Preview

Beggar Colony Fact Finding Report

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
10398 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Beggar Colony Fact Finding Report
A fact-finding report on the situation & deaths at the Beggars’ Colony (Magadi Road),
& Isolation Ward, Indiranagar, Bangalore

Conducted by

St. Joseph’s College,
SICHREM,
Indian Social Institute,
Sangama,
& Global Concern, India, Ananya
The Concerned for Working Children,

With Inputs from

Vimochana,
Karnataka Kolalagiri Nivasigara Sanghatana
Women’s Voice

On 19th & 20th August 2010

INTRODUCTORY NOTE

There have been several tragedies affecting the poor in Karnataka and India. But the latest one concerning several deaths due to the gross cruelty, negligence and inhuman treatment in the Beggars’ Colony of Bangalore is the worst we have ever witnessed. What has disturbed the citizens of Karnataka is the total apathy, indifference and even collaboration of the state in these deaths. Instead of addressing the concerns of the beggars, the Officials of the state have been responsible for their deaths through cruelty, physical assault and torture.

There is a lot the state has to explain about the misdeeds of its Officials in the beggary home. The home was established with laudable goals to provide solace and comfort to the homeless, the penniless and the defenseless. But the only experience both the dead and the living in the place have is one of pain, suffering and torture. They are treated worse than animals. Many must have died in the last few years due to an attitude of inhumanity among the Officials in the Colony.

Bangalore is known across the world as an IT city, a city of technology as well as of affluence. What is unfortunate is that the affluence of the city has not been shared with all. In the deaths and inhuman treatment of the Beggars, one sees the other face of Bangalore. While the poor are being hounded all over the country, with an anti-beggary law, the Karnataka state has imprisoned the poor behind bars. Instead of addressing deep-rooted issues of inequity,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Sitting in a university classroom, coming from a fairly privileged socioeconomic background it is difficult to image the experiences of inhabitants living in Indian slums. Katherine Boo’s novel, ‘Behind the Beautiful Forevers’, coupled with course material helps begin to depict a story of poverty that many North Americans have been sheltered from. Therefore, in this paper chapter’s one and two from Boo’s novel will be analysed based on theoretical content presented in the first half of the ‘Development and the City’ course. Discussing such topics as socio-economic relations, gender differences and aspirations of those living within slums, this paper will attempt to highlight some of the constraints these individuals encounter. In addition,…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article reveals many instances of structural violence inflicted upon the residents of Dharavi, some of these instances include children regularly experiencing diarrhea, malaria, tuberculosis, asthma, tooth decay, and malnourishment. Many of…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Poverty, the lack of life’s necessary needs is not something an individual hopes to strive in life. In the book, poverty is the driving force for the individuals living in Annawadi to have tension between them. Asha, a kind mother…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gang Leader for a Day

    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Sudhir Venkatesh, a student of University of Chicago, majoring in Sociology. From the very first week, he got warning that not to wander outside of the area of patrol. Venkatesh with a lot of spare time on hand began to wandering around the campus. The poor areas beyond the safety line soon make him wonders: How’s the life there? Do they go to work? What jobs do they have? What’s like to live in the poor area? It had peak his interest about the life of the poor neighborhood in the city. The frustration for answers and a daring personality thirsted for the firsthand experience through face to face interaction with the research. It would soon lead him to an adventure that would soon change his way to look at life differently.…

    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The second chapter is an overview of societal methods of dealing with poverty and homelessness from the time of Martin Luther and after. As Gowen says “the charity activists, like Martin Luther 350 years earlier, were nostalgic for a radiant past when rich and poor had interacted more intimately, with less overt conflict” (Gowen/HHB, pg 35) To add to world history, there is also specific history about San Francisco, including the program called Matrix of the Frank Jordan era through “Care Not Cash”. Gowan discusses the dialog around the constructions of poverty, a moral viewpoint where sin is the cause, a disease viewpoint, and a systemic viewpoint. She points out that these discourses are taken up not only by authorities but also by homeless people themselves. Somebody who is considered a bad boy is somebody who is buying into the sin-talk viewpoint; the sick-talk viewpoint is common among people who have left the street through 12-step recovery; system talk is formulated in various ways, including identification with veterans who have been abandoned by the system. The theories of John Locke play a key role in the previous sentence. As Locke’s theories state that each person should be guaranteed “life, liberty, and estate.” The veterans who were left with nothing by the government and had to survive off of nothing did not fall under Locke’s theory, not given a type of life they needed, not given the same liberty as the rest of the people who are not considered homeless, and not given any estate to call their own like a rich man does.…

    • 264 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Starving In Jamestown

    • 103 Words
    • 1 Page

    When referring to those starving in the Jamestown colony, most have assumed that “all of these Virginia colonists were men” (Bernhard, 1992, pg. 600). Bernhard’s article focuses on the thought that many details were left out simply because of the failure to account for information overlooked. Bernhard found that the often overlooked piece of information involving the women and children had explained why Jamestown came out to be successful. If it were not for the women and children, “Jamestown might have been abandoned, and the history of successful English colonization in North America might not have begun in 1607” (Bernhard, 1992, pg.…

    • 103 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout U.S. history the United States has encountered many stressful and life taking hardships, and all for what? For the world to continue growing, for each individual to feel safe and to be created equal. History is a word that we look upon and think of famous people who changed our way of living, who went beyond what they were capable of in order to be remembered. People like George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, John Hancock, all these men did great things. Yet we still forget to remember those who went through terrible hardships in order to survive back in those days. I’m talking about indentured servants; these particular individuals lived lives we couldn’t even imagine. The hardships they went through are unforgettable,…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The urgency of these demands is seen in the six cases Ms. Pfeiffer presented. There is only one mutilated survivor of the six, and all of the five deceased have left behind harrowing tales of wretchedness leading up to their deaths. These tales are located in public institutions, facilitated by public policies, to the full knowledge of public officials serving to carry out modern public policy. There is no throwback period of…

    • 1912 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Early Jamestown

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Jamestown is the first permanent English settlement in America, and a widely used model in American history lessons. The early English colonists settled there in 1607 and faced a tough life. They suffered from drought, starving, illness and coldness. Approximately two-thirds of them died in the first three years. The main cause of their death was lack of basic living skills, especially farming. The natural environment also oppressed them. We inspect the colony's social and natural environment, and analyze their influence on the settlers.…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A Change Must Come

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Singer’s goal in his article, “Famine, Affluence and Morality,” was to inform the viewers of their moral obligation to people suffering from obtaining their basic necessities. In relaying this to his audience, Singer used East Bengal’s current state of suffering as an example. Right now, people who reside in East Bengal are currently suffering because of lack food , shelter, and medical care. While referring to the current situation in Bengal, Singer argues that relatively affluent countries react to situations like Bengal’s in improper manner and it can not be justified. What Singer wants his audience to understand is that if we can prevent something horrible from happening, without causing more harm, we should do it. Singer not only believes that we ought to do it but he also feels that it is something we should , morally. In other words, it is the right thing to do to prevent anything bad from happening.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Refugee Speeches

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page

    Conditions at the refuge camp are unwelcoming.The wooden buildings are junky and falling apart and there is a fence with barbed wire that encloses the camp. The children at the camp do not have much food and really love sweets. They had raggedy clothes until people started giving them hand me down clothes.…

    • 246 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Memoir: The Homeless

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The moment I looked out the window of the car and my eyes turned to the row of homeless people weaving its way through the traffic begging for money, I jumped out of my seat. It was my first visit to India after leaving the country for the United States. The homeless people's’ hands were making weird gestures and thumping the windows of the honking cars. I could not digest what I was seeing! While reaching out to an old woman to give her some money, I thought about what non homeless people could do to help those without a home and basic needs. Then, I asked myself a question. Why not give them something that will be with them forever and help them out of their poverty and teach them valuable skills? After all, a mountain of…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Glt1 Task 1

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Unfortunately, this wealth is not shared equally throughout Indian society. India has innumerable amounts of people that are living in horrible poverty in thousands of slums Although some of the poor have benefited from the increased demand for construction workers and domestic services, they are still not paid sufficient wages to meet the rising cost of living. Choices by younger adults to become more independent and take on less traditional roles, often results in conflicts between the older and younger generations (Parande,…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the scorching July heat, a man walks on the footpath headed to his destination with files clutched under his armpits. His demeanor and his strides were of a much younger person but the broad daylight revealed the lines of wrinkles and lumps on his face indicating that he was no less than a 70 year old man. And when I looked around I saw many such old and middle aged people walking about with paper files clutched under their armpits heading toward the post office, photocopiers or to any yellow walled office of a government official. Their mannerism and their stiff style of walking indicated that they are retired government officials. Then my thoughts jumped to the bad, yet in some way comical situation of our country. The officials were known to be corrupted and so were expected to roam around in land cruisers. Yet this man climbed out of a rickshaw, argued with him over few rupees and headed towards a photocopier. He may have walked at least a mile to save his auto fare. So all I could relate him with was with an honest ex officer who is now, despite his old age and tiring limbs is doing some paperwork, perhaps for himself or for anyone in his family. That meant he is not very well off and is maybe living on a pension. Than my thoughts wandered on his income and on several honest people who live and survive on income the state provides. Anyone can guess now that the man may not be very well off or has to be a real penny pincher. Funny how my thoughts shift from one place to another? Any how, so I was wondering exactly how much does this state provides to them? And even today how our state relies on photocopies and paperback system. Where was the term of the world becoming a global village? It sure was not only restricted to private sectors? Now that sir, is pure discrimination. And one thing I have most commonly noticed is why in the world are they not carrying around their data is some sort of electronic backup? Using technology should actually cut costs in…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the sixteenth century, we began to see institutions developed to care for a variety of people in need. This did not just include the elderly or disabled, but any dependent poor, sick, orphaned children, widows, insane, and even minor criminals. These institutions could be considered a predecessor to the nursing homes that eventually followed (Morris, 1995). Poor laws in Europe gave rise to these institutions referred to as workhouses, almshouses, or poorhouses. They provided very minimal nursing care, and the care was often provided by “pauper nurses” who were not trained and usually inmates themselves, often alcoholics. Agnes Jones, a Nightingale trained nurse visited a Liverpool Infirmary in 1864 and reported “deplorable” conditions. She was forced to dismiss 35 pauper nurses for drunkenness and stated that bed clothes had not been washed for months (Ebersole & Touhy, 2006).…

    • 1993 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays