Preview

Comparing Sheffield Scuffle's Contagion And Hotel Rwanda

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1466 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Sheffield Scuffle's Contagion And Hotel Rwanda
English poet, satirist, lawyer, and cleric John Donne once said, “No man is an island, entire of itself.” In this, Donne is expressing the innate interconnectedness of the world, which is also applicable when considering the effects of international relations. In this day and age, the world exists in a very interconnected web. What impacts one nation impacts another directly, in a matter of seconds. Much of this is due to the evolution of globalization, a factor that has been capitalized on by Hollywood. However, beyond Hollywood, the effects of the interconnectedness of the world are felt on deep and personal levels by many people. Through the movies Contagion and Hotel Rwanda, as well as the public events of the Sheffield Scuffle and a rally …show more content…
The movie starts out with Rusesabagina and his job as manager for Mille Collines, a luxury Belgian hotel in Kigali, the capital of Rwanda. In a country wrought with bribery and corruption, the tension between the Hutus and the Tutsis rises, and intrastate conflict ensues. Rusesabagina is a Hutu and has powerful connections, so he is relatively okay, but his wife is Tutsi, which puts her and their children in danger. After the tensions and conflict escalate quickly within a few days, Rusesabagina takes his wife, children, and friends from his community to the Mille Collines to keep them safe. By bribing the military, he is able to protect refugees as they arrive at the Mille Collines. As more and more refugees arrive, including over twenty Tutsi orphans, Ruesesabagina tries to continue bribing the military, get help from outside sources because the United Nations peace keeping officials are not helping, protect his family, and maintain the illusion that the Mille Collines is not, in fact, a refugee camp. After much violence and death, Rusesabagina and his family and friends make it mostly intact to a refugee camp and eventually make it to Zambia. Hotel Rwanda did an amazing job of giving an accessible look at the effects of genocide, as well as the impact of globalization. Due to globalization, people were actually aware of the problem. At the Geneva Convention, the Genocide Convention was signed, and all the signatories were legally bound to intervene in the case of genocide. This coincides with R2P, or the responsibility to protect, stating that if states do not respect or are inflicting harm on their state or citizenry, then the international community has an obligation to intervene. The United Nations did intervene in Rwanda, at least somewhat, by sending in peace keeping officials. However, when peace keeping officials

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Paul Rusesabagina saved more than 1,200 refugees in his hotel, what was the world doing to help refugees during the genocide? Nothing, the UN hardly helped at all during the entire genocide. Paul was the hotel manager for the hotel Diplomates, a high end hotel where foreigner government officials stayed. Another hotel, hotel Mille Collines, was another hotel Paul had access to. During the Rwandan genocide Paul kept over a thousand Tutsi and moderate Hutu save in the walls of the Mille Collines. He kept these people safe with words, drinks and lots of phone calls. While Paul and a few other’s tried to save people in Rwanda the whole world turned it’s back on the small country even though they knew what was going on and then decided to beat…

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hotel Rwanda Analysis

    • 2525 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Rwanda experienced the most extensive slaughter, a most evil moral crime, committed by the ruling Hutu government in this blood-filled century. The movie revolves around the protagonist Paul Rusesabagina, a house manager of a four star Hotel Milles Collines, who experienced this slaughter and acted as a superhero by sheltering more than 1100 Tutsis and Rwandans and saved their lives from the Hutu militia. The movie illustrates that there was an old historical conflict between two ethnic groups Hutus and Tutus, which planted the seeds of civil war which then molded into a massive genocide. There are a couple of scenes in the film, which shows the brief historical tribal background and the reasons of the genocide. As depicted in the opening of the film, a scene shows a conversation between a foreign journalist Jack Daglish and a local Rwandan journalist Bendict. On asking the difference between Hutus and Tutsi and the reason of their conflict, Bendict replied that Belgians were responsible for this conflict. He says, “According to the Belgian colonists, the Tutsi are taller and more elegant. It was the Belgians that created the division. They picked people, those with thinner noses lighter skins [Tutus]. The Belgians used the Tutsis to run the…

    • 2525 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    During the Rwandan genocide the will to survive of the Tutsis causes them to survive against the insurgent majority Hutu’s. After many deaths and endless torture the Tutsis, an African ethnicity in Rwanda, are seeking a safe haven in this time of genocide and will go to anyone for help just so they can survive. One person in particular Rusesabagina, a Hutu hotel manager married to a Tutsis, risks everything to help others. Lovegren, the author of this article, reveals that Rusesabagina does just that in his article about the hotel “Deserted by international Peacekeepers Rusesabagina began cashing in every favor he had ever earned, bribing the Rwandan Hutu soldiers and keeping the bloodthirsty militia outside the gates during the hundred days of slaughter.(Lovgren)” Being a Hutu hotel manager in Rwanda and harboring Tutsi fugitives including his wife and children is a death wish considering that the Hutu rebels will gladly kill everyone. Rusesabagina, the hotel manager, will do anything to keep his family and the innocent people living in his hotel alive. The Tutsis and himself both strive for survival. Likewise Valentina is a Tutsi girl who saw her parents and loved ones die at the feet of the dispassionate Hutus, leaving her with nothing but dead corpse’s, a broken body, and no shelter or food. Hundreds of Tutsi fugitives gathered around in a church that one day, one of them happened to be Valentina and her family. Her family was slaughtered but Valentina…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hotel Rwanda tackles a recent event in history where the Hutu extremists of Rwanda initiated a terrifying campaign of genocide, massacring approximately 800,000 minority Tutsi who had been given total power by the Belgian colonists, while the rest of the world looked on and did nothing. The Hutu killed the Tutsi people because they thought the Tutsi were being excessively rude to them. It is important to recognize the similarities in Night and Hotel Rwanda because if we did not keep a close watch on these prejudice actions, the world would be a very bitter and non-diverse place. Night and Hotel Rwanda are both based on true stories about genocide and share similar situations such as the Nazis and Hutus called the Jews and the Tutsis degrading names, the Jews and Tutsis had to travel in tight spaces, and watching people get badly beaten by the Nazis and the Hutus.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    English Exam Study Guide

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages

    3. How does Rusesabagina use the “Rwandan No” as a way to critique first his own culture and then the international community? What effect do Rusesabagina’s accounts of the actions of the United Nations and the United States have on your impression of either? What, if anything, do you think that the international community should do in situations similar to Rwanda?…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conflict in Rwanda was caused by many actions throughout history and resentment and anger being built up which led to one swift cruel act - genocide. The road to genocide begins with labels, or classification. The people who brought these racist ideas to a once peaceful Rwanda in the first place were Belgian colonists who believed the white race was superior. Rwanda became a colony of Belgium in 1914, and, gained independence from Belgium in the 1960s (“Year of Africa”). Following Rwanda gaining independence from Belgium began the dispute to figure out who would rule Rwanda after the Belgians left and there was no one the favor, the Tutsis. This was when the genocide broke…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a developing country, Rwandans have tried their best to prevent violence by their government offering clean food and water, clothing, and education in order to develop as a nation. The Rwandan genocide has affected the world socially, politically, and economically due to tribal inequalities and European…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Human Rights Dbq Analysis

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages

    To elaborate, despite the UN’s clear outline as to what constitutes a genocide, the UN refused to provide help to the Cambodians who were being “...executed in the hundreds of thousands…” due to the fact that they were considered “intellectuals” (Doc 4). This illustrates how the UN disregarded their proclamation of what defines a genocide, and would not react against the apparent human-right violations, as well as the mass killings caused by Pol Pot’s Khmer Rouge. Furthermore, the UN would not intervene with the Rwandan genocide, in which Hutu extremists brutally slaughtered the majority of the Tutsi population; the UN decided to “[not] reinforce the small and lightly armed UN blue helmets already in Rwanda…”(Doc 7). The withdrawal of funds and supportive equipment for the Rwandan UN soldiers goes to show that the UN refused to acknowledge the atrocious genocide that was taking place in Rwanda. It also illustrates that the United Nations acted as more of a peanut gallery by pleading ignorance than a peace group that halts genocidal…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rwandan Genocide Dbq

    • 954 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Genocide, and act that said to never occur again by the Genocide Convention, has come through time and time again. Each genocide, including the Rwandan Genocide, leaving countless numbers of men, women, and children wounded and lifeless. The imperialism brought by the Belgian empire onto Rwanda was the start of the deadly massacre. The lack of international aid from the rest of the world caused the genocide to last longer and longer eventually ending after 100 days. Finally a young population gave the people of Rwanda a little more motivation to start the horrifying mass killing. Imperialism, lack of international aid, and a young population were all factors in the start of the genocide but clearly imperialism is the most significant which without the genocide would have never started.…

    • 954 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Imperialism In Rwanda

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Rwanda, a small landlocked country in central Africa, has a long and rich history of differences and conflicts. One of the most known historic events of this region is the Rwandan Genocide which took 800,000 lives over the course of four months (Britannica). The conflict between two tribal groups, the Hutu and Tutsis, had been accumulating for decades before it finally reached its breaking point. The Rwandan genocide can be attributed to three main factors: Belgian colonial policies, tribal tensions between the Hutus and Tutsis, and the assassination of the Rwandan president. Before European colonization Rwanda was united under a total Tutsi government.…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Rwandan genocide was an atrocity that marked an age of unrest and violence in Central Africa. A nation unbalanced for years had finally imploded, leading to the mass murder of hundreds of thousands of Tutsis. This genocide was the result of multiple things, creating instability and unbalancing the relationship between the Tutsis and the Hutus. Tensions built up for decades were finally released. While many would blame Belgium, Germany, and colonization for catalyzing the genocide, there were many other factors involved, including structural oppression, the rise of the Rwandan Patriot Front, and most notably propaganda spread by the Rwandan Radio; proving that while colonialism may have played a large role…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tutsis In Rwanda Genocide

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Rwanda is located in central Africa and is not very big, you could compare it to the state of Massachusetts in the United States. It has little arable land and has no important natural resources that the United States could use. “The US arguably chose to ignore the Rwandan genocide of 1994. Rwanda was not an oil, gold or diamond rich country and from an economic perspective, the US did not have a lot to gain by intervening.” I found this quote in an article I was reading, it shows us how the United States decided to ignore the genocide due to to the fact that Rwanda had nothing of value to offer. They basically said that intervening would not benefit them in any way so they had no reason to help. President Bill Clinton's administration knew Rwanda was being engulfed by genocide in April 1994 but buried the information to justify its inaction, according to classified documents made available for the first time. The president did not think Rwanda was important enough to be thought about. Him not saying that he knew about the genocide gave him an excuse not to intervene and made it okay. He allowed the massacre to go on and acted as if he did not know, in fact senior officials privately used the word genocide within 16 days of the start of the killings, but chose not to do so publicly because the president had already decided not to step in and help. The United States let the genocide happen with no intention of helping all because Rwanda had nothing of value to give back. President Clinton was basically saying resources were worth more than human life. "Our conclusion is there is one overriding failure which explains why the UN could not stop or prevent the genocide, and that is a lack of resources and a lack of will - a lack of will to take on the commitment necessary to prevent the genocide.” The United Nations didn't want to help…

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On April 7, 1994, around 3,000 Tutsis sought safety at the base of a Belgian contingent in Kigali, “but after 10 commandos were killed by forces from Rwanda's regular army, Belgium decided to pull its troops out. The Tutsis were left with no protection, and thousand were slaughtered on April 11 on a hillside called Nyanza” (Corbett). Through this devious act, it shows the world governments arrogance and apathy surrounding Rwanda, effortlessly abandoning 3000 innocent civilians, soon to die. An example of the lack of efficiency is when “the Security Council later voted in mid-May to send 5,000 troops back to Rwanda after reports that the genocide spread. However, by the time the force returned, the genocide had long been over” (Ilibagiza). Due to lack of coordination and orderliness, it created a bubble in which the productivity in the UN was not present leading to a capsize in military force and in Tutsi population. Towards the beginning of the Rwandan Genocide “Major international leaders were ready to collaborate with the common goal of evacuating their own citizens and expatriate employees, but they refused any joint intervention to save Rwandan lives”. The response to the Rwandan genocide was quite disgraceful because those who are meant to preserve and protect human dignity put…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rwanda Genocides Today

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page

    Not many people understand that genocides are still happening today. The Rwandan genocide, although it is not happening at this moment, only occurred within the last two decades. People need to be more educated about the fact that genocides are occurring and that awareness needs to be spread. After the Rwandan genocide, the United Nations sent in troops to make sure nothing else would happen. They stepped…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Holocaust

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Hutus were towards the government and destroyed a lot of Tutsis lives that rebelled the government. Representatives of the International committee of the Red cross identified that every week of the genocide more people have been killed, in numbers of thousands of bodies. The United Nations security council decided, at the Urging of Belgium to remove peace keeping forces even while the killings continued. The UN withdrew most troops and limited actions of tiny force of 450 soldiers who stayed behind. There was a lot of International Media and Mark Doyle of the BBC was suppose to report about what was happening in Rwanda and even though it was his job, he didn’t tell the news anything. Mbaye Diagne was also a U.N Soldier and he took things into his own hands to help the tutsis. Laura Lane describes the Rwandan Genocide as evil. “She says, its not the color of their skin, not male or female and being in Rwanda, some of the things you saw were women going after their own children. It was indescribable, but you can see it in their eyes, the blackness you cannot explain.” A genocide means with intent to destroy whole or in part, a national, ethical, racial or a religious group. The tutsis were being prosecuted because of something of which they were or in which they believed in, which should not be a crime. Even when warnings were received, the United Nations ignored them. UN force commander in Rwanda, Major General Romeo Dallaire asked for protection and additional troops to prevent the planned violence from…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays