Preview

Born Into Brothels

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
938 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Born Into Brothels
Born into Brothels, a life of turmoil. In India, children from Calcutta are born into turmoil. Prostitution, poverty and little hope for the future, can make anyone who sees this documentary feel sorry for these children. Avajit(one of Zana Briski’s pupils)said; “there is nothing called hope in my future”. These children can subdue to the anguish, and follow the lead of their parents, or they can create their future by trying to educate themselves. The children from Calcutta have a choice, but do they really want to change from this lifestyle? The future of these children starts with parental moral support, and economic stability of the family, which can impact the future of their lives. Watching Born into Brothels, one can sympathize with the life the subjects lead. The depiction of overpopulated, deteriorating environment, and crowded living conditions, set the mood. The children born into these conditions did not ask to “walk the line” (forced into prostitution at the age of 13), they did not ask to clean houses or be verbally beaten by their parents filthy mouths. These children believe this is the way of life in Calcutta, India. These children have seen no other way of life till now. Tapasi (another pupil of Briski) was quoted saying; “when we first got to use the camera it felt so good. Before we got the chance…we’d watch other people doing it and wish we had a camera too.” Most of these kids parents did not go to school, so for this family to believe their child Tapasi had a future in photography, was not very promising.
Another child named Kochi said; “I feel shy taking pictures outside, people taunt us, they say “where did you get those cameras from?” The sentiment in this quote particularly signifies how the authoritive figures around Kochi have impacted her choice to become something better. Kochi has regret taking these photographs because of how other individuals look at her. Her intuitiveness is diminished by others spiting

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Nikky Finney, in her book of poetry Rice, captures her intention to “camera / What they believed / Could not be caught” (“Daguerre of Negras” 1-3). In other words, she records what she and people like her believe as well as what they perceive cannot be captured, reached, or taken hold of (OED, 1). By converting the noun camera into a verb, Nikky Finney expands the meaning of camera. She moves from the simple recorded image (i.e., from a still or moving picture) and expands it into the act of recording, the act of movement, the act of capturing a moment, etc. Furthermore, she uses words as her lens to “snapshot the face / Of the unwilling travelers,” exhorting readers to bring out their camera to document the atrocities they see. (Implying that each person determines his or her medium, the speaker reflects that words are her camera.) By doing so, all beings bear witness to the experiences that heretofore had not been captured. Using poetry as her lens, Finney's scathing commentary about the emasculation of the spirit propels readers to dismantle their notions of what it means to be an outcast in society and to return to the self.…

    • 1602 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Zana Briski and Ross Kauffman’s “Born into Brothels” is a lengthy documentary that shows lives of seven children growing up in the squalid red light district of Sonagchi, Calcutta. Briski and Kauffman focus on the everyday lives of these children which include: drug addiction, abuse and beatings, rage and apathy that perpetuate their misery.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The film makers of Born into Brothels took the opportunity they were given, exploited these children and their families lives in a film that can be viewed worldwide. These children do not know any better, and the film is revealing what the future holds for these children in the Brothels. Although in the film, there were no scenes of violence against these children, or explicit sexuality around them, the film focuses more on the everyday aspects of their lives, and of course on photography. With this being said, their day-to-day activities revolve around running through the streets and taking pictures. These kids have no real future ahead of them. All they know and have in their future is sex work for supporting themselves and their future families.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Still, the Children Are Here “Still, the children are here” a documentary about a village in northeast India .The people of Sadolpara, a small village occupied by the Garos. A society that lives just like their ancestors did they plant their own rice to eat and store. This society is isolated living in their own world with their old ceremonies for agriculture, believing in tradition gods and they have a different gender role.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Born Into Brothels, written by Zana Briski and her collaborator, Ross Kaufman was a humorous yet serious film about the children of the prostitutes trying to change their future. The film was recorded at the infamous red light district of overcrowded city of Calcutta. While trying to capture pictures of the prostitutes, Zana saw a bigger picture; to give opportunities to the children of the brothels for a better life (entering boarding school),by using money from the selling of their pictures taken around the brothels and Calcutta. With film cameras were equipped to the children, they were asked to take pictures with the camera in various scenes. The group of children consists of 8 children, Avijit, Kochi, Tapasi, Manik, Puja, Shanti, Suchitra and Gour.…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gang Leader for a Day

    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Sudhir Venkatesh, a student of University of Chicago, majoring in Sociology. From the very first week, he got warning that not to wander outside of the area of patrol. Venkatesh with a lot of spare time on hand began to wandering around the campus. The poor areas beyond the safety line soon make him wonders: How’s the life there? Do they go to work? What jobs do they have? What’s like to live in the poor area? It had peak his interest about the life of the poor neighborhood in the city. The frustration for answers and a daring personality thirsted for the firsthand experience through face to face interaction with the research. It would soon lead him to an adventure that would soon change his way to look at life differently.…

    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The film’s use of interviews gives the audience an emotional attachment to the struggles of students and their families; it also gives the viewer an insight into how the problems of education affect people’s lives. One great example of how the film illustrates the need of educational reform through interviews is when the documentary shows a young single woman traveling great distances to look at potential charter schools for her daughter. The young mother spends a great portion of her day looking for better education for her daughter, but the only option available to her is a lottery in a charter school. In this lottery the opposition is hundreds of other students and failure means her daughter will be forced to go to one of the worst schools in the state. Many of the failing public schools in cities are not paths to success but instead a fast-track to failure. The emotional distress the mother presents shows just how bad education is in her nearby area and by displaying this woman’s struggle in the form of an interview, the audience is more involved in her…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Zana Briski and Ross Kauffman’s Born into Brothels is, in my reckoning, a quiet miracle, a feature-length documentary that follows and transforms the lives of seven children growing up in the squalid red light district of Sonagchi, Calcutta. Carefully avoiding bathos and melodrama, Briski and Kauffman pull us deeply into the everyday existence of these kids - the verbal abuse and beatings, the drug addiction and atrocities,the desperation and impoverishment, the rage and apathy that perpetuate their misery.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Waiting for superman

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages

    If you had a child and lived in an undeveloped area with poor educational facilities would you not seek out the best alternatives available? Would you not go out and discover what opportunities offer the greatest chance for success and embrace every single one of them in an effort to give your child unlimited opportunities? In the film we viewed in class, we were shown unbelievable and also amazing scenarios where children and their parents were forced into similar situations as addressed above. All the parents and guardians of the children in the film would have answered yes to all and any questions similar to the ones prescribed above. They explored all the alternatives they could in desperate attempts to get their children the quality of education they believed they not only needed, but also deserved. The one unique thing about all these possible solutions is that they don’t seem to come from those demanding the proper results, the government. Instead the most promising solutions are coming from private foundations, innovative and motivated individuals, and persistent efforts.…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We all learn differently. We can learn from books, from other’s life. We can also learn the hard way and easy way. Either way, learning can be painful for all of us. Especially for children who have to experience the real life around them. The short story “The Lesson” by Toni Carde Bambara, shows seven poor children who experience where they are a level of economy the hard way. Even though it hurts for the seven children to force the lesson down their throats, such lesson become the lesson that is necessary and valuable for them to change their life in the future.…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    South Side Research Paper

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Each generation is receiving less hope than the one prior. It takes a village to raise our children. Yet when the village is corrupt itself, what can it offer the child who is awake all night sleeping according to the parents’ drug schedule? This same child is expected to perform at school, yet can’t. The little boy whose father insists on piercing his ear now is confined to the community. If he leaves outside of the area, he is liable to be gang beat due to misrepresenting. The man who has recently been freed from jail may have to return because he cannot find a job and returns to hustling that leads to an arrest. There are some mothers who are cocaine addicts and are not just selling their bodies, but will offer her son or daughter if asked. Guilt is felt after the high wears off, but the fact remains that a child has been allowed to be…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Papers

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Writer, Toni Case Bambara, in his short story, “The Lesson” explains and refers the norm in which Bambara accredits to a group of kids who have been exposed to a number of social, economic, and political issues. Sylvia and the rest of the group of kids are not aware of the significant but negative impact that these factors will have on their lives if they do not realize what kind of system they are living and depending upon. Based on some bad ramifications on the personal and social department regarding kids in their societies, all these factors can be effective. Being set aside, the main purpose in the short story is not to take advantage of the opportunities given, but to understand and be grateful for what they have, but also to be determined to thrive for more giving them ambition.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Guggenheim strives to make the documentary an emotional rollercoaster through the stories of the five children. In a personal anecdote from the grandmother of one child, Anthony, she explains that she herself never much cared for school and did not finish because of poor experiences. That disposition transferred to her son, Anthony’s father, who later died from drugs. In order to potentially prevent Anthony from the same fate, she tells how she hopes that he has a better education aiding him to be proud of his success. This heart-clenching remembrance helps us, as viewers, to fully comprehend that the need for education is rising and that the people of our nation recognize it and are pushing their children to strive for the ability to learn from the older generation and live in the world of education.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    An important issue highlighted in the background of Monsoon Wedding is the heinous and inhuman crime of child abuse. Being a Mira Nair film, it was more than just a romantic comedy depicting the norms and values of a typical yet somewhat westernized Indian society. Coming from art films and documentaries, the director tried her level best to depict the plague that shames not only today’s India, but almost every other country in the world.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Robert Koehler’s review on Slumdog Millionaire talks about how the film failed to touch upon the problems or culture that are truly present in India today. Rather it is, “Boyle’s feverish, woozy, drunken, and thoroughly contrived picaresque also conveniently packages misperceptions about India (and the East) that continue to support the dominant Western view of the subcontinent,” as Koehler states in his thesis statement. He continues in his paper to talk about how Boyle has created a skewed view on India that takes advantage of the westernization happening in India, but over exaggerates and glamorizes many aspects…

    • 1958 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays