Preview

Role and Identity in Toni Morrison's, Recitatif

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
652 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Role and Identity in Toni Morrison's, Recitatif
Mackenzie Thurmond
Dr. Rob. Bleil
World Literature II
April 25, 2014

Role and Identity “If there’s a book you want to read, but it hasn’t been written yet, then you must write it.” (Morrison). In reading Toni Morrison’s short story “Recitatif,” there are several things that Morrison does for her readers that allow us to relate and make the story our own. Morrison is a prime example of how language and translation play a role in the reader’s experience and what the reader takes away from the story. In “Recitatif” Morrison also helps the reader understand how much the past affects one’s future. “The past is never dead, it’s not even past.” (William Faulkner, Requiem for a Nun).The way in which Toni Morrison begins “Recitatif” is crucial to understand the entire story. It is just as Faulkner has said in the aforementioned quote; the past is never dead. Twyla and Roberta have both been dramatically affected by their past and the stereotypes others have planted. Before Twyla and Roberta even got to talk more than a few words, Twyla had assumptions about Roberta, ideas constructed by her past. This is ever true for each of us.Based on the experiences and circumstances we previously endured, we mold our future. Our individuality is mainly based on others in that because of what others inflict on us or walk with us through, we build our future. We are but the summation of our past.
Both girls may have had already formed ideas about each other. However the reader cannot do the same. Morrison does not allow the reader to know which character is white and which is black. She does this to portray the difference between necessary characteristics and accidental characteristics. By not know which girl is which race, we cannot make automatic assumptions, this is known as accidental characteristics. Accidental characteristics are not provided in a story but assumed, and dramatically affect perception. A necessary characteristic is purposely revealed in hopes that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Outline Recitatif

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Conclusion: There were inequality and contradictions issues between social classes, race, and shame in the short story “Recitatif” by Toni…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Recitative is a style of vocal music intermediate between speaking and singing; reflecting on the natural rhythms of speech”. In the story Recitatif this meaning is important because it points out the natural rhythm of speech between Roberta and Twyla’s relationship. Roberta is black and Twyla is white. They both have an unspoken understanding of each other because they are in an orphanage yet neither one of them are orphans. Due to them being in this orphanage their racial identities do not exist. They are no longer black/white but children in an orphanage whose mothers cannot take care of them. Twyla and Roberta both come from complete different backgrounds. Even at their young age yet they both have completely different ways that they see the world and their surroundings. This is prevalent when Roberta and Twyla meet again a few times throughout the years. Recitatif is about how people view, deal and handle life differently due to their race and circumstance even though one race may be sympathetic to another race that does not mean that truly understand or see the big…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    How does Morrison use gold as a motif for Milkman finding himself and his identity?…

    • 693 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The beginning of the novel is the rivalry between Heed and Christine, middle part is showing a friendship that existed once to these two women as children and their deep feelings towards the end of the novel. The women try to come together and find out about this communication situation on why they are not friends. Christine asks “Was he good to you, Heed?...Mind you at eleven I thought a box of candied popcorn was good treatment. He scrubbed my feet til the soles was like butter.”( Morrison 186) The misunderstandings of being young and ignorant, having no one to explain important things in life to them leads to the characters living the life they have. She started blaming everyone for a lot of things that were happening around her. Having…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Sula came back accompanied by “plague of robin” in Medallion. She dressed in the manner of a movie star. When Eva saw Sula it was like when she saw worthless BoyBoy return, and being judgmental, why she didn't get married. She was furious the way Eva was criticizing her, she had to tell her to shut her her mouth. As a result, of that she told her, bad enough you cut off your own leg to collect insurance money. That doesn't give you the right to control other people life. Eva told Sula God is going to strike you, which one, the one who watched you burn Plum. Consequently, She was so scared that she locked her door at night. Surprisingly, later Sula have Eva committed to a nursing home, because she was her guardian, the whole community…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine shutting away the memories in one’s mind; covering them with a cloak, never to be seen again. The brain could spend hours searching, tearing itself apart before adapting and becoming numb to the feelings and moments from the past. This is the case for the numerous communities in Lois Lowry’s The Giver. By masterfully twisting together the idea of the the community’s lack of wisdom, the suffering of the Giver and his trainee, Jonas, and finally the lack of human bonds, Lois Lowry writes a tale of loneliness and heartache. Through words, she proves to the reader that memories are meant to be shared.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Song of Solomon is a novel of finding self, but in this, one must first find a niche, a home, a family within a group of people. Morrison repeats the coincidence of belonging and finding a sense of self throughout the novel. One of the first instances of this can be seen in Milkman’s mother, Ruth. She had a niche and a comfortable sense of self with her father; however, this was overturned with his death and the complete disintegration of her marriage. With her loss of any connection, intimacy with anyone, she, too lost herself, becoming “a frail woman, content to do tiny things,” with no real life or sense of purpose because she had lost “the only person who ever really cared whether [she] lived or died” (64, 124). Pilate, on the other hand, seems to be an outlier in this novel due to her seeming wisdom, confidence, and self-assurance; however, she too needed acceptance before she could embrace herself in entirety, including her absent naval. The island people of Virginia provided this to her by showing her an ever-accepting family by “watch[ing] over her and [giving] her fewer and lighter chores as her time drew near,” despite her unusual choice not to marry the father of her child (147). Once the island people showed her such kindness and acted as her family, she was able to move on with her own, new family to satisfy that need, now that she knew how to partake in the love, strength, and acceptance necessary for life. Milkman follows her lead in the most obvious example of a sense of place and family being necessary in order to know and accept yourself. Milkman’s journey through this is far more focused on in all the steps, as in a very chronological order he went from being completely disinterested in himself, wandering aimlessly through life from one party to the next to inadvertently delving into his families past until he understood his family and where he stood in it, finally finding interest and purpose in life again. He first really admits this interest…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Olivia McNeely Pass evaluates Toni Morrison’s Beloved as one in which the main character goes through Elisabeth Kübler-Ross’ five stages of grief. Pass iterates that in denying the evil of the ghost (and in turn Beloved’s death), Sethe takes part in the first stage of Kübler-Ross’ model (118). When Beloved literally and metaphorically begins to strangle the life out of Sethe, she finally reaches the second stage, anger, and even reprimands Beloved for the first time (122). This anger quickly leads Sethe into the bargaining stage because she is not fully aware that Beloved is actually her child (121). Morrisons also uses literary devices to symbolize the stages; Pass comments that her use of metaphor “clearly exemplifies the bargaining position…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The overall theme of this story is the acceptance of aging and the passing of time. The passage of time throughout the story has a relentless hold on White, he struggles throughout as reality becomes harder and harder for him to grasp. The author incorporates many literary devices which add to his overall vivid descriptions and comparisons, a few which include: imagery, tone, and symbolism. By these techniques the narrator is able to set the reader’s imagination on fire! Throughout this literary work detailed comparisons are blended in as he remembers his own vacation to the lake as a young boy. These comparisons make it hard for him to face the fact that he has aged very much since that time. The feelings and emotions these reincarnated memories create bring about sensations of a “dual existence” (25) in White.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Flowing from Virginia Woolf’s poem “Memoirs of Being” is a beautiful piece of her childhood. This picture that has been created, is one that is filled with imagery, anaphora, and is an allusion to a time when her cares were not burdened in the way that they would become later in the poem. We can see that the piece is a picture of a time of youth. One that is not yet marred with the understanding of consequences. And a joy can be seen from start to finish, but her understanding of that joy experienced growth during this piece. Although, she doesn’t agree with her truly enjoys her trip, she finds that the joy experienced therein is one that is a ‘momentary glimpse’ of her childhood, and not one that would be repeated.…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Everything about the book feels forbidden, from the intense language to the plot itself. In “This Amazing, Troubling Book”, Toni Morrison recalls that she found the novel to be extremely uncomfortable and worrisome, but Morrison also states that she was without guidance the majority of these times. Without the guidance of a teacher the message of the book disappears in the controversy of it all. On their own, high schoolers will read this book and have the same reaction. Teaching this book to the students offers the guidance they need to understand such an important and relevant novel.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    While Toni Morrison was growing up she has also experienced prejudices similar to Twyla. Toni Morrison’s family moved to Ohio to get away from the dangers and economic struggles of the south (Kubitschek 5). As Toni Morrison grew up, she wondered what it meant to be black. She has said that when someone was born black they had to “decide to be black” (3). What Morrison said goes beyond skin color and refers to what the world views (3). This gives insight on why Morrison decided to write this short story. Both women Twyla and Roberta have preconceived views of each other based on world views. Once they build an emotional relationship with each other, they forget what the world has always told them about each other.…

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By physically becoming the past, Beloved forces all the character consider their self image within their painful past that, ironically, worked so hard to obliterate the idea of identity. Morrison’s usage of symbolism help emphasize on the idea of accepting the past and focus on the future through Beloved’s convoluted persona. She symbolizes both the past and the future of the generation: providing the necessary yet cruel reminder of the past while displaying the bright possible future, acting as a bridge between the two time period during the…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Toni Morrison's "Recitatif", Morrison decides to withold the racial identity of her characters to show the struggle of two girls who connected when they were younger despite their racial differences in an era where it is such a huge ordeal to most others. Throughout the story Twyla is characterized as one of the two orphan's who "weren't real orphans with beautiful dead parents in the sky," (Morrison 201) and Roberta is the only other that understands her struggles because her mother is sick, and Twyla's likes to "dance all night." (Morrison 201) Maggie is an older, disabled lady that works at the orphanage who doesn't speak because she is mute. She also wears a "dumb, kid's hat with ear flaps," (Morrison 202) as Twyla would describe her.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This literature was confusing however, conceptually understandable that even though this short story was written somewhere between the life-time of Ernest Hemingway. People can relate to it in someway and the style of how it is written is something it could be said to be artistic and educational that people can learn from. As this textbook was dedicated for the purpose of learning literature, it was appropriate for using this literature in the book; So that people could debate, discuss the very meaning of the contents and…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays