Preview

Compare and Contrast Nurit Bird-David’s and Kaplan’s Different Takes on Marshall Sahlin’s Theory of the Original Affluent Society & Argue Which View You Think Is Most Convincing.

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1413 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast Nurit Bird-David’s and Kaplan’s Different Takes on Marshall Sahlin’s Theory of the Original Affluent Society & Argue Which View You Think Is Most Convincing.
In Stone Age Economics, Marshall Sahlins offered cross-cultural interpretations of various economic practices. The most powerful argument in the opus concerned the economic behaviour of hunter-gatherers. It was a general anthropological assumption that hunter-gatherers were pre-occupied only with the quest for food and lived on the edge of starvation. However, in his book, Sahlins used anthropological field studies which revealed that contemporary hunter-gatherer societies not only have an adequate diet, but enjoy much more leisure time than supposedly more advanced agricultural peoples. Sahlins concluded that prehistoric hunter-gatherer communities were the “original affluent society.” The term did not go unnoticed amongst the scholars. Most anthropologists embraced the thesis, but some also showed some objections against the thesis. As a result, a hot debate was created within the scholars of economic anthropology.

Nurit Bird-David and David Kaplan form part of those who have emitted criticism of the original affluence thesis. In this essay, I discuss the opinions of the two scholars one at a time, showing the main arguments of their works. Then I shall proceed to describe points of commonality on which the two authors agree. Finally I will posit my own argument as to which scholar’s takes I think is more convincing.

Nurit Bird-David’s article - “Beyond ‘The Original Affluent Society’: A Culturalist Reformulation” (1992), the latter discusses the anterior work of Sahlins “Original Affluent Society.” She reviews Sahlins’ main contentions under a culturalist perspective. For Bird-David Sahlins’ work definitely succeeded in breaking the anthropological assumption that hunter-gatherers were poor, starving people; a view that David Kaplan as well share. However, for Bird-David Sahlins perpetrated a mistake; the one of confusing cultural ad ecological evaluations: “He overprocessed the ecologically oriented quantitative data from the […] studies and in the



Bibliography: 1. Bird-David, N., 1992, Beyond the “Original Affluent Society”, Current Anthropology, 25-47 2. Kaplan, D., 2000, The Darker Side of the “Original Affluent Society”, Anthropological Research, 301-324 3. Sahlins, M., 1972, Stone Age Economics, Chicago, Aldine Publishing

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Within every society, and every community or settlement across the globe, there is undoubtedly one thing that they have in common; we identify this as ‘culture’. “Culture is a design for living” (Clyde Kluckhohn, cited in Halambros et al, 2013: 5), it describes the norms, values, beliefs, and practises of a people. The economic base and division of labour, political structure, religion, and strata of the Nama Tribe are very different to that of modern English society. Emile Durkheim and Karl Marx established theories relating to different aspects of society and the way in which it operated, e.g. mechanical and organic solidarity (Durkheim, 1893), these can offer a platform for a new perspective on The Nama people and modern English society.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the following essay I am going to compare and contrast the theories of marxism and functionalism, looking at the topics of the family and education.…

    • 2075 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Guns Germs Steel

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Jared Diamond, author of the Pulitzer Prize Winning, National Best Selling book Guns, Germs and Steel, summarizes his book by saying the following: "History followed different courses for different peoples because of differences among peoples ' environments, not because of biological differences among peoples themselves." Guns, Germs and Steel is historical literature that documents Jared Diamond 's views on how the world as we know it developed. However, is his thesis that environmental factors contribute so greatly to the development of society and culture valid? Traditions & Encounters: A Brief Global History is the textbook used for this class and it poses several different accounts of how society and culture developed that differ from Diamond 's claims. However, neither Diamond nor Traditions are incorrect. Each poses varying, yet true, accounts of the same historical events. Each text chose to analyze history in a different manner. Not without flaws, Jared Diamond makes many claims throughout his work, and provides numerous examples and evidence to support his theories. In this essay, I will summarize Jared Diamond 's accounts of world history and evolution of culture, and compare and contrast it with what I have learned using the textbook for this class.…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Prologue: According to the author, why did human development proceed at different rates on different continents? What is his personal view on civilized and progressive societies versus hunter- gathers?…

    • 3088 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Chumash vs San

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In a period of complete change beknownst to us as the Neolithic Revolution, some groups of nomads deserted their “normal” way of life and began to settle down in villages and use agrarian methods to make a living for themselves. Two examples would be the Chumash of Southern California and the San of South Africa. Although the Chumash and the San both led a gathering and hunting way of life, they are ultimately two completely different civilizations, embodying unique political organizations, social structures and hierarchies, distinct economic foundations and individual sets of differing values.…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Etruscans

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Cited: Adler, Philip J., and Randall L. Pouwels. World Civilizations. 4th ed. Vol. 1. Belmont CA: Thomson Wadsworth, 2006. 117-118.…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What we eat and how we eat are imPortant both nutritionally and culturally. This selection suggests that how we get what we eat-through gathering and hunting versus agriculture, for example-has draThis seemspretty obvious.We all matic consequences. imagine what a struggle it must have been before the We developmentof agricu-lture. think of our ancestors spending their days searching for roots and berries to eat,or out at the crack of dawn, hunting wi.ld animals. isn't In fact, this was not quite the case.Nevertheless, it really better simply to go to the refrigerator, open the door, and reach for a container of milk to pour into a bowl of flaked grain for your regular morning meal? What could be simpler and more nutritious? There are many things that we seldom question; the truth seer$ so evident and the answers obvious. One such sacred cow is the tremendous prosPerity brought about by the agricultural revolution. This selectionis a thought-provoking introduction to the .onnection between culture and agriculture.The tran',ition from food foraging to farming (what archaeoloqists call the Neolithic revolution) may have been the rforst mistake h human history or its most imPortant event. You be the judge. But for better or worse, this tultural evolution has occurred, and the world will neverbe the samea8ain. As you rcad this selection, askyoutself the follouing questions: What is the fundamental differencebetween the progressivistview and the revisionist interpretation? How did the developmentof agriculture affect people'shealth? What three reasonsexplain the changesbrought about by the developmentof agriculture? How did the development of agriculture affect socialequaliry including genderequality? Thefollotoing terms iliscussedin this selectionate includeil in the Glossary at the back of the book: agr icult uraI dmelopment ciztilization of dofiestication plantsandqnimals hunter-gatherers Neolithic…

    • 2923 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Dobe Ju/Hoansi Essay

    • 1067 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the case study “The Dobe Ju/’hoansi”, the author Richard B. Lee, an anthropologist from the University of Toronto, provides an in-depth look into the lives of the South African tribe known as the Dobe Ju/’hoansi. In the book, Lee strives to shed light on several important factors of the Ju/’hoansi culture and lifestyle. The author addresses the point methodologically by first covering the foraging methods of the hunter-gatherers and then their sexuality and religion. Other factors of the tribe that the author focuses on are: politics, social change, marriage, conflict, and social organization. After analyzing Lee’s research on the Ju/’hoansi, I was able to discover that the biggest issue lies within their kinship, subsistence, and sexuality. [So far, you have stated the topic of the book, but you still need a clear statement of what you think Lee was trying to prove. He does describe their culture but he also have some things he wants to persuade us about.]…

    • 1067 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    classism

    • 7854 Words
    • 29 Pages

    Bullock, H. E., & Lott, B. (2010). Social class and power. In A. Guinote &…

    • 7854 Words
    • 29 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    He then goes on to analyze the Indians ' involvement in the capitalist economy, then the efforts of Europeans in capitalist expansion, and describes the complicated processes of ecological change that resulted from both. In my opinion, Cronon 's argument that, “capitalism and environmental degradation were hand and hand” (Cronan, 161), is strong and supported well throughout the book. Also, he presents everything coherently and without bias, which makes for an analysis that is compelling, thought provoking, and easy for most to…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is a frequently stated detail that the hunter-gatherer way of life was much less energy intensive than its successor and offered a relaxed, care-free lifestyle. Indeed, Marshall Sahlins contends that hunter-gatherer communities were “the original affluent societies” [Sahlins 1972, p1] who enjoyed a bountiful way of life “free from market obsessions” [Sahlins 1972, p2]. Why, then after ninety-nine percent of current human history had elapsed, were hunter-gatherers suddenly restricted to a smattering of groups across the globe? This essay will address this question and will then proceed to examine the multitude of effects (cultural, social, political; positive, negative) that this shift of modes of production had on world societies.…

    • 3271 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The ! King Tribe

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages

    They have lived in relatively small groups, without centralized authority, standing armies, or bureaucratic systems. Yet the evidence indicates that they have lived together surprisingly well, solving their problems among themselves largely without recourse to authority figures and without a particular propensity for violence. American anthropologist Marshall Sahlins to call them, in another famous phrase, "the original affluent society:' Most striking, the hunter and gatherers have demonstrated the remarkable ability to survive and thrive for long periods, in some cases thousands of years without destroying their…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chadwick, Edwin. “Living Conditions of the Working Class”. Documents of Western Civilization. Edited by Candace Gregory. Sacramento: Thomson Wadsworth, 2006. (331)…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    He is currently the Curator of Mesoamerican and Central American Anthropology for Chicago’s Field Museum of Natural History. Dr. Feinman is known for his work in the development of an archaeology survey, as well as his research in the Oaxaca Valley in southern Mexico. Dr. Feinman asserts that the purpose of this title is not to redefine accepted theories and facts in anthropology and archaeology, but to consolidate them all into a single reference source. This is a compilation of anthropological data and theories as it stood during the new millennium. This text will assist me in providing relevant archaeological findings and anthropological theories on the topic of the foundation of neolithic cultural leisure. This text is similar to Dr Hanks and Dr Linduff 2009 title, Social complexity in prehistoric Eurasia. The primary difference is the scope of Dr. Feinman is much broader in the exploration of a wide variety of topics, while Drs Hanks and Lindruff provide a more detailed look at relevant finds in and around the Eurasian…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I feel that this is a trick question. Sahlin makes a great argument about the hunter- gathers being the original affluent society. Great points are brought up about them being able to survive with what we would think of as little or just enough. Food and water were the most important and valuable things that they had. I hate to say things because they are necessities. Everything else is really more things we want and don't need. Through out history and even in movies there are those few people who want more then what they have. Thats why I say this is a trick question. Again, the article has a great argument, but I would want more. Those are my thoughts.…

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics