Case Study Ethics
CASE STUDY
PRESENTATION
LENHAGE AG:
ETHICAL DILEMMA
ABDUL
NUR IZZAH
SHAARMINI
NURAZZYYANNA
SUMMARY
RINGO WEINHARDT
Parent company :Lenhage AG
US citizen
Expatriate president & general manager
LENHAGE AG
CHULSOO LEE
European manufacturer
& seller of tools for construction industry
Head of purchasing for
Chun-Ha construction, large
Company in South Korea
Chun-Ha construction
Largest technologically advanced construction company SOUTH KOREA
• Uncorrupt nation
• Infrastructure projects were receiving highest
• priority from government housing • POWER GENERATION
• High speed rail project
NUCLEAR POWER
GENERATION PLANT
•
Plan to bring on eight new power generation power
Weinhardt and his team work hard to become key supplier of safety anchor for these plants.
The dilemma arises when Mr Lee asked money from Weinhardt to award the contract
Based on the specific criteria of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA):
a) Is Weinhardt subject to the FCPA based on the facts of this case? Yes or
No? Explain your answer.
YES
YES because because U.S
U.S Citizen
Citizen are are covered covered under under the the provisions provisions of of the the FCPA.
FCPA.
>Any
>Anycompanies
companiesregistered registeredin inUnited
UnitedStates
States
>Any
>Anycompanies
companiesorganized organizedunder underthe thelaws lawsof ofthe theUnited
UnitedStates
Statesor orone one of ofits itsstates states(example:
(example: New
NewYork,
York,Washington,
Washington,California,
California,Alaska,
Alaska,etc...
etc...
),),commonwealth
commonwealth(Malaysia,
(Malaysia,Canada)
Canada)or orterritories territories(Alaska,
(Alaska,Hawaii,
Hawaii,
Puerto
PuertoRico,
Rico,Guam,
Guam,and andthe theVirgin
VirginIslands
Islandsof ofthe theUnited
UnitedStates)
States)
>US
>UScitizens
citizenswho whois isworking workinganywhere anywherein inthe theworld world
b)
b) Would
Would the the payment payment outlined outlined in in the the case case to to Mr.
PRESENTATION
LENHAGE AG:
ETHICAL DILEMMA
ABDUL
NUR IZZAH
SHAARMINI
NURAZZYYANNA
SUMMARY
RINGO WEINHARDT
Parent company :Lenhage AG
US citizen
Expatriate president & general manager
LENHAGE AG
CHULSOO LEE
European manufacturer
& seller of tools for construction industry
Head of purchasing for
Chun-Ha construction, large
Company in South Korea
Chun-Ha construction
Largest technologically advanced construction company SOUTH KOREA
• Uncorrupt nation
• Infrastructure projects were receiving highest
• priority from government housing • POWER GENERATION
• High speed rail project
NUCLEAR POWER
GENERATION PLANT
•
Plan to bring on eight new power generation power
Weinhardt and his team work hard to become key supplier of safety anchor for these plants.
The dilemma arises when Mr Lee asked money from Weinhardt to award the contract
Based on the specific criteria of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA):
a) Is Weinhardt subject to the FCPA based on the facts of this case? Yes or
No? Explain your answer.
YES
YES because because U.S
U.S Citizen
Citizen are are covered covered under under the the provisions provisions of of the the FCPA.
FCPA.
>Any
>Anycompanies
companiesregistered registeredin inUnited
UnitedStates
States
>Any
>Anycompanies
companiesorganized organizedunder underthe thelaws lawsof ofthe theUnited
UnitedStates
Statesor orone one of ofits itsstates states(example:
(example: New
NewYork,
York,Washington,
Washington,California,
California,Alaska,
Alaska,etc...
etc...
),),commonwealth
commonwealth(Malaysia,
(Malaysia,Canada)
Canada)or orterritories territories(Alaska,
(Alaska,Hawaii,
Hawaii,
Puerto
PuertoRico,
Rico,Guam,
Guam,and andthe theVirgin
VirginIslands
Islandsof ofthe theUnited
UnitedStates)
States)
>US
>UScitizens
citizenswho whois isworking workinganywhere anywherein inthe theworld world
b)
b) Would
Would the the payment payment outlined outlined in in the the case case to to Mr.