Preview

Begging and Greta

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
507 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Begging and Greta
Beggarland
B1
The short story ‘BeggarLand’ by Alan Sillitoe (1998) is about a woman named Jane, who is a writer. She lives in a big house with her husband, Tim, and her two children, Ben and Angela. Both Tim and Jane work a lot. They hire a new au pair to look after the children. The new au pair is an ugly, non-stylish 18-year-old girl from the North named Greta. Greta is very good with the children and they bond nearly right away. Soon after Greta and the children come home from a short trip to the South Bank, the children want to play beggars in the garden. At first Jane is against it, but as long as they are occupied it doesn’t really matter. One day when Jane goes to the London library to get some information for her book, she sees Greta, Ben and Angela begging for money to get money for a trip to Southend. When Jane calms down and goes home, she confronts Greta, but doesn’t fire her.
B2 - characterisation
Jane and Tim are married and live together with their two children Ben and Angela. Jane is a writer, and she hires an au pair named Greta to watch the children, while she works. Tim doesn’t really care what’s going on. Greta is from the north and takes good care of the children. Although she isn’t familiar with the surrounding area, she looks at maps to see where she can take the children, when the mother (Jane) wants some peace and quiet. Greta is not a good looking woman, she has yellowish hair and she doesn’t have any good taste in clothing, she is 18 but she could go for being 20 to 30 years old because of her looks. This makes Jane comfortable, that Greta is so far from being a sex appealing object for Jane’s husband Tim. Tim is Jane’ husband and he just got a new job, so he’s never really home.
B3 – comment on the conflict
The conflict starts when Jane sees Greta, Ben and Angela begging for money in the train station. This is way over the line for Jane and she’s thinking that she want to kill Greta for doing that to her. And it’s probably

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The au pair agrees to assist with household duties and caring for children; Matthew Murphey, aged 3, and Georgia Murphey, aged 1 (‘the children’).…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alex and his girlfriend, Elizabeth, live within the state of Washington. Alex is twenty-seven and his girlfriend is twenty-one. Elizabeth wants to become a cardiologist one day. Alex finds out that Elizabeth is pregnant and wants to give the baby up for adoption. Alex, however, wants to be a parent to the unborn child. Both Elizabeth and her parents believe the baby would be better off with a stable married couple.…

    • 900 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary is a single mother to Shayla. She works as secretary. She appears well-groomed and is fairly well-spoken. Shayla’s father is not involved in her life, and does not contribute to her support. Mary and Shayla have medical insurance through Mary’s employer, but Mary indicates it is not very good health insurance.…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The two women in the story are Mrs Johnston and Mrs Lyons. Mrs Johnston is a lower class single mother living in a council house in the centre of Liverpool. Her husband has left her, while she is pregnant, for a younger woman after she had given birth to 7 children. Willy Russell portrays her as a superstitious and lonely woman. ‘Oh God. Never put new shoes on a table Mrs Lyons.’ At the beginning of the play, I feel sorry for Mrs Johnston because she has lots of children and loves them all equally but she simply cannot support them financially as a cleaner. How she has let herself get into this position is extremely sad but is also a social comment by Willy Russell on society today. Russell sets Mrs Johnston up as the extreme example of the benefit living, single parent family who live with and by the hand of the social. ‘The welfare’s already been onto me. They say I’m incapable of controlling the kids I got.’ I do feel a bit angry at Mrs Johnston when she gave Eddie away to Mrs Lyons but when I see how Mrs Lyons manipulated her and made her think that she was doing the right thing, I feel sorry for her. The picture is quite complicated; Russell is testing the moral ethics of the audience.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    2 years back, Mrs. Cooper and her late husband had moved into the house next to Elizabeth's. Being a friendly suburban housewife with a loving husband and two sons, the 36 years old housewife would always offer helps to make them feel welcomed. The husband, Mr. Cooper was a really friendly and an easy going man. He would laugh easily. Mrs. Cooper on the other hand was introverted and rarely talks. From regular conversations with Mr. Cooper, Elizabeth found out that Mr and Mrs Cooper did not have any child of their own as Mrs. Cooper underwent hysterectomy after having complications with her first pregnancy. Elizabeth felt sorry for her but had always felt something wrong about Mrs Cooper.…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    woman in the catcher

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages

    idolises Jane and does not want the image of her shattered. This is clear at the beginning of the…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    2 The note goes on to state an apology to her parents. She felt as if she was disappointing them, by not working hard enough, and also "not good enough to please her parents" (7-9). Everything she had done seemed to be the best she could do, but to her parents, it wasn't good enough. She begins to fantasize about what it would be like if she were a son, "shoulders broad as the sunset threading through the pine" (10-11). Would she have gotten more attention? Would she then be praised for the jobs she has accomplished? Would it be good enough for her parents? Since she was a girl, her parents expected less from her. She tried to stand up and take charge, by doing chores and tasks that a boy would be required to do. Had she been a boy, her life would be a lot easier, and she would have gained more respect from her parents. She admits that "tasks did not come easy to her" (24). "Each failure, a glacier" (25). The glacier…

    • 630 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She loses herself, as I would imagine Sophie to do after a lifetime of oppression. Jane saw a woman in the wall, and then became her. She took on that identity, and in her mind, then became free of ruling and imprisonment. All of my sympathy for any of the other characters in this work went solely to Jane. Her obvious mental instability made the story difficult for me to read- not because it’s what’s wrong with her, but what’s wrong with professional medical abuse, which especially back then was an ongoing problem in addition to today. I almost wonder if Gilman was trying to speak out facetiously through the story about how mistreatment of the mentally ill is a phenomenon that will continue to take place in the future. Furthermore, Jane was ill, and having been mistreated in her circumstance only made her existing condition and also the unpleasant topic for me worse. Looking at this story with Feminist theory in mind would be fitting, as her husband dismissed her voiced needs because he believed he knew what was best for her and she did not. I interpret this selection of the text as sexism; though I’m sure he loved her very much, he was still controlling and believed she couldn’t think for herself for she was a woman. Psychoanalytic Criticism may also be applied, as…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jane has regarding the choice between her friends and the N.I.C.E. puts humanity in danger. What looks…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Her childish, innocent attitude is enhanced with how she responds to hearing the news of Eva, as she says ‘’Oh – how horrible’’ which seems genuine as opposed to her father’s rather dismissive attitude. This shows that she is quite compassionate. This is further highlighted when she tells her father that ‘’these girls aren’t cheap labour, they’re people!’’ recognising the problem with his mentality.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Montana 1948(Monologue)

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Now now David, just one more, then your changing clothes?” Marie said in a soft and gentle voice. I ran to her, tackled her to the dry ground, wrapping my freckled arms around her bony blemished body and suddenly I got scared I’ll break her to pieces. “Ok David, go have a shower before Mrs. Hayden gets here. You don’t want Marie getting into trouble right?” Ronnie broke the moment. You see, my mother is not one of those typical mothers that stayed in the house. She is usually out and with Marie; I don’t feel blue at all. I'm only twelve years old and leaving in such a small town, I can pretty much do what I want as long as I get home before mum or dad does. Marie never tells on me anyway.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trim & Notions

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Samantha has difficulty finding peace with her less than ideal pregnancy during the story. She worries that the pregnancy is a mistake, that people will judge her for being a single parent, and that her mother and sister will be disappointed in her. Compared to her sister, Samantha has always been the organized and meticulous child, which is where her need for approval and assurance stems from. She is an organized person who prides herself on how long she can go without making a mistake, and in her mind, this baby boy is a mistake. Samantha’s sister Anne tries to explain to Sam that her baby is not something to be ashamed of and that “it’s not some black mark on your record. It’s a baby!” Her sister is referring to Samantha’s desire for perfection in life and explains how her baby is not like a bad grade on a report card nor a crime committed. The people that Samantha surrounds herself with are supportive and caring and see nothing negative about her pregnancy or the absence of the father. Instead of enjoying her pregnancy, Samantha is hiding it from the world the best she can. She even goes as far as attempting to hide her baby bump from a man whom she finds attractive. Samantha hiding her pregnancy upsets and confuses both her sister and…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jane Eyre

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Through the journey of Jane, she approaches many new places, as well as obstacle. Every event, she is asked the same question--to submit and she gives the same answer--no. For example, in the beginning of the novel when she was still at Gateshead, Mrs. Reed tries to get her to change and be a good child, and instead, Jane is rebellious. Jane refuses the order of Mrs. Reed and continued her actions because that is who she is. Another example of Jane never going through moral reconciliation is when Rochester asked her to marry her even after she discover that Rochester already has a wife--Bertha. Though Jane loved him, she respected herself and her beliefs too much and therefore, left Thornfield. As well as these two, another example is also when is at Moorehouse and she does the same thing. St. John constantly asks Jane to marry him, but every time , she refuses. She doesn't want to give up her independence.…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nanny instills the idea into Janie that love was not as important as having a life with a stable husband and income. She does not want to see Janie in the same position that…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Family and Ann

    • 1322 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ann experiences a wealth of difficulties caring for Angus, she encounters emotional, physical, mental, social and financial demands as she tries to fulfil her role as carer. Ann was thrown into the role of carer when her mother had asked her to take of Angus on her deathbed. It was a role expected of Ann, she was the woman in the house and it was a role she had not been trained for. Caring for Angus presented many difficulties, Ann had given up her job to care for Angus thinking it would lessen the pressure she was feeling at that time, on the contrary, Ann now was experiencing the financial impact of only having her husband Bobs wage to support the family, this puts considerable strain on Ann as she is now solely reliant on her husband financially and the family are at risk of poverty. Bob and Angus have a strained relationship with both battling for Ann’s attention, Angus reminds Bob that he owns the house in which they all live in, this is demoralising for Bob. Ann states during interview that she feels like “piggy in the middle” torn between her obligation to Angus and to her own husband and child, Ann’s daughter Zoe has recently been diagnosed with dyslexia, she is experiencing difficulties at school, Zoe try’s to seek out support from her mother, Ann however is totally overwhelmed with caring for Angus and is unable to provide her…

    • 1322 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays