Preview

beyond scared straight

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2910 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
beyond scared straight
Article Rebuttal
9/20/2013

Parents of today, it is time for a wake up and for you to demand better from society and its programs, do it the same as you are placing the demand for your child to do and conduct better behavior. Parents need to Stop being that kettle making funny looks and smirks at that pot, in essence parents if you do better so will your children. A child is a creation of the parent, and children may not know how to explain, what they know, but their actions, their behaviors tell the tells of what they have learned. Now what is it? Could it be a scar that did not heal or damage to be undone that is a question for the parents to uncover. You have to uncover why the behavior is there not try to scare that behavior out of the child, because everything that is buried takes more then fear to dig it up. So when a child is sent to a “scared straight” program is it really and truly effective? Can a child truly be “scared straight”? These programs make the claim that fear is the way to set a child straight and the programs surround the child in fear to correct their bad behaviors. Fear to correct bad behaviors, well, that no more than asking us to one-day wake up and change our heritage or the color of our skin, we simply cannot do such great task in one day. In essence to fix a child it cannot be done in this manner. But guess what? This method is being tried and trialed everyday, and that method is “scared straight programs.” They are filling some parents lives and formulating their minds to believe that they work. In this monkey see, monkey do society, do the minds really believe that by a child who sits and witnesses criminals will stray away from crime. Better yet do the minds believe that such an experience will prevent the child from becoming a criminal?
Scare straight programs are sweeping the nation and they are growing fast. The question for these programs are not “why are they so popular?” instead the question

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In "Parenthood" we view different outcomes of child development due to various parenting methods. Seeing this from a third person view we say to ourselves, "if that was my kid I would set him or her damn straight." Those parents seem to have chosen a parenting style that is lacking for their situation and that it might necessarily be their faults that the children have grown up to be the way they are because the parents were raised that way. This is the first thing I wanted to make clear is that most people have leant their parenting methods from their parents, wrong or right that's how things work and the only way things will ever change is if parents sit down and reconsider their actions.…

    • 840 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Prison is not a fun place to be and showing kids exactly just that with a real inmate in their face would give them a reality check really quick. Terrifying teens by making them lie in coffins, forcing them to spend a night on a frigid street or a bare prison cell— these harsh measures are used in reality shows in an attempt to put delinquents back on the straight and narrow. But the strategies may make for better TV than treatment. On A&E’s Beyond Scared Straight and Lifetime’s Teen Trouble, producers document some extreme methods to address adolescents who act out. The shows intend to educate while entertaining, and some of the tough love strategies certainly make for riveting TV. But unfortunately, decades of research show that such extreme…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Final Capstone Project

    • 5220 Words
    • 21 Pages

    “This is probably one of the biggest factors that we see that leads to a juvenile becoming a delinquent and criminal.” “With no role model, and no one to really look up to, these kids unfortunately fall prey to a life of delinquency and crime.” I asked her how she felt about a child that witnesses criminal and abusive behavior from their parents and how this would impact them down the road. She told me this is one of the biggest factors when a child goes on to become delinquent. “When a child see’s this type of behavior, they see it as acceptable and that is how they respond, in the same manor.” I asked her if she felt this was the same reason why we see a substantial link between children who have parents involved in crime and they themselves becoming criminals and delinquents. “Absolutely, it goes along the same lines as what I just described above, children who see this behavior see it as acceptable and become a product of their environment.” My final question for her was if she felt their was anything that could be done to improve the recidivism rate and try and keep juvenile delinquents from making the same mistakes. She told me that more support was needed after a juvenile is released from correctional facilities. “Juveniles with no support on the outside fall right back…

    • 5220 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Many argue that the use of restraints have a negative impact on children including psychological effects and physical harm (Singh et al., 1999, p.244). The use of restraints on children with histories of physical, sexual and emotional trauma are at a higher risk for these negative consequences (LeBel et al., 2004, p.38). Children are admitted to these programs to receive therapeutic treatment because of the behaviors they exhibit in the community due to previous trauma “the failure to recognize childhood trauma and abuse produces iatrogenic effects” (LeBel et al., 2004, p.38). For children with previous history of trauma, these programs are meant to be a place of healing, a place of serenity. With the use of restraints on these children, it can turn their place of serenity and healing into a place that represents new trauma, therefore continuing to affect their mental health and wellbeing (LeBel et al., 2004, p.38). In order to help a child, the programs should be looking at each child as an individual in order to avoid causing further trauma or re-traumatizing the child placed in their…

    • 2634 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    I also believe there are definitely kids who are just troubled and domestic violence has nothing to do with their behavior. However, if these children are identified and turn out to not be potential batterers they will still be getting the help they need for whatever that may be. This program could have the potential to help any child in need not just domestic violence witnesses or unfortunately abused children as well. This program can filter different children and help identify their problems. The main goal is to identify, counsel, protect and prevent a child in a situation that may put them at risk to become a batterer or a…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A program such as Scared Straight puts together organized visits to prisons and jails. This is programed toward juvenile’s or children that have been in trouble in are at-risk for becoming delinquents. Human awareness programs like Scared Straight became popular crime prevention strategies during the 1970s. These policies on getting tough on our kids have wide public and political appeal. It is quoted in many articles and…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Scared Straight Analysis

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Scared straight in a documentary from 1978, teens that have been in trouble with the law to spend a day at a Federal penitentiary. The hope, is that the teens would realize that, the life they are leading is headed towards jail time. The inmates are part of a program designed to scare the teens into changing their paths and make a change within their lives. The original 17 teens were followed up to 10 years later and out of the 17, only one went on to be a hardened criminal. When asked, the remaining 16 what worked, most of them agreed it was a wakeup call because they got to see the other side and we’re literally “scared straight”. Of the group in 1978, Terrance reached the greatest level of success. He went on to join the…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    New Mid Term

    • 2715 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Noblesville, IN’s Department of Job and Family Services’ implemented a new policy stating that “any household that has one or more documented offense of domestic violence, child abuse, or drug or alcohol related offenses committed by the mother, father, guardian, and/or caregiver, will result in the removal of any child or children from the home.” In addition to the removal of a child, “the child will be placed in the care of the state, or foster care services, until documentation can prove that the offender has undergone any or all of the following, and has thus been “offense free” for a period of no less than six months: alcohol and /or drug treatment, counseling, family therapy sessions, mental health treatment, anger management, life skills classes, and/or parenting classes.” I have to say that I strongly oppose the majority of the policy. Firstly, I see many ethical and moral dilemmas. Secondly, I believe this policy will have an immediate negative impact on the children, as well as an ultimately destructive effect on criminality in the future. Lastly, while I do feel that the Department of Job and Family Services interpreted the social learning theory properly, I do not feel, however, that they applied it properly when implementing the policy. I question this policy for that a number of moral and ethical issues come to mind when I think of this new policy. This policy seems to be that of one that too quickly jumps to conclusions as well as judgments. Which brings up questions such as who determines that a child is in danger? What constitutes endangerment in the government’s eyes? How is it decided that the state is better suited to raise my child?…

    • 2715 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    scared straight

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Now there was a study done by Anthony Petrosino and researchers at the Campbell Collaboration analyzed results from nine Scared Straight Programs and found that such programs generally increased crime up to 28 percent in the experimental group when compared to a no-treatment control group (Slowikowski, 2011). In another analysis of juvenile prevention and treatment programs, Mark Lipsey of the Vanderbilt Institute for public Policy Studies found that youth who participate in Scared Straight and other similar deterrence programs have higher recidivism rates than youth in control groups (Slowikowski, 2011). Also there was a report done in 1997 presented to the U.S. Congress where there was 500 crime prevention evaluations and said the program “Scared Straight” is “what does not work” in preventing juvenile crime. Yet programs like “Scared Straight” are continuing to be used as an approach in the United States and throughout the world.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Farrington, D., & Welsh, B. (2006). Preventing crime: what works for children, offenders, victims, and places. New York: Springer.…

    • 2549 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Society and government seek both to protect children from abuse and to defend the rights of the family. Weighing those two goals and determining which is more important in a particular situation poses a serious challenge. Child welfare experts constantly struggle to balance the risk of causing psychological damage to children by removing them from their families with the risk of exposing them to physical harm by leaving them with abusive parents or guardians. This decision is especially difficult when the evidence of abuse is unclear.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Being antisocial is looked at as a list of multiple behaviors that disrupt normalcy. As the child of an incarcerated parent grows to be an adolescent, there may be even more social problems. Now the child is growing up and can get into more trouble for their social deviance. When it comes to getting in trouble, they may use excuses to cause them to get into more trouble. After all, what excuse is better than, “My dad did it?”…

    • 1815 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These individuals possess a need to be “fixed” because society has defined them deviant. Troubled persons industries works to bring people viewed as a threat to themselves or to others into the stream of "adjusted" citizens. For example, criminal behavior ultimately leads to correctional institutions. Prisoners have been defined as deviant members of society for centuries, costing America billions of dollars to house. However, organizations such as the Innocence Project shine a light on prisoners that is not often captured, and that is innocent prisoners. Louisiana and Mississippi have the highest incarceration rates in the United States and organizations like the Innocence Project exist because there are thousands of innocent individuals existing in the American criminal justice system. The troubling reality is the reason why…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    and the success rate of the rehabilitation tactics with the juvenile (Norris & Callahan, 2012).…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juveniles

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In schools, counselors of juveniles don’t have the skills to handle juvenile delinquents. Most counselors do not deal with juveniles that have committed violent crimes. The juveniles get sent to a rehabilitation facility, but sometimes they don’t always work. The juvenile may go back to continue crime when getting out of the rehab facility. Most counselors now don’t have the resources needed to “fix” the juvenile. Juvenile crime records show that it is one of the most valid predictors of repeat adult crimes and adult offenders.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays