Preview

Classical And Strain Theory Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
482 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Classical And Strain Theory Essay
As per the nature of theories of crime, they all take a different approach to explaining and conceptualising CCB, classical and strain theory are no different and present two very different explanations for CCB. Classical theory takes a literal approach to conceptualising crime, explaining that crime is simply the violation of current law (White, Haines and Asquith, 2012, p30). As mentioned previously, classical theory explains crime as being chosen. Individuals chose to violate the laws of their own free will to gain something and thus, should be held fully responsible for their actions (Loughran et al. 2016, para 4). The theory chooses to address/react to the issue of CCB through punitive punishment. It is critical to the effectiveness of …show more content…
Drug trafficking is the illegal trading of drugs in the global market which encompasses the manufacturing, distribution and sale of illegal drugs (Bright, Hughes and Chalmers, 2012, p152-154). Classical theory would explain this crime as individualistic and chosen i.e. the individuals have chosen of their own free will, after weighing up the pros and cons of committing this crime to sell and distribute illegal drugs. In this case, the benefit of receiving large monetary rewards from this crime outweigh the potential punishments if caught. Strain theory, on the other hand, takes a very different approach to explaining this crime. Merton’s strain theory would argue that this is an example of innovation, where the individual accepts cultural goals but takes an alternative means of achieving due to the inability of using conventional methods (Clinard and Meier, 2008, p72-73; Merton, 1957, p195). The theory would highlight that although the individual did commit the crime, it was not by free will, but instead due to societal pressure put on them to reach SAG that they haven’t been able to achieve through legal

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Agnew's Strain Theory

    • 110 Words
    • 1 Page

    Dr. Robert Agnew studied strain theory and spoke about the criticisms that were discovered in the original theory. The original strain theory found an increase in delinquency would result from an increase in aspirations as well as a decrease in expectations. This was later found to be false. The initial theory was a prediction of a focus of lower class delinquency. Research into this claim was found to be just as likely to happen in both middle and upper classes. The original strain theory ignored different variables, which Agnew addressed. Both the abandonment of crime in late adolescence as well as the quality of family relationships was overlooked (Agnew, 1985).…

    • 110 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Functionalist such as Merton explain crime through “strain theory” stating that individuals commit deviant behaviour when they are unable to achieve socially approved goals through legitimate means, arguing that an individuals position in society affects how they respond to the strain to anomie. There are 5 types of adaption such as; Conformity is where individuals accept culturally approved goals & achieves them legitimately, this is usually found within the middle class. Innovation refers to Individuals who accept the goals of money & success however uses illegitimate means to achieve this success through activities such as Fraud & theft. Ritualism is usually associated to individuals who give up on trying to achieve goals however still how still follow rules for their own sake; on the other hand Retreatism describes individuals who reject both goals & legitimate means leading them to becoming dropouts which can result to individuals resulting becoming drug addicts. The final type is Rebellion individuals reject society’s goals & replace them with new ones in desire to bring about revolutionary change. This theory is useful as it explains how crime arises from mainstream goals as both conformist & innovators are pursing the same goal but one is legitimate & the other is illegitimate, however it all seems to take notice of utilitarian crime &…

    • 550 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Being a young American in the 70s meant living in a decade burdened by political disillusionment after Vietnam, Watergate, and the Cold War. There was neither trust in our governing institutions nor faith in our administrative leaders. Plagued by economic stagnation, a decline in standards of living, and a growth in poverty, our country was in shambles and Uncle Sam 's holy grail of the "American Dream" seemed to be slipping through the cracks of the shattered cultural ideology. Rosenfeld and Messner (1995) claim that the American Dream “refers to a commitment to the goal of material success, to be pursued by everyone in society, under conditions of open, individual competition” (164). The social pressures to maintain a high standard of living while feelings of paranoia and cynicism towards the government continued were surely disenchanting for any American. It would be in vain to assume that an individual such as George Jung was not influenced by these factors in his interpretation of and reaction to the strains that he encountered both as an adolescent and an adult, or rather a deviant and a non-deviant. In this essay I will use General Strain Theory of deviance to illustrate and attempt to explain an individual’s motive for engaging in criminal behavior such as drug dealing.…

    • 2266 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    David Mares gives us insight into the political economy of drug trafficking in his book Drug Wars and Coffee Houses. To help us understand how psychoactive substances are organized and distributed, he uses the concept of a commodity chain. A commodity chain is the system that links consumption of psychoactive substances to everything that makes it possible, and proves that if something affects one phase of the system, the other phases are affected as well. Consumers and producers in this system depend on each other, and “neither one could exist without the other” (Mares, p.13). The whole system consists of various pieces that ultimately work towards getting the consumer what they want, and from a producer who actually has what they want. Since consumers and producers are rarely ever in the same place, consumers get their substances from a transportation network. These traffickers get the substances from the producers, and just like any other business, producers need various inputs. This includes “labor, chemicals, and in the case of illegal products, perhaps weapons and corrupt officials, to produce and transport the substance” (Mares, p.13). So then we have the people who provide these inputs. Playing with drug money can get messy, so then money launderers come into the picture. The commodity chain system that Mares presents helps us organize and understand how all these roles connect to get a psychoactive substance produced and distributed to consumers.…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    However, Merton’s strain theory can be criticised because it focuses on individual responses to limited access to opportunity structures or access to illegitimate opportunity structures and doesn’t recognise that there is a social pattern of crime and deviance affecting whole groups of people, linked to social class, age, gender, ethnicity and locality, and not all of these people are subjected to the same opportunity structures.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Robert Agnew published the general strain theory of crime and delinquency in 1992 as an improvement upon previous strain theory arguments proposed by Merton (1938), A. Cohen (1955), and Cloward and Ohlin (1960). The general strain theory explains crime and delinquency at an individual level, with a particular focus in social-psychological factors in the individual’s life. Despite the individualized approach, general strain theory includes some discussions of implications on the macro-, or structural, level as well. The theorist expands on earlier iterations of strain theories by supplementing the possible sources of strain, further specifying the relationship between strain and delinquent actions, contributing to the understanding of adaptations…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    General Strain Theory

    • 2128 Words
    • 9 Pages

    There are many criminological theories to explain why crime and criminals work the way they work. Five theories are fit into a majority of today’s crime cases are Anomie theory by Emile Durkheim, General strain theory by Robert Agnew, Social Disorganization theory by Clifford Shaw and Henry McKay, Social Bonding theory by Travis Hirschi, and the Containment theory by Walter Reckless. Anomie is when there is a clear lack of social norms and values. This is common among teens who grew up in a dysfunctional, abusive family. General strain theory is used an individual is strained and unable to cope with the strain so they commit their time to doing crimes. Social Disorganization theory shows why certain neighborhoods experience more crime rates…

    • 2128 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea that globalization has produced new opportunities for crime is supported by Held et al (1999), who suggest that it has also led to new means of committing crime as well as there being new offences to commit. On the surface we may deem this to be due to knowledge of certain crimes and processes being shared between associates in each country, introducing the new ways and means to try and gain the upper hand on the out of touch police, however we must look at the situation in more business like terms: supply and demand. Held et al found that the western civilizations generally had more demand for certain aspects of crime, such as drugs and illegal sexual encounters. Not being able to produce enough within their own civilizations, other parts of the world (notably South America for drugs) come into play. Due to them having the raw materials, whether it be drug ingredients or ability to kidnap etc. they are able to supply the west with the products they need, thus building greater connections between the continents worldwide.…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The general assumptions of strain/anomie perspective basically discuss that social structures within our culture could coerce people into group and situations that would push them to commit crime. The reason why I chose this over subcultural perspective is because the strain/anomie perspective has more application to explaining the causes of crime though expounding upon certain goals and motivations than to claim that certain groups and subcultures of people just have a great affinity for crime that others. I argue that out of all of the strain/anomie perspectives, Agnew’s general strain theory provide the best explanation for the overrepresentation of homicides in inner-city areas. While the other theories claim that they can identify the causes that give people the motivation to commit…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Strain Theory Crime

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Strain theory focuses primarily on socially defined goals and the permissible modes to achieve the goals. The theory attributes delinquency and crime as a response to the pressure of social instability created when there is difficulty attaining the goal or the goal becomes an end in itself. The early development of strain theory examined the social structure at a macro-level and related anomie while later studies on strain theory resulted in general strain theory, which emphasized individuals and their direct social environment. Several empirical studies on strain theory including, generalized strain theory and their components are reviewed within this paper. Lastly, a theoretical framework of general strain theory will be applied to an existing criminal justice program to make the program more effective.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the use of Agnew's Strain theory, we understand how a person engages in illegal criminal behaviors, such as robbery, or Larceny-theft to successfully obtain a good. Or how individuals engage in violent behaviors such as rape, aggravated assault, and even murder to pursue their goals and they can vary, from satisfying their sexual desires, gain control of the situation, or try to change the way they view society, by threatening and engaging in violent…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Strain Theory

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Such strains indicate the likelihood of crime, which include the harsh discipline of a parent and discrimination. Research says that these increase crime because of the emotional abuse in brings on someone. Sometimes research finds support for these strains but sometimes they do not. With strain theory, there is a likelihood of crime and it leads to negative conditions such as bullying, teasing, humiliating, and anything that has to do with verbal or physical abuse. There are two types of general strain theory, which is subjective and objective strain. Objective is events that are disliked within a given group. Subjective strain is events that are disliked by the person experiencing them. “As the larger stress literature demonstrates, individuals often differ in their subjective evaluation of the same objective strains. For example, some students are devastated by low grades, while others care little about their grades.” (Agnew 654). Sometimes grades affect students and if they get a bad grade when they put all their effort into it, these students do not understand why and think it is unfair. Strain can cause anything and especially if someone has so much work at school, family problems, or even problems with their peers it can cause them to act out. Some of these offenders have never committed a crime in their life and because of all the stress that they are getting they just cannot handle it. Bullying happens all the time and it is something we cannot stop because no matter what there will always be someone bullying another. Bullying is one cause of strain theory because if someone is being bullied for a long time they probably cannot handle…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Drug trafficking has been a major epidemic throughout the United States. The drug supply and demand creates an environment of greed and malevolence. It has caused countless deaths, destroyed people’s families, careers, and lives by taking them into a destructive path which could have been prevented with the proper guidance and support. It has developed into the most lucrative organized crime operation throughout the United States which has influenced an immeasurable amount of American lives. There are many detrimental aspects that could be discussed in reference to drug trafficking. A specific claim related to this topic that I plan to dispute is how the United States laws are not as strict or severe as they should be.…

    • 2268 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Edward Sutherland believed that without including white-collar criminal offense as its own category it would contribute to errors in how we depicted the crime, understood the cause of offense, and evaluated crime in the justice system. (Simpson & Weisbud, 2009) Sutherland’s idea did not hold up well with scholars, due to missing information of the criminal, so his idea never took hold. Still, Robert Agnew in the 1990s breathed new life into the general strain theory (GST). It is merely explained as sometimes it’s the sole direction for one to attain riches and what society’s idea of wealth is. If one does not have wealth it puts a strain on the person to gain wealth and commit crime to achieve this. If we look at corporate identity fraud, we can apply how the GST relates to the category of masculinity which can lead to white-collar crime.…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To begin with, Social structure theories enlighten on how social economic structures can influence economic opportunities in our society, which then could also lay an impact on criminal tendency to a person. According to (author), strain theory, developed by Merton, states that there are certain things or circumstances that could increase the likelihood of a person to commit a crime, these are known as strains or stressor. These strains or stressors create a negative impact to the person’s emotions such as frustration and anger. These types of emotions influence the corrective actions and behaviors of an individual, thus committing a crime is an unavoidable result. Moreover, material success, such as cars,…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays