Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Compare and Contrast of Alice Walker and Maya Angelou

Better Essays
1122 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast of Alice Walker and Maya Angelou
Two well regarded and recognized poets, Maya Angelou and Alice Walker, wrote lots of different renowned poetry that is appreciated for its beauty and its truth. Both poets are African American woman, although in different times, many of their words rang true to one other. Their work can be compared and contrasted by understanding the poems, as two separate pieces of work, and then looking at how each are similar and different in their own respects. Alice Walker grew up the youngest of eight children. She was in an accident as a child that left her blind in one eye. She is best known for her work The Color Purple. Much of her work is focused on Civil Rights for African Americans. In Alice Walker’s poem Remember? she begins by posing a question. Just by the title, the reader begins to believe that this poem is taking place in the past, it may cause the reader to think of another time where they have been asked the question, remember? To paraphrase, the poem begins rather dark, a hate for Walker’s physical appearance, which makes reference to her past time when her eye had been shot by a BB gun. She continues with detest towards her life and the way that she is living her life, "holding their babies / cooking their meals / sweeping their yards / washing their clothes." After these first two stanzas, the poem shifts into a powerful and defiant outlook. She no longer lets this hate for herself, or the hate that comes from the oppression against her skin color to affect her. She turns from looking at the bad times that have struck her life, as moments for possibility for the future. Walker includes rhetorical question in the title, Remember? There is the use of repetition when she says, “I am the woman” and “I am the girl,” which shows both change and a sense of confidence in who she is. She also uses the metaphor "roots of the flower: justice and hope." As she states that "I am the woman / offering two flowers / whose roots are twin, " we understand that her view on the oppression and physical deformities are the roots of the justice, while the new and fixed woman is seen through the idea of hope. The organization is clear with the shift coming after the second stanza. The theme is justice and hope, whether it is for a better future for herself or for that of the African American people. She challenges the people to be better. Maya Angelou’s writes poem, Phenomenal Woman, based off of experience. Growing up, an African American woman, she was often discriminated against. She never saw herself as someone who was beautiful, and as a child was sexually abused. Through these experiences, she writes Phenomenal Woman as praise to those who do view themselves in this respect. The title hints to the reader that they will be reading a poem about a phenomenal woman, whoever this might be. The poem is written describing the different factors that make this woman beautiful. The woman in this poem is not necessarily about her outside and how she looks, but much greater about who she is on the inside and how she carries herself. Men are drawn to this woman because of the way she carries herself, though she is in addition physically attractive, that is not what the poem is supposed to be central around. Angelou describes the emotion of a hidden frustration and anger at any who may begin to doubt the woman’s confidence. But overall Maya Angelou praises the woman who can learn to love herself. Angelou uses great imagery throughout her work, especially in describing the characteristics of the woman in the poem. She also uses metaphor when she states, “Then they swarm around me/
A hive of honey bees.” Her use of repetition is seen in “I am woman, 
Phenomenally. 
Phenomenal woman, 
That’s me.” Overall her words give a great description. The poem shifts when she begins talking about outsider’s opinions. Her tone throughout is both confident and proud. The title is self-confidence and introducing a movement for change. The theme is beauty is shown through self-confidence. In both essays, each discusses the idea of confidence and a love for who you are. In Angelou’s, it is very loud and clear, that a woman is beautiful because of the way that she carries herself and everything she has. While Walker begins with a lack of confidence but builds up to appreciate herself for who she is and what she can do. In accordance, Walker has a central idea that inner beauty comes through mentality. Walker’s theme is justice. These two go hand in hand, because Angelou wants to change the modern image of American women, blond hair, blue eyes, and show is not the only kind of beauty. It is a justice for African American women to understand that they are beautiful. In Walker’s poem, it is apparent that hope and justice give her the chance to understand her own beauty and her own strength to build the kind of self-confidence that is seen in Phenomenal Woman. The tone of both of the pieces varies. In Angelou’s version, the tone is consistently proud and confident and unwavering at the opinions of others, whether it is the jealous women or the men, the focus stays very consistent. In Walker’s version, the tone begins rather dark and gloomy, but changes drastically into a feeling of hope that good can be done, a belief in self. Both have a free-verse style with repetition. The purpose of the two poems does differ. Overall, the purpose of Maya Angelou’s poem is demonstrating the beauty of an African American woman on how she carries herself. Walker’s purpose is much more of a challenge. She wants the reader to walk away, giving anyone the chance that is willing to stand against the injustices of society. She uses her own personal afflictions in order to better create a stronger, individualized woman after the acquisition of hope. She uses her story; she enlists the help of the reader to put justice and hope back into society. Therefore, "Let us begin." The poetry by these two poets creates several different images, both overall, each with a different goal, have achieved their purposes. Though from slightly different times, they can both be recognized and appreciated as poets who did not fear the outside, and were willing to put themselves out there to create both truth and beauty.

Works Cited
Clark, Tara. "Alice Walker." Alice Walker. Mark Canada, 1999. Web. 09 Mar. 2014
Tegr, Maja. "Phenomenal Women." Maja RSS. Maja, 2014. Web. 11 Mar. 2014.

Cited: Clark, Tara. "Alice Walker." Alice Walker. Mark Canada, 1999. Web. 09 Mar. 2014 Tegr, Maja. "Phenomenal Women." Maja RSS. Maja, 2014. Web. 11 Mar. 2014.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Maya Angelou, the author of I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings was a young influential black girl in Stamps, Arkansas. The three most remarkable people in Maya’s life were Bailey, Vivian Baxter, and Grandmother Henderson. Bailey, her brother, was there for her when she needed someone, and Vivian Baxter taught her how to express herself. Grandmother Henderson was the person who always supported Maya Angelou and taught her almost everything she knows.…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both Sojourner Truth and Maya Angelou lived in different time periods, but they both were conveying the same message: civil rights. They were both African American women who believed that blacks and women were treated poorly and should be treated better. They also conveyed their points with different styles of delivery. One of these styles is better than the other.…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Maya Angelou books and poems relate to real world situations. In her poem phenomenal women it talks about how you should not live in a stereotypical way of life and have confidence in yourself. You should celebrate how remarkable you are and it makes you a champion. Being a woman makes you supreme, because women are a mystery and hard to figure out. She expresses you don’t need to be loud to get attention just being yourself shows who you are. Maya Angelo works states you should embrace your purpose, practice a self-confidence ritual, and enjoy spending time alone, refuse to buy into the media’s image of a perfect woman, refuse to take anything too personally, ask empowering questions, and ask what they can do to improve the world. Her story…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Frederick Douglass was a newspaper editor, lecturer, United States minister to Haiti, and a very successful writer despite living a childhood of slavery. In the essay by Frederick Douglass, Learning to Read and Write, Douglass describes his personal experiences as a young black slave during the 1800’s. Similarly, in another essay by Maya Angelou, Graduation, Angelou describes her experiences as a black girl in the 1960’s. Both authors bring out the challenges as a child that they had to overcome to become successful. Although Frederick Douglass and Maya Angelou agree that education for blacks was extremely challenging, Douglass provides a more convincing argument because he became literate under more challenging circumstances.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Maya Angelou’s life was a roller coaster. Through her upside down loops and her cork screws, she made a high living for herself. She achieved awarding accomplishments. Maya is not only one of the most famous poets in the world but, she was also a literature writer, a dancer, actress and a singer. She wrote children books and she was also one of the first African American women to have an original screenplay produced called Georgia. She won the National Book Award, A Pulitzer Prize and is listed as one of the one hundred most influential women in the world. She was also the first African American to have a nonfiction book on the best sellers list Maya was big into the civil rights movement. Maya got involved with helping Malcom X with his…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Summary: The Color Purple

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Color Purple written by Alice Walker was written to show us how thing were during 1910-1940 around the world, especially for women. The author showed us that women living in male dominated ed world and the feelings they had to live with. Walker has done a great job of showing us the past for black women around the world through the main character and the writer of the letters named Celie. The Color Purple discusses prejudice and by analyzing Celie’s use of symbolism—of the God, the pants and the color purple.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Maya Angelou is best known for her poetry, but is also an accomplished author, actress, civil rights activist, and producer. She is a professor of American studies at Wake Forest University. (Umanoff) She has also published ten best sellers. She is a product of a broken home and was an insecure teenager that was unsure about herself and her surroundings.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    On April 4th, 1928 an extraordinary woman was born in St. Louis Missouri to the late Bailey Johnson and Vivian Baxter Johnson when they seen her gorgeous face she was given a beautiful name Marguerite Ann Johnson. At the time of her birth no one knew how great she would be in our history of poetry, novels, movies, and plays. Sometime in her life she changed her name to Maya Angelou. Maya came from her brother he used to call her my-a-sister; it was his nickname he gave to her. During her years Maya has had rough times especially in her first seventeen years of life. She has been highly honored for her many bodies of work including being awarded with over thirty honorary degrees and nominated for a Pulitzer Prize for her 1971 volume of poetry, “Just Give Me a Cool Drink of Water “Fore I Diiie.” (Wikipedia.org) Maya has been through trials and tribulations in her life that she has managed to get through with her head held high and a determined persona of herself. Maya is considered a legend in her own time and a powerful role model for several of our inspiring poets including Nikki Giovanni and Gwendolyn Brooks just to name a few. Maya Angelou has written six autobiographies which have all focused on her growing up and her early childhood years. In Maya’s first published book “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings,” Maya speaks about her family, parents divorce, her and her brother Bailey living with relatives, and the abuse and rape she endured from her mother’s boyfriend. Maya Angelou has overcome racism, rape, and being a mute and when you look at this spectacular woman and all of her accomplishments she deserve a standing ovation. Maya the Person…

    • 1522 Words
    • 44 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Walker conveys emotion with the narrator’s relationship to her daughters. Walker uses the contrasting daughter’s attitude and feelings; to express this, like how Maggie makes her feel. “When I looked at her like that something hit me in the top of my head…Just like when I’m in church and the spirit of God touches me and I get happy and shout.” (Walker 10-11) Walker connects to her audience by showing that feelings can be beyond description spiritual even. Mama has a deep, rich personality, and although she has not lived an easy life, the rough life she has lived has turned her into a strong woman.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Maya Angelou Analysis

    • 2435 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Growing one’s body into what one considers an adult is amongst the simplest things a human can do -- however maturing mentally and emotionally into an individualistic being would arguably be one of the most difficult. Even more difficult would be trying to become an individual while in a constant state of oppression. Through her numerous essays, poems and novels, Maya Angelou does an exceptional job of recounting the hardships of adolescence, and lets her audiences and readers find out, first hand, the way she suffered growing up . In her works, Angelou uses her experiences with her family, the places she’s been, and the changing ideas of her own self to explore her mind as a growing child. Even with everything in her life fighting against…

    • 2435 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Walker uses the accident that happens during her childhood to prove that one’s mindset can be altered because of a profound experience and how her attitude completely transforms from a conceited and arrogant child into a newly reborn woman who sees a new kind of beauty within her life. She uses different points of her life to build on this idea in separate clear stages. She begins the story with a very conceited outlook on life where she knows she’s beautiful. “I’m the prettiest!”, a young Walker decrees, as she abuses her beauty for her father’s consent. This attitude is further encouraged by the society of which she is a product. She is always used to hearing praise from people such as “Oh, isn’t she the cutest thing!”. In a culture like this, Walker begins shaping into a commodity more than an actual person. Walker herself even views her younger form with disdain because of this snobbish attitude, because she…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Black Arts Movement was the name given to a collection of politically persuaded black artists, craftsmen, producers, performers, and scholars who developed in the wake of the Black Arts Movement. Maya Angelou played a huge role in this movement with her literature and many more inspirational influences. Maya Angelou's impact as an artist amid the Black Arts Movement and complexities her impact to Amiri Baraka, the man who began the BAM with his radical lyric "Black Art”, helped her become one of the greatest female writers during the BAM and In the black community and history as a whole.…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jennifer Lopez

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Alice Walker believes that even though slavery ended women were still fighting like men to be treated equally. For example she said " How they battered down doors and ironed starched white shirts". Meaning women did the same as men, but didn't receive enough credit or equal rights for what women did as men did. Another metaphor is " A place for us how they knew what we must know without knowing a page of it themselves". This means they knew what the others knew without being told themselves. The strategy she uses to covey her…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Maya Angelou

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Maya Angelou paved the way for many of today’s black poets. She is famous for her poems and series of autobiographies. Angelou has had an interesting life filled with many accomplishments.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The power and fervor illustrated within Maya Angelou’s numerous works resulted from the tribulations that she overcame. As a young African-American, discrimination vastly influenced Angelou’s life. However, Angelou refused to succumb to such unfair racial bigotry and strived for her voice and inequalities to be heard. Maya Angelou, herself, claims that although “ We may encounter many defeats...we must not be defeated…in fact, it is necessary to encounter the defeat, so that you can know who you are, and what you can rise from.” With strong devotion, Angelou worked eagerly to convey her beliefs and assure confidence to those who also felt insecurities within their own identities from racial discrimination. Angelou’s vigorous efforts were successfully…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays