Collegial Model
South African Journal of Education Copyright © 2005 EASA Vol 25(1) 11–18
Use of the Collegial Leadership Model of Emancipation to transform traditional management practices in secondary schools
P. Singh
De partm ent of P ostgra duate S tudies & Edu cational R esearch , Nelso n M ande la Me tropolitan U niversity, P O Bo x 77 000 , Port Elizabeth, 6031 South Africa prakash.singh@nm mu.ac.za The Collegial Leadership Mo del of Emanc ipation (COLME) is used to address the concerns of transforming traditional management practices (T M Ps ) in seco nd ary scho ols . T his m od el is ba sed p rim arily on the princ iple s o f co llaboration a nd p articip ation that fa cilitate collegial leadership practices to flourish in an environment characterized by shared decision-making, shared values, shared vision, and shared leadership. Inevitably, this process impacts on all stakeholders. The positive effect that collegiality has on the improvement of learning and improved teach er pa rticipa tion a nd c om m itm ent s ugg ests that the effectiveness of a sch oo l ne ed no t be syn on ym ou s w ith privile ge no r sh ou ld inefficiency be synonymous w ith the disadvantaged comm unity. For the positive effects to be sustained, the collegial practices need to be evolutionary and em ancipatory in order to evoke the values of collegial leadership set out in this article. Research condu cted at ten secondary scho ols stron gly su ppo rted th e prin ciples esp ous ed in the C OL M E. It w as ev iden t from the in terview s tha t the ex-mo del-C schoo ls were better equipped and had appropriately qualified personnel to incorporate elements of the COLME . This was not the case with all the his tor ica lly disadvantaged secondary schools (HDS S). How ever, all the re spo nde nts a gree d tha t collegia lity was a ke y com pon ent in transforming tra dition al m an ag em en t pr actice s in ou r sc ho ols . T he COLM E p rovid es a suitab le fra m ew ork to achie ve this n ote wo
Use of the Collegial Leadership Model of Emancipation to transform traditional management practices in secondary schools
P. Singh
De partm ent of P ostgra duate S tudies & Edu cational R esearch , Nelso n M ande la Me tropolitan U niversity, P O Bo x 77 000 , Port Elizabeth, 6031 South Africa prakash.singh@nm mu.ac.za The Collegial Leadership Mo del of Emanc ipation (COLME) is used to address the concerns of transforming traditional management practices (T M Ps ) in seco nd ary scho ols . T his m od el is ba sed p rim arily on the princ iple s o f co llaboration a nd p articip ation that fa cilitate collegial leadership practices to flourish in an environment characterized by shared decision-making, shared values, shared vision, and shared leadership. Inevitably, this process impacts on all stakeholders. The positive effect that collegiality has on the improvement of learning and improved teach er pa rticipa tion a nd c om m itm ent s ugg ests that the effectiveness of a sch oo l ne ed no t be syn on ym ou s w ith privile ge no r sh ou ld inefficiency be synonymous w ith the disadvantaged comm unity. For the positive effects to be sustained, the collegial practices need to be evolutionary and em ancipatory in order to evoke the values of collegial leadership set out in this article. Research condu cted at ten secondary scho ols stron gly su ppo rted th e prin ciples esp ous ed in the C OL M E. It w as ev iden t from the in terview s tha t the ex-mo del-C schoo ls were better equipped and had appropriately qualified personnel to incorporate elements of the COLME . This was not the case with all the his tor ica lly disadvantaged secondary schools (HDS S). How ever, all the re spo nde nts a gree d tha t collegia lity was a ke y com pon ent in transforming tra dition al m an ag em en t pr actice s in ou r sc ho ols . T he COLM E p rovid es a suitab le fra m ew ork to achie ve this n ote wo
References: Bo wring -Carr C & W est-Bu rnham J 199 4. M ana ging qua lity in s cho ols. Essex: Longman. Bu rns R B 1 998 . Introduction to research methods. Melbourne: Longman. Bush T 2 003. Organisational structure. In: Thurlow M, B ush T & Coleman M (eds). Leadership and strategic management in South African sch ools . Lon don : Co m m onw ealth S ecre tariat. Bu sh T 199 3. Exp lorin g co llegia lity: the ory , pro cess and stru ctur e in ma nag ing s cho ols. M ilton K eyne s: O pen Un ivers ity. Bush T 2001. School governance in transition: South African and international perspective. Fourth international conference of the Education Man agement Association of South Africa. Durban. Bu sh T & W est-Bu rnham J 199 4. The principles of educational management. London: Pitman. Cam pbell RJ 198 5. Developing the primary school curriculum . Winston: Holt, Rinehart & Eastbourne. Coleman M 1994. Leadership in educational management. In: Bush T & W est-Bu rnham J (eds ). The principles of educational management. London: Pitman. Co lema n M , Bu sh T & G lover G 1 996 . Managing finance and external relations. Harlow: Longman. Coleman M 2003. Theories of leadership. In: Thurlow M, Bush T & Co lema n M (eds). Lea der ship and stra tegic ma nag em ent in Sou th Afric an s cho ols. Lon don : Co m m onw ealth S ecre tariat. Co nger J A & Kan ung o R N 1 998 . Charismatic leadership in organizations. California: Sage. Cres well J 199 8. Qualitative inquiry and research design. London: Sage. Da lin P 19 94. How schools improve. Lo nd on : C assell. De partm ent of E duca tion 19 96. Ch ang ing m ana gem ent to ma nag e ch ang e in education. Report of the Task Team on education management development. Pretoria: Governm ent Printer. Garm ston R J & W ellman B N (e ds) 19 95. The adaptive school: leading and facilitating collaborative work culture. Norwood: Gordon. He enan P 19 99. Leadership into the next millenium. Helsinki: ICP. Kou zes JM & P osne r BZ 199 7. The leadership challenge. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Kouzes JM & Posn er BZ 2001. B ringing leadership lessons from the past into the future. In: Bennis W , Spreitzer GM & C um ming s TG (ed s). Th e futu re o f lead ersh ip. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Lofthouse M 1994. M anaging learning. In: Bush T & W est-Burnh am J (eds). The principles of educational management. London: Pitman. Lokotsch KH 2000. The impact of transformational styles of leadership on human resource management in primary schools. Unpublished MEd diss ertatio n. P ort E lizabe th: V ista U niver sity. M aeroff G I 1993 . Team building for school change: equipping teachers for new roles. New Y ork: Teachers ' College Press. M an ser P G 1 99 9. Th e effe cts of co lleg iality on learning in a his tor ica lly disadvantaged seconda ry school. Unp ublished M Ed dissertation. Po rt Elizab eth: V ista U niver sity. M anz C C & Sim s H P 20 01. Th e ne w s upe r lea der ship . San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler. M arshall C & Ro ssm an G B 1 995 . Designing qualitative research. London: Sage. 18 Singh Mbokodi S, Singh P & M sila V 2003. Parental involvement — a m issing link. The Teacher , 8:3. M cM illan JH & Sch um acher S 199 3. Research in education: a conceptual introduction. New York : Harper. M eintjies F 2 001 . The secret o f succe ss lies in go od lead ership . Sunday Times Business Tim es, 6 M ay. Msila V 2000. A comparative study on the effects of shared leadership on staff performance in secondary schools. Unpublished MEd dissertation. Po rt Eliza beth : Vis ta U niver sity. M urgatro yd S & M organ C 1 994 . Total quality management and the school. Buckingham : Open U niversity Press. Raywid MA 1993. Com munity : an alternative school accomplishment. In: Sm ith GA (ed.). Pu blic s cho ols th at w ork : cre ating com mu nity. New York: Routledge. Ro wan J 199 3. T he re ality ga m e. London: Routledge. Ro yal MA & R ossi R J 199 7. Sc hoo ls as com m unities. ERIC D igest, 111. Sch loss PJ & S m ith M A 19 99. Conducting research. N ew Jers ey: Pr en tice -H all. Sen ge P 199 0. The fifth discipline: the art and practice of the learning organization. Perth: Random H ouse. Serg iovann i TJ 19 91. The principalship: a reflective practice perspective. Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Sin gh P , M bok odi S & M sila V T 2 004 . Blac k pa renta l involve m ent in educ ation. South African Journal of Education, 24:30 1-30 7. Sing h P & M anser P G 20 02. C ollegiality in education : a case s tudy. Sou th African Journal of Education, 22:56-64. South African Schools Act, Act No. 84 of 1996. The Living Webster Encyclopedic Dictionary of the English Language 1981. New York : Delair. Waring S 1999. Finding your place: sensing the external environment. In: Lum by J & Fosk ett J (eds). Managing external relations in schools and colleges. London: Paul Chapman. W est-Bu rnham J 199 7. M ana ging qua lity in s cho ols. London: Pitman. W hitaker P 199 5. Man aging to learn. Lo nd on : C assell.