In "Boys and Girls" by Alice Munro, the narrator as a woman who is telling the first person point of view of when she was a girl. The girl's father was a fox farmer. Every the father killed the foxes that he raised and sold their pelts. The narrator had a little brother, named Laird.
The girl took great pride in the fact that she helped her father with the chores on the farm. The mother tried to get the daughter to work inside doing work deemed appropriate for a lady, however it was not something she enjoyed. Even though the narrator could do more work that her younger brother, she was still under appreciated. One winter when she was eleven years old they had two horses, Mack and Flora. Mack was an old workhorse slow and easy to handle. Flora was a sorrel mare who was violent and reckless. Narrator's dad decided to kill Mack so he could feed his foxes. The girl felt very uneasy about the death of the horse. Two weeks after it was time for Flora to be killed. The girl tried to save the horse, Flora, by letting her run free, Laird called his father and the hired man who were going to chase the horse. The girl thought that she would be in trouble for letting the horse out.
During dinner, when Laird told everyone what horse run because of the girl, father only replied, "Never mind, she's only a girl."
Response
All "Boys and Girls" story by Alice Munro is about stereotyping sex-role in society. At the time of the story it was normal to think that men and women are not equal. All things which woman was expected to do was household work. Boys and girls were growing up in different conditions. It was normal for girls to play with dolls and help mother. Boys were usually helping their fathers. It is amazing how society can affect on our life.
The narrator was very happy in her childhood. She even helped her father to look after foxes. However, as she grows older, the difference between boys and girls becomes more clear and conflicting to her. Her grandma always told her how to behave, what young girl should and what not. It was stressful for her, I think.
Knowing that she is expected to become a girl and conform to society's beliefs and norms, she expresses her desire to rebel against what is expected. But strong influent of parent and grandma made the most important affect to her life.
In my opinion there is the same situation now in our world. Girls are expected to behave more polite, to play with dolls, read books. Boys in the contrary do all work which is connected with power.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
“Bold Girls” by Rona Munro is a dramatic play set in Ireland during “The Troubles”. The play centres around the lives of three women; Nora, Cassie and Marie and the hard times they come to face. Though the women’s husband’s have been killed or jailed, the women’s life must continue however their lives are suddenly unsettled when a young disturbing teenage girl appears, Deirdre, acting as a catalyst and disrupting the settled lives of these characters as well as unveiling well hidden truths.…
- 821 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the movie version of “Boys and Girls”, there were many differences, such as the beginning. In the movie, we open into the scene where the first horse is shot. The girl and Laird are both watching, however another difference to the original short story is that Laird has an adverse reaction to the death of the horse. He runs out of the barn and away until his sister catches him and tells him that it was good that he saw, so he now knows what has to eventually be done in these cases. In the events leading up to the “great escape” of the horse, Laird is the one to tell her that the horse would be getting shot in the morning. After the escape of the horse, the father brought the horse back to the house alive, whereas in the book they butchered…
- 375 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Summer’s almost over and autumn is approaching, Brother recalls himself for being ungrateful with his little brother, Doodle. When he was still young, the narrator, wants a baby brother that he can play with. “He was born when i was six and was, from the outset, a disappointment.” (p.416). The narrator was still young when Doodle was introduced to their family. With lack of appreciation, Brother tried to accept his brother’s condition. “... I wanted more than anything else. Someone to race to Horsehead Landing, someone to box with, and someone to perch with…” (p.416) Growing up for the narrator was so hard because he tried to…
- 605 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
She is the Hero of this novel. As the narrator and the protagonist she eventually develops a more mature point of view and learns how to see in other people’s perspective. She also learns to appreciate the goodness in people.…
- 922 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
2 The note goes on to state an apology to her parents. She felt as if she was disappointing them, by not working hard enough, and also "not good enough to please her parents" (7-9). Everything she had done seemed to be the best she could do, but to her parents, it wasn't good enough. She begins to fantasize about what it would be like if she were a son, "shoulders broad as the sunset threading through the pine" (10-11). Would she have gotten more attention? Would she then be praised for the jobs she has accomplished? Would it be good enough for her parents? Since she was a girl, her parents expected less from her. She tried to stand up and take charge, by doing chores and tasks that a boy would be required to do. Had she been a boy, her life would be a lot easier, and she would have gained more respect from her parents. She admits that "tasks did not come easy to her" (24). "Each failure, a glacier" (25). The glacier…
- 630 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
When thinking about gender in past years compared to gender in todays world there is a large leap to where gender and its stereotypes have come. For many individuals gender is an intense controversial topic. Although we are all human beings trying to live up to some kind of goal there are still these stereotypes degrading each other based on how we are born. Many times we see the stereotypes of gender in society being portrayed through the "typical character roles" within stories read.…
- 695 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The short story of “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid is about a mother and her relationship with her daughter. It is a harsh one sided conversation between the narrator and her mother, with the mother doing all the talking. The story gives a rich description of what her mother expects from her in all aspects of her life, from chores, to how she plays, to what she sings in church. From each line you see the viewpoint of how her mother sees the world, what is proper in her eyes and her expectations for her daughter. Throughout the story the symbolism gives deeper meaner to every verse and shows deeper insight to their realsonship.…
- 1465 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The essay will then examine how Society views gender, the differences in raising boys and girls and what society expects for males and females in the way they present themselves.…
- 2553 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Female roles have been depicted differently under different culture background. From the example I list above, we can see how culture background has shaped the imagines of roles differently in traditional tales, and how those traditional tales impact children’s life in the same…
- 407 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Another stereotype of gender is found in Snow White. The princess is perceived as a beautiful, faire, young lady who is nothing like the typical woman you would find in America, living in the woods in solitude who loves to cook and clean up after the dwarves. This idea is similar to that of women having to stay in the house and clean up and cook for the family, and not being able to have a life outside of the home as anything but a caretaker. This idea of women having to stay in the house goes hand in hand with…
- 677 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The girls letter presents an insider's view of the child labor issue. She describes several incidents that result in the death or serious injury of children that work with her. The young girl attempts to reassure her father by writing that she is lucky enough not to be burdened with the hard labor. Her letter opens a door for outsiders to see into the harsh reality that many children lived in during that time. It also offers a view on what family life was like in the 1800's.…
- 814 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout history and in all cultures the roles of males and females vary. Relating to the article "Girl" written by Jamaica Kincaid at a time when women's roles were to work in the home. By examining gender roles, then one may better understand how women and men interact and how better to build relationships at home and in the world of business. At the time that this article was written, women mainly stayed at home and did housework while few of the very poorest households required the woman to work in an industrial job. Kincaid wrote of the specific roles and responsibilities that a mother would tell her daughter. By what she wrote, one can fully understand what was expected of a woman at that time and in that particular culture.…
- 1292 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The mother in this story is such a cold and mean woman who is indifferent about her daughter’s emotional world. Cynthia Bily, who writes a literary criticism of “Girl”, points out that” She gives no advice about how to be a friend, or how to sense which women to confide in. There are no tips about changing a diaper or wiping a tear or nurturing a child in any way; she mentions children only when she shows’ how to make a good medicine to throw away a child before it even becomes a child’” (Bily 2). Maybe the mother was also brought up in such a cruel family, then she does not have the awareness to consider her daughter’s emotion at all. Besides, the mother has a negative living attitude because she doesn’t care whether the world outside is beautiful. In the contrast, what she care is the right way that the girl should behave in front of people. Kincaid writes” don’t squat down to play marbles- you are not a boy, you know; don’t pick people’s flowers- you might catch something; don’t throw stones at blackbirds, because it might not be blackbird at all” (Kincaid 259). All the statements concerning about the natural scene are prohibitions. She doesn’t teach her daughter how to enjoy such a beautiful living environment or how to make herself feel happy, however, all the suggestions are…
- 889 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
From the m0ment a child is born they are born into a family that have set cultural norms that shape their behavior and the events they will encounter in life. Gender, the meanings that society associates with being male or female, in the media helps guide how society interacts with each other which in turn will develop cultural norms. In advertisements women are still portrayed to be cleaning the home, or modeling clothes where as men are portrayed in high paying positions, or overshadow women in car ads. As a society women are viewed as unintelligent, emotional and dependant. In contrast men are viewed as intelligent, competitive and independent. Therefore early on children learn from culture that female and males are different because gender bias shapes our thoughts and actions throughout life.…
- 633 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Alice Munro's "Boys and Girls" tries to view a young girl's rite of passage into womanhood, through a limited feminist perspective. The narrator battles with conformity on a 1940's Canadian Fox Farm. As this time period was still centred on male dominance, her desire to become a powerful woman wastes away when she finally submits to the rules that society has imposed on her.…
- 1241 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays