Preview

Comparison of Cultural Nationalism in Modern Korea and China in the Early 20th Century

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1656 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison of Cultural Nationalism in Modern Korea and China in the Early 20th Century
Comparison on Cultural Nationalism between Modern Korea and China in the Early 20th Century

Over the confronted, yet shared borderline, Korea and China have actively been engaged with each other in various fields of life ever since the dawn of the nations. Such frequent and constant interactions had undoubtedly brought about the civil similitude between them until nowadays. Amongst numerous cultural resemblances of Korea and China from the history, this paper focuses on how their unique, yet similar-to-each-other culture had developed particularly during the early 20th century. Both Korean and Chinese culture prospered in the process of fighting against the Japanese colonialism in 1920’s and 1930’s, and the notable sentiment underlying such cultural movements was nationalism. For the cultural nationalism during this period had lot contributed in advancing the modernization of both countries, I found it worthwhile to study further on this phenomenon of respective countries and then pinpoint similarities, as well as differences between them. As far as I have researched on this topic from the given text materials of “East Asian History and Civilization” class, the comparison could be narrowed down onto the criteria of political backgrounds that had initiated the cultural nationalism, features of the changes in educational, communicational, and consumer-habit culture of Korea and China. To start with, it is crucial to analyze the main reason why the cultural nationalism had emerged particularly in Korea and China among East Asian countries, during those specific years, from the first place. With regard to the political stimulations for the cultural mutation, both of Korean and Chinese cultural nationalism were invoked by student-led political movements, the 1919 March First and the 1919 May Fourth, respectively. However, it is important to note that Korea and China were in completely different political status, with Korea being a colony of Japan and China an

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The first half of the twentieth century in Korean history is marked by two harsh and painful experiences, the Japanese occupation between 1910 and 1945 and the Korean War of 1950 through 1953. These events rule the total of every national mind for many years. The legacy left by the colonial period is complex and filled with feeling of love, hate, guilt, and many others. The Japanese colonialists' push toward modernization brings extreme technological, and as a result social, advances, such as the building of infrastrue and the development of modern school systems. The Japanese also carry out the first modern archeological digging jobs of ancient Korean sites, royal graves, temples, ceramic kiln and preservation of their artifacts. On the flip side is the question of the colonialists' desires and their methods in these cultural efforts, and more seriously, war crimes of torture, rape, and killing. In the postcolonial period, Korea struggles with the issue of how to create an agreement between the positive developments of the colonial time in history and the unforgettable animal-like violence, embarrassment, and…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Asian American Paper

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This book explains the History of Korean immigration and the evolution of Korean assimilation in America. Moon goes into detail about the motives of immigration for Korean first generations. Moon goes further and discusses the issues of the language barrier many Koreans had when first arriving to America. He collected most of his data through questionnaire survey and case-study interviews, focusing primarily on problems such as social isolation, family tension, and the challenge of earning a livelihood. This source will be very helpful to my research because it provides a deep insight into the history of the first Koreans that arrived here in the United States and what they did in order to assimilate and succeed. Because this author received most of his information from studies and interviews, there should not be much bias, however, avoiding bias on complicated topics such as racism and prejudice is almost not possible. This should not hurt my research but provide a different voice in my paper.…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It has been argued that most of the crucial political and ideological battles of the Cultural Revolution were fought over the issue of the nature of social class structure in post-revolutionary China. What does the Cultural Revolution teach us about class structure and struggle under socialism?…

    • 3355 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Korea also had the same idea as Japan, cultural borrowing from China. They copied Buddhism, China’s art & architecture, and Confucian learning. Korea tried bureaucracy as well but they failed, having no support form nobles. Korea was soon almost re-conquered by Tang to take advantage of internal divisions, establish a tribute system instead with new…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Culture Convergence

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Culture is not a thing to be pushed on. It will converge naturally as it needed. When one country tries to persuade its culture to another, the quarrel will arise. The annexation of South Korea by Japan took place in form of ‘culture modernization and globalization’. And it also happened in entire South East Asia, Japan Imperialism pressed on their culture in the name of…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Yin and Yang of American Culture: A Paradox by Eun Y. Kim is a perspective of the American way of life by a Korean American. Kim uses the yin and yang symbol to describe the positive and negatives of American culture and how it compares to Asian culture. Kim’s exposure to American culture as a young child in Korea and immigrating to the United States while also being raised in a Korean household where Korean tradition was upheld provides a solid basis for her analysis. I have chosen five of her yang statements for discussion which I believe I have experienced being a fourth generation American but also witnessing the truth to these statements during my travels to Asia as well as to Portugal.…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Evaluating Mao and China

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Chinese history has been guided to the global economic power player that it has become today, based largely on its nationalism. A strong sense of national pride and subsequent perceived competition with the rest of the world for superiority has given birth to a ‘technological revolution’ in more recent years. One of the fundamental principles inherent of a nationalistic society is the shared sense of “all for one, one for all”, which in turn creates an ‘us versus them’ philosophy, and has been present in Chinese history for hundreds of years. Thus one can deduce that nationalism has greatly driven Chinese history.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The growth of the Korean immigrant population in the United States has undoubtedly been on the rise within the context of the past several decades. This is evidently the case as many of the major American cities now house massive Korean diasporic communities including Los Angeles, Atlanta, and Chicago (Min, 1370). The rise of these Korean communities in the United States has definite links to the history of immigration policy in the U.S. The history of Korean immigration into the United States will be an integral part to my research of Korean immigrants in the United States. Essentially, however, the Korean diaspora is at the core of my research in this paper. Initially, I will discuss different topics that generalize the notion of diaspora.…

    • 3704 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    While both groups of people experience a sense of nationalism and patriotism, they sit on opposing sides due to the circumstances of the past. Because he spent the next 38 years living in the same region in China, 朱学’s negative ideas towards Japanese people were reinforced by the people around him, who had been similarly victimized by the invading soldiers. “As I grew up, my friends and neighbors frequently talked about how savage the Japanese people were,” my grandfather told me. Additionally, his wife and my grandmother had also suffered similar atrocities, almost perishing at the age of 2 as a result of the invading troops. This reinforces his social identity as a patriot, as his interactions with the people around him polarize his views further and cements this patriotic identity. Most outsiders would classify both Japanese people and Chinese people as “yellow” and of similar physical traits, but according to Jenkins, “sometimes a changed or strange situation makes the difference” (3). This relates to the Second Sino-Japanese War, which affected the mindsets of both groups of people and created a set racial divide. This shows that high nationalism can create conflicts that result in an “us versus them” mentality, instead of an international harmony between the two Asian…

    • 1986 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Between the time of 600 and 1450, Japan and Korea had adopted much of China’s culture. A similarity between the influence of Chinese culture on both Japan and Korea include of the resistance political domination of China. On the other hand, tha difference between the two regions is that Japan was not forced into integrating Chinese culture unlike…

    • 59 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    History 251: China: Nationalism and Communist Revolution CHRONOLOGY Section II of course 1895-98 Looting of China. Division into “spheres of influence” of foreign powers. 1898 The Hundred Days of Reform. 1900 Boxer Rebellion. 1905 SUN YAT-SEN creates the Nationalist Party TONGMENGHUI (later became the GUOMINDANG). 1911-12 Revolution overthrows Manchu dynasty and establishes the Chinese Republic. 1913 The warlord YUAN SHIKAI comes to power, outlawing the Guomindang. 1916-c.1927 Politics in China dominated by various regional WARLORDS. 1919 May 4th student demonstration protesting against the Versailles Conference. Also indicative of a new cultural movement among sections of the Chinese intelligentsia. Section III of course 1921 Formation of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). The Communist International (COMINTERN) plays important role. 1924-1927 First United Front between the Guomindang, (headed by CHIANG KAI-SHEK after 1926) and the CCP. 1927-1934 Exile and valuable practical experience for Chinese communists such as Mao Zedong in rural areas, for example with the formation of the JIANGXI Soviet . 1934-35 LONG MARCH and a new base in North-West China, in YANAN. 1937-46 Second United Front between the CCP and the Guomindang. Jockeying for position between the two even as they “cooperate” against the Japanese invasion. 1946-49 Civil War and Communist victory. 1949 Formation of the People’s Republic of China. THEMES Section II of course Nationalism in China: Anti-Manchu nationalism: the result of Manchu oppression of other nationalities. Manchu state-sponsored nationalism: self-strengthening, modern government systems, encouragement of Chinese industry. Popular nationalism: Boxers opposed foreign domination resulting in unemployment, increased financial and social demands of government in crisis Presence of predatory foreign powers: western as well as Japanese oppression contribute to growth of nationalism. Cultural nationalism: May 4th Movement, revising Confucianism…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Dallas was launched to Europe in the 1980s. Before it was launched to Europe, the ideal mission for European television was has generally been perceived as educational. According to Ang’s essay, “(Not) Coming to Terms With Dallas, most European critics believed that television should be a “window on the world” for the mass audience, and should enhance people’s awareness of their duties as national citizens. Yet, Dallas, being an American commercial television soap opera, is totally different from the European critics’ notion of “quality programs”. Today, many people believe that Dallas has led to the commercialization of European television, which is frequently cited as a metaphor for the decline of classical European culture. Similarly, the intrusion of the Japanese culture to the Chinese culture since the early 90s also serves as the primary reason of the loss of patriotism among many Chinese people.…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Chinese influence was nowhere else so long nor so profound as in Korea (even though rule of Vietnam lasted much longer). Of course geography played a role in this connection because China and Korea are, well, connected. Koreans are ethnically distinct, however, a fact that led indigenous Korean rulers to establish dynasties with a will to keeping their peninsula secure. Koreans originated out of eastern Siberia and Manchuria rather than out of Mongolia or Asia Minor making them have more in common, ethnically, with American Indians than with the…

    • 2401 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    HY2229

    • 866 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Scholars have pointed out that in many parts of Asia and Africa before the 19th century, the idea of the ‘nation’ and ‘national consciousness’ remains at best very little understood or non-existent, particularly in tribal or feudal societies, where territorial borders were porous and many groups differentiated by race, language, religion, and culture coexisted within a single territorial space.…

    • 866 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Korean wave (Hallyu) was coined in China in mid-1999 by Beijing journalists surprised by the fast growing popularity of South Koreans and South Korean goods in China.” However, the phenomenon of Korean wave flows into East Asia especially China during the early twenty-first century. Korean wave covers the craze for South Korean music, TV dramas, pop stars, but also for fashion styles, cosmetics and electronics. There are many reasons causing Korean wave being a popular mass culture in China. Korean wave spread so successful because of the Confucian themes that East Asian cultures are more familiar with, typically dealing with traditional issues such as family, love, and filial piety. China in particular share a similar history with Korea. Furthermore, Korean government propagates their modernization Korean wave through media power. Extensively promoting Korean culture transnational makes it another reason Chinese suddenly start engaging in Korean cultures. As two countries both strongly pay attention to the international culture exchange, people are more likely try to understand and accept it. The effect Korean wave has made on Chinese people is enormous. Daily life like watching dramas becomes popular and the story lines are discussed among youths and housewives. Due to the drama contains everything like music, fashion styles, pop stars and foods. Chinese people start imitating both the way of dressing, make-up putting. Korean restaurants also sprang up quickly like mushrooms. Korean language is also being chosen as students’ third language in order to understand more about the culture. Chinese start travelling to the filming location in Korea so as to enjoy Korean wave natively and it also helps Korean to obtaining another way of economy profit making. Korean traditional ethnics and education view also influenced Chinese people’s life in many ways. Despite those advantages, Korean wave does challenge the Chinese its own culture. Less attention is paid on Chinese…

    • 2090 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays