated when the Miller thrusts his head through a door to break it. The Miller’s outward appearance correlates with his personality and he is a perfect example for the stereotype of “all brawn and no brains.”…
- 687 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout history, audiences have been entertained by tales of tragedy and catastrophe. Though each author and every story they write puts a unique spin on the genre, the characters employed are often not too dissimilar. Whether admiring drama from ancient Greece or reading the works of the Renaissance era, most of the characters have a parallel character in existing somewhere else literature. These parallels are rarely as clear as when Othello, from Shakespeare 's play Othello, and Oedipus, from Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex, are juxtaposed. The similarities include in their societal positions as prominent and powerful men, the role they each play in their own demises and the fact that both of…
- 1067 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Ribald sexual content, humor, cheating wives, “arse” kissing, “The Millers Tale” and “The Wife of Baths Tale” have it all. However this is only 2 out of the many tales in the Canterbury Tales, by Geoffrey Chaucer. This story is about a group of 29 people who are all going on a pilgrimage to Canterbury to see the tomb of St. Tomas Beckett. In the tavern they meet in, they decide to have a competition for who can tell the best tale, and the winner will receive a free dinner. In this novel, Chaucer is trying to show how various aspects of life such as love and marriage are portrayed in the different social classes of a satire. In “The Millers Tale” and the “Wife of Baths Tale”, Chaucer shows how in two different social classes, love and marriage are shown differently. Some of the loves are based on nobility, some are forced, and some are just mutual respect for the person.…
- 624 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Brutus’ main conflict is within himself because he knows that Caesar’s murder is best for Rome, but he is concerned with the betrayal and feelings of guilt. According to Charney, “The tragedy of Brutus springs from his complete sincerity in preferring duty to Rome to his personal friendship with Caesar” (156). These feelings of Brutus show that he is not the biggest supporter of murders unless given good reasoning. For example; at the meeting of the conspirators, Cassius says that Antony should not outlive Caesar because he could be a cunning and dangerous schemer. In which of course Brutus replies “Our course will seem to bloody, Caius Cassius, / To cut the head off and hack the limbs, / Like wrath in death and envy afterwards; For Antony is but…
- 951 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“Thebes is tossed in a murdering sea,” cries out the priest towards the beginning of the play. Thebes is enwrapped in darkness, the houses are cursed, children are dying at birth, fruit is growing unhealthily, and no one can put an end to it. Creon enters with the message that the plague is a result of the fact that the murderer of Laius, the former ruler of Thebes, is in the city; he must be exiled in order for the plague to end. After hearing the news, Oedipus vows to find Laius’s murderer. Through Oedipus’s actions and responses towards the message, it is revealed that he is compelled to solve the mystery; however, it is this very compulsion that is incorporated with Oedipus’s pride and overconfidence that leads to his ultimate downfall and the destruction of his family.…
- 1664 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays