Preview

Belonging- Romulus My Father

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1120 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Belonging- Romulus My Father
Essay- Community and Society

Belonging is a paradoxical concept illustrating an individual’s sense of inclusions and exclusion simultaneously. This is evident in Raimond Gaita’s memoir Romulus My father as the individuals Romulus, Raimond and Christine experience the dynamic changes evident in the concept of belong to place, society and community. Armin Greder also explores the fluid and dynamic nature of belonging through his picture book ‘The Island’ through the isolation of the protagonist within the confinements of the island. The inclusion or exclusion from a community is shaped by human prejudices and tolerances. The biographical examination of Romulus’ life with in the text RMF, illustrates his rejection and acceptance within the community of Baringhup. Romulus’ immigrant status shows the division between the new immigrants and the Australians, as the immigrants are forced into a camp. This camp offered shelter and food, though it also offered an opportunity for belonging through shared experiences and cultures, “He asked the man who greeted new arrivals whether there were any other Romanians… He sought them out and they quickly greeted.” Although unaccepted by the Australians, Romulus is able to find other immigrants who he is able to connect with and form relationships, creating a family society between them. Through Romulus’ adoption of the Australian name “Jack” he attempts to connect to the social milieu of Baringhup though impeded by his unfamiliar morals and values which are not accepted by the Australian community. The strong prejudices of the Australian community are evident in the event of the fire, when Romulus attempts to scare the snake out of the grass through setting alight of the grass. This event causes the exclusion of Romulus in the community “responding with the instinct of an immigrant… he set fire to the stook…” showing the intolerance of the community and emphasising the belief that he (Romulus) will never be accepted in the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The story of Romulus, My Father closely, personally and accurately details the struggle of immigrants during and after the Second World War, and how these adversities were faced and sometimes overcome. Romulus, being an immigrant himself, faces this personal struggle to overcome these challenges as he attempt to find a new home for himself and his family. Romulus attempts to connect to a place (Australia) which is disparate to what can be referred to as his natural homeland.…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    *From a different perspective, Romulus’s failure to belong to the foreign environment of Australia is highlighted in the ‘fire’ incident. In this, he attempts to kill snake by setting the stock on fire. The fire soon grows to devour the entire paddock. The incident becomes public and a newspaper comments on the situation emphasizing that an immigrant was the centre of the incident.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Romulus, My Father, Raimond Gaita explores his need to connect with and understand his father’s world in relation to personal relationships and appreciation of the land. When explaining the differences between him and Romulus, Raimond states that “childhood as we now know it, a space apart from the adult world, a life of its own, did not exist in that part of the world at that time.” This direct emotive statement creates a sense of sympathy for Raimond as he, like many immigrant children at the time, felt a sense of deprivation of their parent’s world. This statement also communicates the idea that Raimond did not have the same cultural upbringing as his father. Gaita further explores the filial relationship between him and his father, through the fact that Raimond’s cultural upbringing took place in Australia, whereas Romulus’ took place in Europe. This creates an opportunity for Raimond to view and experience the Australian landscape therefore enabling him to understand his life and relationship with his father. Vivid visual imagery is used to suggest Raimond’s connection with the land. He describes the time he took a rifle to go shooting and admits that it was…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In order for one to develop a connection to place and in turn find a sense of belonging, one must develop a sense of belonging to that culture. This is explored in Gaita’s retrospective narrative ‘Romulus my Father’ as he tells the story of Romulus’ difficulties to belong to the Australian way of life, while he desired to assimilate, Romulus felt the need to remain true to his old identity. Gaita employs emphatic language ‘My father Romulus Gaita always considered himself a Romanian’, to evoke Romulus’ strong connection to his birth culture that essentially formed his identity. Repeated references to european foliage ‘The peppercorns to be found at almost every settlement area’, emphasize Romulus’ relentless attempts to both, maintain his identity, and develop a connection to the Australian culture, by changing the nature of his new world to be that of his old world. Romulus was eventually able to develop a connection to Australia and in turn find a sense of belonging, as it was his Eurocentric values…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The memoir Romulus, My Father written by Raimond Gaita follows Gaita’s father, Romulus, as he experiences life in Australia and issues such as belonging to family and land. The family home of Frogmore was a house secluded and surrounded by the harsh and confronting Australian landscape. Gaita uses striking imagery to connect with the reader so that he can communicate how Christine, Raimond’s mother, never belonged or felt comfortable in a “landscape that highlighted her isolation”. In contrast however, Raimond wrote that, “the landscape seemed to have a special beauty… the experience transformed my sense of life and the countryside, adding both a sense of transcendence”, revealing that he joyously accepted the Australian landscape. These differing views between mother and son are another way that the estranged relationship between Christine and Raimond is emphasised, a state further increased by Christine’s mental illness.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romulus, My father explores the immigration experience and demonstrates that the process can involve alienation and dislocation, often balanced by a growing sense of acceptance. Romulus was born and raised in Markovac, Yugoslavia Despite being in Yugoslavia, Markovac is located in an area which they speak Romania. Romulus is connected to its inhabitants by language that provides a sense of belonging to that nation, this makes is hard when Romulus migrants to Australia in the hope to improve his wife’s health. Upon arriving at Bonegilla Romulus…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    An individual’s ability to belong is based on their capacity to reconcile their values to a larger group identity; whereas a failure to connect, due to a disparity in values, results in isolation. Raimond Gaita’s memoir Romulus, My Father, highlights the centrality of values in connecting through the contrasting experiences of Raimond and Romulus where Romulus’ failure to belong is based on his refusal to acculturate. In contrast, Andrew Niccol’s dystopian film, Gattaca, shows that an individual’s refusal to accept that his values are irreconcilable to society ultimately results in the expansion of both the definitions of belonging and connections being forged. Both texts, despite differing contexts, are united in their depiction of connections being based on desire.…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In order to understand belonging an individual needs to accept themselves and consequently be accepted by others. By understanding the innate forces that drive a sense of belonging on can develop a sense of self-identity. The notion of belonging is shaped by personal experiences, cultural, historical and social contexts. The text Romulus, My Father, by Raimond Gaita represents the aspects of belonging through ideals such as family, heritage and personal backgrounds. These aspects of belonging are highly contrasted with the portrayal of isolation and rejection faced by Romulus himself.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Raimond Gaita’s memoir, Romulus My Father demonstrates how an individual’s interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging to an environment. Gaita uses first person throughout the book, not only to express his experiences but to articulate both his mother and fathers experiences of belonging to their surroundings also. Romulus is a migrant to Australia who ‘always considered himself Romanian.’ Gaita often expresses Romulus as being at odds with the environment, never reconciling to the Australian landscape, whose foliage and vegetation “seemed symbols of deprivation and bareness.” This statement is symbolic of how he feels towards Australia and demonstrates how Romulus chose to only see the negative aspects of his surrounds and focused more on his desire to be back in Europe amongst “soft and gentle foliage”. These two simple descriptions of different landscapes are instantly juxtaposed and express Romulus’s feelings of loneliness in Australia…

    • 2226 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A sense of belonging is a fundamental human need that can be formed from connections made with people. This can have a varying impact – both positive, for example in offering, security and/or enhancing self-esteem, and negative for instance, in the suppression of individuality. Those experiencing barriers to belonging, often due to being different, can also suffer a range of negative consequences such as unhappiness and alienation. The drive to belong and its varying consequences are well represented in Shaun Tan’s The Lost Thing, a nonsensical picture book about an imaginary creature lost in a retro/futuristic world.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romulus

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “to a European or English eye it seems desolate, and even after 40 years my father could not become reconciled to it”. Romulus’ reluctance even after 40 years to appreciate, the Australian Landscape symbolizes Romulus displacement and dislocation from the dominant Australian culture. Raimonds pessimistic emotive language reveals the sons frustration with the father.…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Armin Greder’s The Island is a picture book that explores the negative concepts of ‘belonging’ through instances of alienation and judgement. The text presents symbols and metaphors that can be applied to universal social issues, particularly the migrant experience. Although the tone of the text is ultimately pessimistic, there are suggestions of Christian ideals such as sharing, caring for the less fortunate and having a clear conscious. The text also not only discusses an outsider’s perspective of not belonging, but also the negative aspects of belonging to a group or community.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When an individual’s sense of identity is corrupted through prejudicial attitudes they are left exposed and vulnerable allowing a sense of isolation and displacement in society. An individual’s ability to promote change within is largely influenced by the hardships they experience in their struggle to conform and the connectedness of identity that stems from acceptance. Tara June Winch’s novel Swallow the air, adapts the core concept that the perceptions and ideas of belonging are shaped within personal, cultural, historical and social contexts defining who we are resulting in a true understanding and sense of self. This notion resonates in Shaun Tan’s picture book The Red Tree and Armin Greder’s allegorical picture book The Island ,as all three texts explore the potential of the sacrifices an individual makes to belong and the affect the attitudes and perceptions have which can either allow or hinder an individual’s quest to find their place in the world.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The memoir, Romulus, My Father, portrays the ways in which immigrants in 1950’s rural Victoria struggled to be accepted in a foreign society, exploring both Romulus and Gaita’s personal experiences with Belonging. The tone of the narrative is retrospective; Gaita makes himself vulnerable to his responder by inviting them to observe Australian society from the perspective of a migrant. Romulus’ experience is typical of a first generation migrant, he is displaced, separated from his homeland, conveyed through the metaphor of his disconnection to the Australian landscape: “He longed for European society, saying that he felt like a ‘prisoner’ in Australia.” Romulus is an example of stoicism displayed through typically male qualities, defined by his work ethic and strong European morals. Romulus’ European values are echoed by Hora and among the intolerance and alienation of Australian society, they find connection. The setting at the isolated Frogmore provides the Europeans with the opportunity to establish their own values away from mainstream Australia. This draws attention to their emotional need to belong; they group together through shared experience and background.…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To belong is to be, or have the feeling of being accepted or included by a certain group, person, place or community. While initially an individual may belong to a community or group, speaking their opinion can seclude them, and cause them to become an outsider. Belonging to a community or group can be very beneficial, and not belonging can cause an individual to face consequences. Hysteria and fear can be caused throughout a community by outsiders who don’t belong. We are able to view these experiences of belonging and not belonging through the use of characters and events throughout a variety of texts. Arthur Miller’s play “The Crucible” and Armin Geder’s picture book “The Island” display how an individual can belong and not belong at different stages throughout their life and the experiences these characters face.…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays