Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

British Views on the French Revolution

Good Essays
971 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
British Views on the French Revolution
British views of the Revolution was initially favorable because of the belief that the Revolution would weaken an old enemy and transform France into a constitutional monarchy. The discussion was in the beginning was divided between the Pro group led by the idealistic Thomas Paine and the Anti group whose greatest proponent was Edmund Burke. In the early 1790s a political storm was felt in London, as politically marginalized groups sort to ride the wave of revolution. Thomas Paine was the most pro-French Revolution propagandist. He had helped the Americans in their conflict against Britain with his pamphlet Common Sense. He had tried to encourage democracy in England. Later he went to France and was almost executed by the Jacobins on the grounds that he was a royalist. Paine then returned to America. He helped to light the spark of two revolutions and attempted a third. Paine read Edmund Burke's pamphlet, Reflections on the Revolution in France and replied with Rights of Man, which was published in two parts in 1791 and 1792. 1 Like Common Sense before it, it was aimed at the craftsmen and artisans. Paine said that all men were equal and any non-equalizer such as money, power, prestige or titles, were wrong. He felt that governments should reflect social equality.2 Rights of Man was written in plain, forceful English that allowed it to be accessible for ordinary people. It was issued and published in précis pamphlet form and acquired a large following for Paine who wanted to stimulate a democratic revolution. He was a pure democrat and believed in the ability of the ordinary man to make decisions for himself. Paine was responsible for politicizing the lower orders, to a great extent and demanded social reforms including universal and free education, old age pensions and family allowances, all of which were to be financed from income tax. Burke was opposed to the Revolution. In 1790 he published his book Reflections on the Revolution in France as a warning to many English reformers such as the Country Gentry, the Foxites and Wilkesites who believed that the French were having their own Glorious Revolution.3 Clubs had been set up to celebrate Britain's centenary of the Glorious Revolution and these clubs began to celebrate with the French, to aid and encourage their revolution. There were two types of club: Revolutionary Societies for the gentry and Reform Clubs for the lower orders. Reflections were written in answer to these clubs and specifically to speeches and sermons by Priestley and Price, both of who were radical, democratic Unitarian ministers. They advocated that the example of the French Revolution should be copied in England. Burke warned these groups to stop supporting the French, since the Revolution was not what it seemed. Burke had built up his reputation on the defense of the rights of parliament and in supporting the underdog. He had done this over issues in America, India, Ireland and the rights of Catholics, particularly in Ireland. Now it seemed he was contradicting himself because he appeared to be defending the French monarchy. However, Burke did not oppose reform per se. He believed in organic reform and organic growth: that is, natural evolution. He had no time for drastic revolution. He opposed rapid, uncontrolled change, as was happening in France, particularly since the demolition of the Ancient Régime was in the hands of amateurs who had little or no political expertise.4 Burke said that the French were not having their own version of the Glorious Revolution but that events in France were something very different. He asserted that events in France would lead to conflict and bloodshed and that war would result from the Revolution, ending in the establishment of a military dictatorship. Burke got it right, but died 1797 and never saw the rise of Napoleon. However, he failed to see the reasons for the Revolution. Burke had been in France in 1773-4 but had spent the time with the nobility and had been well treated. He had not seen the oppression, the appalling living and working conditions or the misery that existed in France. Burke had practical political reasons for his attitude to events in France. Paine accused Burke of pitying the plumage and forgetting the dying bird. Burke saw no need for the violent changes in France and said it would lead to disaster because all the foundations of government had been swept away leaving nothing on which to build. There were no men of experience in government, only theorists. Burke increasingly gained support, as he was proved right. Most people stopped endorsing the Revolution as it became violent and became conservative and reactionary. The exceptions were Paine, Fox, their supporters and the extremists. For the majority of the population, the word revolution' came to mean bloodshed, mobs and violent change. However, it is worth noting that Reflections was written well in advance of all this. Burke had the greatest impact in Britain because the politically powerful followed his ideas. The Revolutionary Societies ceased to exist after 1793 and the landed, ecclesiastical and government powers fell in with Burke's attitude and adopted it, although misinterpreted, because they believed that any reform would lead to revolution. The only group in parliament advocating reform after the start of the wars against France was the Foxite Whigs. Fox was seen as a traitor and consequently did not hold office until 1806. Fox and Burke fell out very publicly in 1791 and never spoke to each other again. Major Cartwright believed that having long parliaments would subject to fail because parliament has a long history of corruption and bribery. 5 His views are focused more on reasons why revolutions can be started but he would be more on Burke’s side as he opposes the revolution and blame the American Revolution on parliament being corrupt and describing King James as a tyrant.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The French Revolution is considered to be one of the most significant events in world history. It drastically changed the face of France, which at the time of the Revolution was the most powerful country in Europe, as well as altered the society and government. The causes of the French revolution are attributed to several intertwining factors. Socioeconomic, political, and intellectual events before and during the revolution fueled it from the start.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Paine helped to inspire the American Revolution. In “Common Sense”, published in January 1776, Thomas Paine said that the Colonists should aim for complete independence from Britain. Among the arguments he used were that Britain governed the Americans for its own benefit, not theirs, and that, in any case, the distance between the two nations made governing from England very inefficient. The pamphlet sold in its thousands and was very influential. It helped to turn a local uprising into a War of Independence and Thomas Paine was given the title ‘Father of the American Revolution. Another work of Paine’s that is crucial to the revolution is “The Crisis.” argues American independence, of course, but begins with theoretical thoughts on…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If it was not for the help of the French, America would have never gained their independence from Britain. Britain was the biggest empire that the world had seen since the Roman Empire. In fact, without assistance the Americans were no match for Britain. The hatred towards the British from both the French and Americans had made it easy for them to form an alliance. In 1778, representatives of both America and France signed the Treaty of Alliance. The two countries agreed to aid each other in the event of a British attack from the present time and forever. It also stated that neither country would make amends with England until independence of the United States was recognized. America forming an alliance with the French was significant in gaining America’s independence. Because of the donation of funds, the help from French navy and the help from the French military, the Americans gained their independence.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “Common Sense” by Thomas Paine was a very important document at the start of the American Revolution. Paine’s 48 page pamphlet was published on January 10th, 1776 and explained why the thirteen colonies should break off from England. In the first section, Paine explains that as society begins to flourish, a government is more necessary to prevent the “natural evil” he saw in man. The second section of this document points out that all men are equal and that the idea that kings and queens are more superior than everyone else is a false one. Paine then describes some problems that monarchies have caused in past times. He also argues against the constitutional monarchy, an idea promoted by John Locke. Paine says that the limits given in a “mixed state” are not enough.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Paine, as many of you know, has written many pamphlets. “Common Sense”, “The American Revolution”, and “Rights of Man", were probably his most famous because they showcased ideas that had never been said aloud. These pamphlets were his opinions about war, England, and most importantly, independence. All 3 of which, were…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Change is feared. It is often heard that people simply fear change. Sometimes, however, thats not always true. Some claim that they fear the change, when they merely like the way things are and refuse to see things in another way. When discontent spreads throughout the majority of the population of French, a forced revolutionary war is the only way to convince that change is necessary. Three main things contributed to this desire for change, and those include taxes too intolerable to pay and survive, ideas encouraging change that were inspired by the Enlightenment, and the success of the American Revolution.…

    • 656 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The French Revolution is the most crucial turning point in human history. It was the revolt of French people against privilege and autocracy. Unlike the English Revolution of 1688 and the American Revolution of 1776 which were related to political issues. The French Revolution, however, was related to social, political, economic and religious issues. It started on 14 July 1789 and ended when Napoleon Bonaparte took over France.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The French Revolution was a time of sweeping social and political change in France that kept going from 1789 until 1799, and was mostly conveyed forward by Napoleon amid the later development of the French Empire. The Revolution toppled the government, set up a republic, experienced fierce times of political turmoil, lastly finished in an autocracy under Napoleon that quickly conveyed a large number of its standards to Western Europe and past. Motivated by liberal and radical thoughts, the Revolution significantly modified the course of cutting edge history, setting off the worldwide decrease of outright governments while supplanting them with republics and liberal democracies. Through the Revolutionary Wars, it unleashed a rush of worldwide…

    • 141 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Itwasn't until, 1776, when a pamphlet appeared that stimulated the rapid growingsupport for complete sovereignty. Thomas Paine wrote Common Sense andproved to be a brilliant success as a revolutionary propagandist. His pamphlethelped change the American view toward the war. Paine stressed that it would bea folly to think that America would be able to reconcile with Great Britain. Hewanted to shift the Americans' anger from the regulations that the Parliamentimposed to the source of the problem-the English Constitution. He believed thatit was the king, and the system that permitted him to rule, was to blame. Itwas, he argued, simple common sense for Americans to break away from agovernment that was tainted by a corrupted monarch, a government that inflictedsuch brutality on its own people, a government that could provoke Americansinto wars in which they had no interest.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The British returned in force in August 1776, landing in New York and engaging the fledgling Continental Army at the Battle of Brooklyn in one of the largest engagements of the war. They eventually seized New York City and nearly captured General Washington. The British made the city their main political and military base of operations in North America, holding it until 1783, when they relinquished it under the terms of the Treaty of Paris. Patriot evacuation and British military occupation made the city the destination for Loyalist refugees, and a focal point of Washington's intelligence network.[60][61] The British also took New Jersey, but in a surprise attack, Washington crossed the Delaware into New Jersey and defeated British armies at Trenton and Princeton, thereby regaining New Jersey. While the victories involved small numbers, they gave an important boost to pro-independence supporters at a time when morale was flagging, and have become iconic images of the war.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Paine (1937-1809) was 72 years of age when he passed, he was born in England and was an influential 18th-century author. He was an English writer not only of essays but pamphlets too, among them included, “Common Sense,” which was one of his most influential pieces, “Rights of Man,” a piece where he defended the French Revolution; and “The Age of Reason,” regarding his place of religion in society. Thomas Paine brought his ideas to a huge audience, confusing the public opinions and views of the people in Britain. His writings didn’t only influence the British, but also influenced the American Revolution and helped open way for the Declaration of Independence.…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Thomas Paine divides Common Sense into four sections. First and second talking about how a government should be set up, and why a monarchy is wrong and how the effects of hereditary succession are negative. Paine starts the second half of the pamphlet on the natural rights human beings have. He ends it by talking about the capabilities of America and how the Colonists would be able to defeat Great Britain. Paine actually assumed an American victory. Knowing that England was very powerful at the time, people were probably afraid and thought that it would be impossible to overthrow the monarchy. It was definitely reasonable for the Colonists to believe that this incredible feat of victory was in fact impossible. Paine had to be pretty stinkin' bold to make an assumption of victory. The hardest thing for Paine was probably not just convincing people to believe that a monarchy was wrong and independence was a must, getting these people to raise arms. That, I would argue, is the main reason for this pamphlet.…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dbq Enlightenment Analysis

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In his book “Common Sense” (Document 3) he points out was that America isn’t like Britain and how it can stay different from Britain. America doesn’t have a king that solely rules over it, we have laws that help to govern us. With the absence of a king it creates a different government from Britain. Thomas Paine also points out his view on freedom. He goes with the enlightenment thinkers in saying that freedom is good, if we didn’t have freedom bad things would come. He points out that freedom was the main cause of Americans wanting to start the revolution. If people then went through all that trouble to get their freedom the government should uphold that main and arguably the most important revolutionary principle. He uses his views and writings to influence the government and create a basis for them to rule off…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    histroy

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Paine presented multiple arguments in his pamphlet, Common Sense. One of his arguments that stood out to me the most is that regarding the monarchy and hereditary succession. Paine describes how nobody chooses to live poorly and cannot choose the status of their descendants and the importance and idea of equality. He describes the difference between Kinds and subjects as being unnecessary and unethical. Everyone is equal at creation. People of the colonies could relate to this on a religious aspect as well, because the Bible supports his statements. Paine supported the beliefs of freedom of property to all men and freedom on religion. Paine also discussed America and the relationship with Great-Britain. Paine stated that America had become dependent on Great-Brittan and that success and happiness should not be reliant on another country. He wrote that Great-Britain had nobody’s interest in mind but their own. Paine also pointed out the unnecessary quarrels with other countries such as France and Spain, due to the fact that we were involved with Great-Britain and pictured them as the parent country. He introduced the idea of having each colony be independent and have representatives chosen by the people.…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The English Civil War and the French Revolution are characterized by a change in power that took place within their existing governments in a relatively short period of time. In addition, the English Civil War and the French Revolution were both initiated from the citizen’s unhappiness with the king’s rule. These were caused by a multitude of political, social, and economic problems residing in the English and French monarchies.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays