Preview

Broken Spears Research Paper

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
873 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Broken Spears Research Paper
_The Broken Spears: The Aztec Account of the Conquest of _Mexico, edited and with an introduction by Miguel Leon-Portillo (Boston: Beacon Press, 1992), pp. 196 Reviewed by: Nicholas Adams Broken Spears is an accumulated, chronological collection of texts and accounts of the invasion of the Aztec empire by the Spanish from April 22, 1519 to August 13, 1521. This time period from arrival to the surrender of the Aztec empire to the Spanish is filled with interactions between two different people and the events that encompass what it takes to conquer an indigenous people with complete disregard. Broken Spears also allows the history of the conquest of the Aztec empire to be seen from the Aztec point of view, as priests and natives who survived …show more content…
They came with ambitions of greed, riches, and the conversion of the Aztec people into Christians and Spanish counterparts by what seems force, due to their feeling that the aztecs were barbaric people. They brought with them horses, armory , guns and swords, and to the Aztecs’ demise, disease. The Spanish were considered Gods, and guests of Motecuhzoma(god) as they entered the historic metropolis city of Tenochtitlan, where they reached the summit of a pyramid where the main temple was built. There they give an account of the awes of the city, and its complex structure: three causeways, irrigated water to the city, canoe travel, great marketplace, fortresses, and a view of all surrounding areas. A direct showing of the crudeness of the Spanish in their conquest is the way in which they slaughtered during the festival in Tenochtitlan. It is said that they immersed themselves among the people and began to kill by cutting heads off, arms, abdomen wounds causing entrails to come out, attacked the drummer discontinuing the music, wounds to the thighs and calves, and the celebrants tried to …show more content…
The lack of understanding in which the Aztecs displayed for the purpose of the Spanish being present created an easier transition to power for Cortes and his Spaniards. The Aztecs talk of their horses, as stags or deer, that bellow and snort with bells that clamor, and how their hooves break open the Earth. The king saw no trouble in their arrival, claiming that they were gods who had returned from the sea. The power and technology the Spaniards exhibited only heightened the Aztec confusion and disaster. A true sign of fear and abdication was the fact that the Spaniards were able to develop native allies with Aztecs from far out by the coast away from the strong city. These allies were aids for navigation and connection to the King and the metropolis, in which the Spaniards wanted to reach. However, the precursor for the invasion by the Spaniards seemed to be a set of omens that were accounted for starting ten years before the Spaniards arrival. And now it is burning, the wooden columns are burning! The flames, the tongues of fire shoot out, the bursts of fire shoot up into the sky! The flames swiftly destroyed all the woodwork of the temple. When the fire was first seen, the people shouted: "Mexicanos, come

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Anderson also shared his views of Miguel Leon-Portilla’s book The Broken Spears. According to Arthur J.O. Anderson even though Miguel Leon-Portilla’s book is mostly of the defeat, the chaos, and grief the Aztecs endured, it is also a story that wanted to remind Spain of their debt they owe to the Aztecs . In my opinion, I also felt that this story was written to make the Spanish aware of their dark history and chaos they brought to ancient Mesoamerica. The book is written in the Aztec perspective and it depicts the Spanish as greedy, careless men who tried to annihilate any trace of Mesoamerican culture and tried to enforce their own way of life. So I do agree with Anderson and feel that the Spanish do owe a huge debt to the natives of Mesoamerican. Anderson also discussed how many natives after the conquest of Mexico were taught by Spanish Francian friars to read and write Spanish and Latin as well as to put their native language into Latin. Unos annles de la nacion Mexicana written in 1528 put native accounts written in Nahuatl with Spanish translation from the Franciscan fathers into one source. The Broken Spears included writings which traced back to the first transliterations such as Unos annles de la nacion Mexicana or The Codex Florentino and many other accounts. Anderson deeply appreciated the energy, artistry and poetry that went in Miguel Leon-Portilla’s book. He felt that Leon-Portilla selected a decent background of the Aztec culture and used effective sources that told the descriptions of the natives very well. He felt that the reader would find Leon-Portilla’s work to be interesting, accurate, and useful to…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Spaniards allied with the Tlaxcalan indians and marched into Tenochtitlan. Montezuma welcomed in Quetzalcoatl’s men with open arms, but Hernan Cortes seized power of the empire by using Montezuma as a figurehead against his will, while Cortes made all the real decisions. Cortes acted as a secret leader until 1520, when events caused tension to escalate, and Cortes demanded Montezuma command his people obey the Spaniards. The Indians didn’t like this at all, and showered their leader in stones, he then went on to die days later in June of 1520. The spanish originally went to Mexico to search for land and gold, or other plunders because they had no prosperity back home in Spain. When they reached Mexico, they discovered the Aztec people and the native indians of the land, and decided to try to eliminate them and their ways (cannibalism, human sacrifices, etc. didn’t appeal to the Spanish, and they didn’t want people like that inhabiting the same land as…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Broken Spears written by Miguel Leon-Portilla is a book that goes into depth about the conquest of Mexico starting in 1519 from an Aztec point of view. The book discusses everything in depth about what occurred during this time period of the conquest. It discusses when the Aztecs first take news of the arrival of Cortez and the Spaniards comparing it to small floating mountains off the Mexican coast, all the way to the revolt of the Aztec people that lead to the end of the Aztec civilization. This book portrays the story from an Aztec point of view so it is clear that the author is on the Aztecs side.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Montusuma

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages

    References: Gillespie, Susan D. (1989). The Aztec Kings: the Construction of Rulership in Mexica History. Tucson: University of Arizona Press. ISBN 0-8165-1095-4. OCLC 19353576.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Broken Spears Quotes

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Montezuma, who was the ruler of the Aztecs, had a funny feeling about them. Not too long after they arrived, the Aztecs realized that the Spanish could be killed just like their other enemies, so they went to war. They caught some of the Spanish, killed some of them, even ate some. The Spanish won out because of their preparation, and because they brought so many diseases with them, it killed some of the Aztecs as well. The Spanish came to the Aztecs land, and the Aztecs thought that this was the 'God' that they had been waiting for. They treated the Spanish with riches and lavish food, as they would a God. They only treated them to the finest of treasures because they were sure this was what they were looking for. The Spanish reported that they 'were sickened by the people's shocking routines', which was mentioning toward the sacrifice they saw. Then, when the Spanish tried to take advantage of what the Aztecs had given them, they realized they weren’t the Gods they thought they were looking for. So they cut them off. Conversely, the Spaniards had the horses, firearms, and they had most of the people of the Aztec society on their side. With that being said, the Spaniards didn’t like how the Aztec land was being run. With these people and the Spanish's knowledge expansions, they overthrew the Aztec Empire. After the Aztecs were conquered by the Spaniards, they were turned into…

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    History Aztec Final

    • 2748 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The question of how a small Spanish army was able to conquer one of the greatest ancient empires in history is one that has been raised countless times. Often there are no simple answers and frequently super natural omens and religious understandings are presented as the reason. The Spanish were also quick to present the answer that they were simply more intelligent, technically and morally and that they had a superior morale. Historians such as Prescott present the answer that Europeans will always triumph because they have superior mental and moral qualities.1 However historians like Clenninden, Fernandez-Armesto, Townsend and Toderov have argued against these explanations, considering them ‘Conquistador myth’. 2 This essay will discuss the traditional arguments and consider the flaws they present, aiming to challenge the idea of the ‘Conquistador myth’. The aim is in line with arguments by Toderov and Clenninden to prove that the Europeans did not manage to conquer the Aztec empire because of their natural superiority but rather a range of factors that included using different cultural understandings to their advantage, including their weapons, their native allies and the delayed initial reaction of the Aztecs.…

    • 2748 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religion conferred a substantial portion of the battle within the two groups. In the Aztecs religion, they believed that a human sacrifice was essential to be made so they could keep the gods pleased. They believed that the gods could be satisfied through animals, objects, and humans. Huitzilopochtli, the god of sun and war was mostly offered the human heart, which belonged to the Aztecs enemies and prisoners during these sacrifices. So when the Spanish arrived at the land of Tenochtitlan, the Aztecs considered that these Spaniards were exceptional for the human sacrifice. Though the emperor thought contrarily, Moctezuma believed that Cortes resembled their god Quetzalcoatl, including the magnificent coincidence regarding the arrival of Cortes and the…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Mexica feared the weapons that the Spanish brought with them. It was the first time the Mexica interacted with advanced technology such as a weapon that “sounds like the clouds” and “kills all those it meets”. The Mexica had only two-handed swords and arrows, but the Spanish had an array of swords, firearms, explosives, armor, cannons, and horses, which was very intimidating for the Mexica. The Spanish used these unknown objects as fear tactics to scare the natives, who were disoriented, into submission. Their superior weaponry gave them an advantage of the Mexica and allowed them to conquer the…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I am planning to ask the King for permission for an expedition to Mexico; I think that it has a lot to offer us and I want to gain land for Spain and glory for myself. Once I get permission from the King I will set sail to explore the New World. I heard that the Aztecs had many things to offer Spain and me but the thing that I wanted was to go down in history. I knew if i conquered Mexico for Spain I would get my belief. I bought 500 men and 11 horses to share this great moment in history my goal was to overthrow Montezuma 2, he has been plaguing Mexico for far too long we needed to get to Mexico.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Azetc essay

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Aztecs were highly religious and took religion very seriously. Their belief of their sun god, Huitzilopochtli, was no joking matter. Religion was so important to the Aztecs that Motecuhzoma and Chihuacoatl began to make human sacrifices; slicing open human’s chests and extracting their hearts (Doc I). They killed their own mankind for the sake of keeping the sun god, Huitzilopochtli,…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “The dismal drum of Huichilobos sounded again, accompanied by conches, horns, and trumpet-like instruments. It was a terrifying sound, and when we looked at the tall cue (temple-pyramid) from which it came we saw our comrades who had been captured in Cortes’ defeat being dragged up the steps to be sacrificed. When they had haled them up to a small platform in front of the shrine where they kept their accursed idols we saw them put plums on the heads of many of them; and then they made them dance with a sort of fan in front of Huichilobos. Then after they had danced the papas (Aztec priests) laid them down on their backs on some narrow stones of sacrifice and, cutting open their chests, drew out their palpitating hearts which they offered to the idols before them. Then they kicked the bodies down the steps, and the Indian butchers who were waiting below cut off…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Broken Spears

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “The Broken Spears” is a collection of many accounts of the destruction of Mexico by…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    History

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Keith Windshuttle and Inga Clendinnen wrote articles illustrating their points of view about why and how the Spanish managed such a successful conquest of Tenochtitlan. Windschuttle analyses the ideas presented by Todorov and Clendinnen. Windschuttle finds that Todorov is making an inscere attempt to take the moral high ground by defending the dead natives from 500 years ago. Clendinnen makes a balanced argument from both the Aztec and Spanish empires perspectives given the limited sources available.…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Aztecs were almost constantly at war and were dedicated to conquering new cities. They adopted many religious beliefs from the cities of which they conquered. The Aztecs had a strange conquering technique in which they did not simply attack a city of their choosing; they first sent out an ambassador from Tenochtitlan and offered the city protection in return for a trade of gold and precious stones. The city would have twenty days consider the offer or until another ambassador was sent out to retrieve their…

    • 739 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the major contributors as to why the Spaniards were able to conquer the Aztecs was because of the much superior weaponry that they had. Compared to the Spaniards, the Aztecs were severely unprepared and underdeveloped for the war that was to occur between them. While the Aztecs fought with spears and shields, Cortez’s army had cannons, iron arrows, and arquebuses (predecessors of the musket) 249. The Aztecs were outnumbered, and outgunned and as a result, “the canal was soon choked with the bodies of men and horses” 251. However, although these inventions brought great destruction to the Aztec Empire, the tactics and weaponry that was left behind was able to help the remnants of these people…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays