Preview

Compare and Contrast the Treatment of Femininity in Pygmalion and Medea

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1701 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast the Treatment of Femininity in Pygmalion and Medea
In this essay I will be comparing and contrasting the way in which two different authors portray femininity in their respective dramatic texts. The two works I am using are Pygmalion by Bernard Shaw and Medea by Euripides. I will be looking at how the way men and women are portrayed can affect the way we interpret the texts, and showing that femininity isn’t necessarily a trait restricted just to women.

I believe that femininity reflects expected female behaviour. There are certain traits which are believed to be typically male or female. Male traits tend to be more physical such as the fact that they are dominant, stronger whereas female traits are much softer, more emotional. In ancient Athenian society such things as ‘bravery in battle’ and ‘general competitive excellence in a public arena’(1) were considered masculine whereas women were relegated to ‘looking after the household and bringing up their children’(2). However, femininity has changed as times have changed. It reflects the acceptable social behaviour of the period. As women were seen as more equal to men, the restrictions on them lessened. So by the time Pygmalion was written in 1912 it was acceptable for women to support themselves: something that was unheard of in Medea’s time.

When Pygmalion was written the woman’s movement was well underway and women were starting to demand rights and become more independent. It was no longer assumed that women would marry just to be looked after. Men no longer automatically took the controlling role. Eliza is a prime example of this as although she is not very well off she is self sufficient as a flower-girl.

Medea on the other hand is set at a time when women were completely submissive to their husbands. Once married all of their property automatically became their husband 's. Medea has no legal political rights; not only because she is a women but also because she is an outsider. Medea’s reference to women being ‘weak and timid in most



Bibliography: The Open University, Myths and Conventions, Block 5, Milton Keynes (1998) The Open University, Resource Book 3, Milton Keynes (1998) Shaw, B (1916), Pygmalion, London, Penguin Vellacott, P (trans.) 1963 Medea, Harmondsworth, Penguin

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The speech itself highlights women's subordinate status in ancient Greek society, especially in the public eye." When Medea points out that women, especially "foreign" women, "require some knowledge of magic and other covert arts to exert influence over their husbands in the bedroom," she argues for a kind of alternative power that women can enjoy. A power that remains invisible to men and unknown by society, yet sways each with unquestionable force. Medea also supplies a method for interpreting her own character towards the end of her speech (lines 251-257): we should read her history of exile as a metaphoric exaggeration of all women's alienation; in fact, her whole predicament, past and yet to come, can be read as an allegory of women's suffering and the heights of tragedy it may unleash if left unattended. Under this model of interpretation, Medea portrays the rebellion of women against their "wretchedness." Such a transparent social allegory may seem forced or clichéd in our own contemporary setting, but in Euripides' time it would have been revolutionary, as tragedy generally spoke to the sufferings of a generic (perhaps idealized) individual, rather than a group. It would be a mistake, however,…

    • 658 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medea And Feminism Essay

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Throughout the many themes of Medea, feminism plays a large role. Medea challenges the stereotype that women are weak and disregards her role as a mother. On the contrary, feminism is a broad topic that would need a lot of expansion. In a case where the information was insufficient, there is the approach of whether Euripides’ was a proto-feminist or misogynist. Also, there is a possibility of taking the idea of revenge, being that when one betrays another, all can be tarnished.…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Medea is a woman in total control of her actions, and she is willing to kill even her own blood. She is not going to die without knowing that her ex-husband has paid for his disloyalty. Medea is angry and full of hate and she will not overestimate the price of her revenge, even if this price could be her own children. She shows this…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medea is a great example of gender oppression leading to belittlement, but we must also take into account the fact that Medea has the freedom to express and take action against the injustice she feels has been done to…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some of the major complaints Medea pleas about are that women cannot reject marriage because of the over dominance of men that women don’t have the power to reject or deny marriage. I believe not only Greece, but other countries around the whole world face the over dominance of men over women. Another complaint Medea states is how women are “bought and sold” by men. Women weren’t slaves back in Greece but Medea emphasizes the point that women are treated like property, being bought and sold. In the present world, there are very few or not even any countries that sell women but are treated like slaves, having limited rights than men. Lastly, she points out women are the “most unfortunate creatures”. I think the hidden message Euripides is explaining is the deplorable state of females in Greece. I think that there are still countries worldwide, facing the same situations Medea points out to the readers. In addition, I think Euripides wants readers to sympathize the state of women and how they’re treated.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women's Role In Othello

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages

    By exploring the role of woman in Othello and other Shakespeare’s plays, this essay has demonstrated literature is most successful in dealing with a worldwide issue like gender role. A memorable play is a successful play. Gender inequality, a current critical subject, is an important theme found throughout the play. It has powerfully developed the readers’ feelings towards the subject and the play, making it unforgettable. Shakespeare’s plays are truly…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This article analyzes the representation of women and gender role in the myth of Oedipus; it critiques the myth that portrays women as victimized heroes. In addition, it talks about heroine’s relation with family: in ancient Greece, they were under the tutelage of all male relatives in her family such as father, brother, husband, or even her grown son. By making Antigone a hero, she also ends up with tragedy. It represents the fears that men have on women at that period of time. I’m planning to use those arguments to support my analysis of “prejudice against female heroes”.…

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Homer's Odyssey, the women are portrayed in many different ways, some are said to be wise while others are cruel, but many are treated differently from the opposite gender. One of the women in the story, Penelope, was portrayed as very wise but because of her gender she was expected to obey many of the men. Similarly to Penelope, Arete, queen of the Phaeacians, was equally wise but was viewed almost as an equal to the men. In contrast to the other two women, Melantho was very malicious and was treated similarly to the men in the end of the book.…

    • 946 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She said, “For I shall kill my own children there is none that can give them safety.”(26) The nature of a typical woman is to be compassionate and nurturing. Medea’s decision to murder her own children was the farthest divergence from her expected nature as a woman. Medea told the women of Corinth, “…What they say of us is that we have a peaceful time living at home, while they do the fighting in war. How wrong are they! I would very much rather stand three times in the front of battle than bear one…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In novels and play writes such as Barbara Kingsolver’s, The Poisonwood Bible and Euripides, Medea, the theme Role of women arises: women in many societies are subjugated and displayed as the inferior gender, when they are truly the strongest; they carry all the pain and suffering of society, the wars and the deaths; thus they are the pedestal that keeps everyone up. In order to reveal theme Kingsolver and Euripides make use of literary devices such as symbolism, imagery and diction. Using all three literary devices Kingsolver reveals that women such as Orleana believe that they are just rag dolls that are pulled, pushed and just there, even so realize how strong they really are; that if it was not for them their children would not be able to live. Medea on the other hand represents all the pains and struggles of women and is attempting to inform all women that they have the power and must stand up for themselves.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Plato & Medea

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In ancient Greece women were viewed as many things. They were not viewed as equivalent to males by any means. Women were portrayed usually as submissive domestic, and controlled. They played supporting or secondary roles in life to men, who tended to be demanding of their wives, but expected them to adhere to their wishes. In the tragedy Medea, written by Euripides, Medea plays the major role in this story, unlike most Greek stories with women playing only minor roles, but she also demonstrates many behavioral and psychological patterns unlike any other Greek women. In Euripides' Medea the main character, Medea, Displays many traits that breakdown traditional Athenian misogyny by displaying her as proactive in taking her revenge, having cruel and savage passions, and being a very manipulative women.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medea

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the play Medea, Euripides depicted the role of a feminist. Her cunning and cleverness which should be admired however cause her tragedy at that time, the Ancient Greek time, where women are subordinate to men. The dominant men cannot bear that women go over them, thus cause the suffering and pain of Medea in her age. And in this view, I do not assume Medea a feminist but a normal woman who pursue harmony in family and loyalty in love, yet that finally depressed her and drove her into manipulation and brutalization. Here are my few thought about questions involved in the play.…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    writers from Aeschylus to present day ones have discussed these issues in detail in their…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Numerous problems present themselves in reconstructing the life of women in ancient Greece. Many of the historical sources have been lost, and histories preserved from the past were written by upper class men for their own edification. A few fragments of women’s writing exist, including lines from Sappho’s poetry. Controversy surrounds the interpretation of these and other artifactual evidence, and thus how women were viewed. For instance, many of the Greek vases depicting women show them handing warriors their helmets as they prepare for battle, and so some scholars point to the passive role of women. Reading the plays of the classical playwrights give us evidence of women as strong, central characters in Greek tragedies and epics.…

    • 7219 Words
    • 29 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pygmalion Book Review

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This summer I read the book Pygmalion written by Bernard Shaw. The genre of the book is fiction and realism. Pygmalion is about a flower girl, Eliza Doolittle, who meets Henry Higgins, who is a professor. Eliza hears Higgins bet Colonel Pickering, Higgins friend, that he could pass Eliza off as a duchess at a party. Eliza takes up his offer and learns how to speak English perfectly. Many complications come along the way as the story progresses. In the end, Eliza leaves Higgins house and marries Freddy Hill. Although Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion is well liked by many people, I myself did not like how they treated women in the book, the format, and the ending.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics