Preview

Comparing Two Poems

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1252 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Two Poems
We are all torn between wanting to stand apart and wanting to fit in. How is this conflict explored in 2 poems and one text? (800 words)

An Amerian psychiatrist, William Glasser, once said: “We are driven by five genetic needs: survival, love and belonging, power, freedom and fun.” As humans, the impulse to search for acceptance is present in our nature; however we are also driven by our desire to be unique. It is this conflict between wanting to stand apart and wanting to fit in that shapes our identities, and distinguishes us as a distinct species in the world. These ideas of acceptance and alienation are explored in the poems Feliks Skrzynecki and Postcard, and Randa Abedel-Fattah’s feature article Prejudice is alive and well in the legal …show more content…
The idea of conflict is introduced immediately by the postcard that “haunts me.” The use of such a strong verb accentuates his response to this postcard as it differs from the typical feelings of excitement and happiness associated with a postcard. Skrzynecki’s bland, generic description of “Red buses on a bridge…High-rise flats and something…” mirrors his unemotional response to the picture- a stark contrast to his parents who would be proud or speak of their beloved homeland. As in Feliks Skrzynecki, the poet once again emphasises his parents and himself as products of different cultures. The poem is a reflection of the confusion in his mind: he appears indifferent yet he cannot deny the connection he seems to share with the city. The poet personifies the city to demonstrate its importance to its people. Although it has been destroyed and massacred, it remains unchanged and lives on in the memories of the Polish migrants, having “survived in the minds of a dying generation half a world away.” This concept is also portrayed with Feliks and his friends in Feliks Skrzynecki. Peter Skrzynecki does not have these associations with the city and hence chooses to reject it, as seen when he directly addresses it “For the moment, I repeat, I never knew you, let me be.” The use of …show more content…
Her title Prejudice is alive and well in the legal profession is sarcastically informative, but also slightly annoyed in order to clearly display her stand in this case. The words ‘alive and well’ connote that not only does prejudice exist, it is flourishing and perhaps even increasing. Like Skrzynecki, the theme of cultural belonging is central to Abdel-Fattah’s argument. Muslim women who wear the hijab as a symbol of their cultural identity are marginalised in Western society- they want to fit in but also hope to be identified by their culture. “Intelligent, dynamic, capable lawyer one minute. Oppressed, passive dimwit the next.” Cynicism is used to convey the author’s disapproval and comments on the superficial nature of society in stereotyping. By opening with an anecdote concerning her friend, the author effectively structures her article to move from the specific to the general and simultaneously adds authenticity to support her opinion. As the article progresses, the tone becomes more sombre and reveals the severity of this issue. The author achieves this by using more sophisticated language. Randa Abdel-Fattah discusses how society can play a part in a person’s fight to balance conformity and
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Peter Skrzynecki - Feliks Skrzynecki analysis essay
    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Peter Skrzynecki - Feliks Skrzynecki analysis essay

    Skrzynecki’s poem Feliks Skrzynecki explores the concept of belonging in which, the central character Feliks is portrayed as a man who didn’t belong to the pro-dominant ‘civilised’ Australia, (Gallic war reference) achieves a sense of belonging when he establishes a connection to his garden. As an immigrant, Feliks suffered barriers to fitting in to the new society, as highlighted by the bigotry attitude given off by the colourless; non individual – a ‘crew-cut, grey haired department clerk.’ The effective use of ‘crew-cut’ is a connotation that describes the speaker’s perspective of their new, adopted society in which the department clerk was seen as a militaristic conformist, who was robbed of his individuality; someone who sees the world simply – in black and white. Feliks had a powerful, almost familial affinity towards his homeland, and as a result refused to accept Australian culture. He didn’t “ever attempt to learn English.” Feliks chose to be an individual and conform to his own society which is enforced by the speaker’s use of the allusion to a popular saying, ‘[his father] kept pace only with the Joneses of his own mind’s making’. This indicates both; his father’s rejection of status-orientated existence and his self-determination and individual standards. He refused to conform to the society of the Australians, as a result of his affiliation to his homeland. However, to counter the struggle of not belonging, Feliks had established his own social agenda, and obtained solace in the…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Compare Migrant Hostel and 10 Mary Street
    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Compare Migrant Hostel and 10 Mary Street

    “Migrant Hostel” describes richly the very early and hostile stages of the migrant journey, and is mostly associated with the feelings isolation and desolation as the migrants were confronted with the government’s systematic approach of accommodation known as ‘hostels’. In the very first stanza, Skrzynecki, through imagery, puts emphasis on the large numbers of refugees arriving from Europe “Arrivals of newcomers/ in busloads from the station/ sudden departures from adjoining blocks”. It shows the migrants lack of belonging, where they have no control over their fate. The next stanza is juxtaposing two opposing ideas, the mention of “nationalities” shows some sense of belonging, however this idea is replaced by the quote “partitioned off at night”, conveying that the migrants are finding it difficult to let go off their own ways. The quotes “like a homecoming pigeon” and “we lived like birds of passage” emphasises the temporariness of their existence here, like the temporariness of migrating birds waiting for the changes in season to fly away. Unlike birds, however, they are “unaware of the season” and are completely confused by their situation. In the concluding stanza, images of separation and isolation are repeated, “A barrier at the main gate/ sealed off the highway”, the “gate” symbolising their journey of belonging being closed to them, separating them from the rest of the world. The…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    peter skrzyneck
    • 325 Words
    • 1 Page

    peter skrzyneck

    Peter and his father Feliks Skrzynecki have a contrasting experience of belonging to a new land. Through this poem we get to know about as much about the son as the father. The relationship appears to be a wholesome one of mutual respect and friendship as skrzynecki uses formal language .His father wants him to integrate with the Australian culture and his traditions of don’t forget where you come from. Skrzynecki’s poetry and it is there the fractured identity problems originate. While embracing his new country, he yearns to cling to his parents values. But also has to reflect on his culture and the new society facing difficulties of cultural and language barrier that will create a huge distance in their relationship .``Watched me pegging my tents further and further south of Hadrian’s Wall.’’ The use of the metaphors of a tent , a piece of temporary accommodation. It’s an indication of the poets own uncertainties about his place.…

    • 325 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Peter Skrzynecki - Belonging
    • 975 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Peter Skrzynecki - Belonging

    Skrzynecki uses the displacement of European migrants, in particular Polish migrants, to demonstrate how a personal connection to one’s homeland and society at a time of insecurity and discomfort can form a sense of belonging with others. As with many migrants the Skrzynecki family was forced to flee their beloved Poland for personal safety at a time of war. “Migrant hostel”, through the use of simile, demonstrates how those of similar culture band together in times of need to form a sense of belonging to each other as a community. “Nationalities sought / Each other out instinctively- / Like a homing pigeon” indicates a sense of cultural identity from a previous time allowed for the migrants to connect and form a sense of belonging and community in such an unfamiliar place. A different sense of belonging between the immigrants is highlighted in the juxtaposition “To pass in and out of lives / That had only begun / Or were dying” which finishes the poem in a suitably depressing tone because for the migrants, there is no sense of connectedness to the Australian society and the sense of impermanence only exacerbates this feeling.…

    • 975 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Peter Skryznecki Analysis
    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Peter Skryznecki Analysis

    ‘Post Card’ mentions Warsaw, a place which is a part of Peter Skryznecki’s parents past rather than his own. ‘Warsaw, Old Town, I never knew you’ is a line in the poem which is evidence to the feelings of disillusionment, Peter Skryznecki feeling this past is not his and therefore he does not belong to it. The line, ‘I repeat I never knew you’ is continuously used in repetition to strengthen this feeling even further. The poem ‘In the Fold Museum’ ironically compliments ‘Post Card’ as it relates to Peter Skryznecki not feeling as if his past lies in the eyes of Australia, the place he was breed, and therefore what past he feels he belongs to is unknown. It is evident of his feelings towards the Australian heritage through the line ‘To remind me of a past that isn’t mine,’ as well as the line ‘would you please sign the visitor’s book’. The first quotation is straightforward mentioning plainly the Australian heritage is not his, although the second quotation uses a creative play of words. There is literally a physical visitors book which he was asked to sign upon leaving the museum, although ironically the visitors book emphasis’s Skryznecki’s feelings towards the Australian heritage he feels he is only a ‘visitor’ in the culture and therefore does not entirely belong to it. Both these poems hold feelings of not belonging to a past culture, these feelings escalate and allow Skryznecki to feel a lost sense of belonging in his present. It can be said that Skryznecki was searching for his past which he felt he belonged to, as he was looking into the folk museum at Australian past, and reading into the post card of the polish past. This search of belonging, which can come from a past, is a part of human nature, something which if missing, can create an escalade of confusion about where they belong in the present. Once again from…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Immigrant Chronicle Skrzynecki Analysis
    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Immigrant Chronicle Skrzynecki Analysis

    Although the very first line of the poem, “my gentle father” shows a sign of acceptance and admiration of his father, Skrzynecki’s overall statement shows resentment, dissatisfaction and alienation, “Watched me pegging my tents further and further south of Hadrians Wall”, Hadrians Wall used as a symbol comparing the differences of his culture and heritage with his father. Likewise the poem ’Migrant hostel’ was written in Parkes, 1949-51, which happened to be during the time of ‘White Australia’ policy. The fact Skrzynecki wrote this poem in ‘Parkes’ he was only further alienating him from where he is and it creates a barrier to society which can damage him emotionally. The first stanza Skrzynecki expresses isolation, dehumanisation, uncertainty and curiosity. That was the environment Skrzynecki lived in for two years. “Like a homing pigeon” Skrzynecki lived in the chaotic hostel crossing paths with the people he shared a room with. The hostel became a place for everyone to rest which formed a sense of belonging as the reason why they are there together was driven “By memories of hunger and…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Belonging - Peter Skyznecki
    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Belonging - Peter Skyznecki

    As seen in Feliks Skrzynecki, the generational gap is the ultimate reason Peter Skrzynecki’s cultural belonging is not established to the same extent as his father’s. The poem communicates the idea that experience and memory are two fundamental aspects that allows one to connect to place, a quality embodied by Feliks who served “five years of forced labour in Germany.” The historical allusion gives insight into the devoted nature of Feliks, in which his military commitment to Poland has instilled a timeless attachment to his country. This cultural connection echoes into his present life in Australia, manifested physically through the garden, of which he loved “like an only child.” The simile humanises the garden to highlight the emotional bond that links Feliks to his home, perceived as a sanctuary that preserves his memory of Poland.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Rabbit Proof Fence & Peter Skyznecki Belonging
    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Rabbit Proof Fence & Peter Skyznecki Belonging

    Polish friends in “Feliks Skrzynecki” and his rejection of Warsaw in “Postcard,” and ___________(the related text). Yet the texts differ in their portrayal of the idea that attitudes towards belonging may be modified over time. While the persona in “Feliks Skrzynecki” and “Postcard” ambiguously changes his attitudes towards his Polish heritage, Molly and Mr Neville do not change their attitudes in Rabbit Proof Fence. Each text powerfully explores the significance of culture to a sense of belonging through a variety of techniques.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Feliks Skrzynecki Analysis
    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Feliks Skrzynecki Analysis

    Feliks Skrzynecki is an individual physical and cultural journey experienced by Felik’s and narrated by Peter Skrzynecki. It seems Felix Skrzynecki never was culturally accepted in Australia, except by other immigrants, “Did your father ever attempt to learn English?” Despite this, Felix Skrzynecki is at peace, he made the best of his journey and finds contentment in the simple…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    How is the concept of Belonging represented in Peter Skrzynecki's poetry? - Feliks Skrzynecki, 10 Mary Street and St Patrick's College
    • 1866 Words
    • 5 Pages

    How is the concept of Belonging represented in Peter Skrzynecki's poetry? - Feliks Skrzynecki, 10 Mary Street and St Patrick's College

    The poem 'Feliks Skrzynecki ' tells us of Peter 's father, his life, and his clear sense of belonging. It explores the concepts of familial, cultural and self-belonging, and reveals the regretful feelings of Peter, in relation to his alienation, his family 's migration and the filial bond with his father. The clear and possibly most significant message of the poem is that belonging comes from within, and requires an accepting and peaceful attitude. These concepts are expressed through the use of poetic devices and language techniques, which show the differences between the attitudes of father and son. The admiration Peter has for his father is evident in the first line -"My gentle father." The use of the word 'gentle ' introduces Feliks as a kind, peaceful man, and the possessive pronoun 'my ' can suggest a sense of ownership or the yearning to be associated with Feliks. The father 's independence and emotional self-sufficiency is evident in the first stanza - "Kept pace only with the Joneses of his own mind 's making". The reference to 'The Joneses ' is important to consider, as it not only refers to mainstream society, but Australian mainstream society. It shows that…

    • 1866 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    We All Stive to Belong Essay
    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages

    We All Stive to Belong Essay

    Peter Skrzynecki clearly illustrates how some individuals resist the need to belong to gain independence in developing their own sense of identity. This is strongly showcased in ‘Feliks Skrzynecki’ through the composer’s tone of admiration towards his father in the line ‘kept pace only with the Joneses Of his own mind’s making’. This is a metaphor for the influences the Skrzyneckis were subjected to in Australian society, like attaining greater social status. It shows that Feliks was a strong and independent character who was driven by his own personal goals and did not have an interest in fitting in with the neighbours or assimilating into Australia and chose to hold onto his Polish traditions. His own sense of belonging is also embedded in the care and attention he provides in his garden which is evident in the simile ‘loved his garden like an only child’. This suggests that Feliks strives to create a sense of belonging for himself. Reinforcement is made by the hyperbole of sweeping his garden ‘Ten times around the world’, as it emphasises the time and effort he puts in the garden which ultimately allows him to belong to himself, a…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Belonging Essay
    • 2848 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Belonging Essay

    In these poems, Skrzynecki focuses on the theme of not belonging. In Migrant Hostel it’s particularly apparent, as he speaks about his family’s initial experience as migrants. The entire poem conveys a sense of isolation and dislocation on the part of the immigrants during this time. The mood of the poem is a dark, negative one, his description of it resembling a prison; Skrzynecki’s effusive use of imagery allows his responders to effectively depict this particular setting – “No one kept count of all the comings and goings-arrivals of new comers in…

    • 2848 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Feliks Skrzynecki Essay
    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Feliks Skrzynecki Essay

    An individuals upbringing fabricates their social and cultural expectations which inevitably influences their ability to belong. The poem Feliks Skrzynecki, composed by Peter Skrzynecki depicts a nostalgic yet perplexedly negative description of the writers father. The readers are taken on a journey from Peters child-like admiration for his father to the pairs developing detachment throughout the poem.…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Different People Have Different Perceptions of Belonging Speech
    • 2039 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Different People Have Different Perceptions of Belonging Speech

    Through out Peter Skrzynecki’s poem ‘Feliks Skrzynecki’ we explore Peter Skrzynecki’s perception of his relationship between him and his father, and the issues of adapting to the new Australian society and migrating from an old European culture as well as contrasting experiences of belonging and not belonging. In the poem Peter shows use the gap that widens between father and son as Peter matures “at thirteen”. Also the gap between Felik’s Polish culture and the new society of which Peter is becoming a part of. Feliks Skrzynecki is content in the environment he has created for himself, which depends greatly on his Polish heritage. Peter is not as much secure. He reflects that his father is “happy as I have never been”.…

    • 2039 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Feliks Skrznecki Analysis
    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Feliks Skrznecki Analysis

    Peter Skryzenecki’s poem, ‘Feliks Skrzynecki, has two comparable contexts. It deals with the issue of generational relationships, in this case father and son and the issue of adaptation, from an old European culture into Australian society. In both cases tensions exist. The issue of generational tension pervades throughout the poem as the personas, comes to question his “gentle fathers“ values, “I often wondered how he existed” and reflects, how he is “happy as I have never”. This is furthered through the idiomatic reference, he “kept pace only with the Joneses of his own minds making” which registers Feliks’ as a simple man who is indifferent to the standards set by his neighbours. Language operates as a central motif in the poem and develops as the persona passes through the passage of time. Initially through “remnants of a language I inherited unknowingly” a link is formed between the persona and his Polish heritage. However over time he becomes increasingly disconnected from his father and assimilates into Australian society. Language again acts in the point of realisation, (“at thirteen stumbling over tenses in Caesar’s Gallic war I forgot my first Polish word”) which signifies a terrible transition within the personas world as he is losing his native tongue and leaving his fathers world behind. The metaphor as he “watched me pegging my tents further and further south of Hadrian’s Wall” denotes the persona leaving his father’s northern culture behind; the wall itself gives representation to the ever-increasing language barrier between father and son. Tragically his father becomes figuratively “like a dumb prophet” no longer able to…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More