Preview

Banquet Hall Collapse Case Study

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
827 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Banquet Hall Collapse Case Study
Introduction A banquet hall collapsed within 30 seconds during the wedding party in Jerusalem on May 24, 2001 resulting in many casualties. This incident happened at that time when people were dancing on the fourth floor of the building. This disaster was due to the failure of many strategies, which were interacted with each other. Now, these strategies are being discussed the causes of which were the reason of the dance hall disaster.

Engineering Strategy The engineering strategy was a main failure in the case of banquet hall collapse of Israel. The engineering and works department did not pay attention to the conditions of buildings in the city. It should be a duty of the engineering department to check the conditions of building every year to make sure that building is meeting the safety standards and therefore they will not be a need for building elimination. There should be restrictions for the amendments in any constructed building during the reconstruction. As in this case the whole structure of the building changed when some pillars and walls were removed during the renovation which weakened the building. It was the duty of engineering department to examine the building not only this building but also other buildings on a regular basis.

Construction Strategy There is a need to adopt new construction strategies in the country. As Israel is situated in an earthquake zone, so the construction strategies must be formulated and strictly implemented in the country. In this case the Pal-Kal construction method was used which is a cheap method having metal plates and thin sheets of concrete. Pal-Kal method is considered the cheapest and lightweight method among other methodology. The dance hall was built by using the Pal-Kal method of construction, which was unable and weak enough to bear the weight and pressure of the people during their dance because of this, the banquet hall collapsed. Powerful and strong construction methods are necessary to use in the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    For decades intelligent, ambitious, business minded women have had their careers stunted by the boys’ club cooperate glass ceiling that exists in companies all across, not just the United States, but across the globe. Women have had to take a backseat to men even though they have had the same education, training, and drive as their male counterparts. Women have been bashing their heads against the glass ceiling trying to gain access to the boardrooms and CEO offices of cooperate America with the end result being the concussions they have sustained for all their hard work and dedication. It has taken the persistence and hard work of a few pioneer women to finally begin to crack this glass ceiling and ultimately shatter…

    • 2014 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Construction projects involve use of heavy machinery, execution of numerous work activities simultaneously. Working environment like in Pakistan where safety culture does not prevail results in increased vulnerability to accidents thus frequent emergency situations on construction projects. The author being a Project Manager on construction projects have experienced number of emergency situation involving loss of life of worker. The Safety Rules requires that the constructor shall establish Emergency Response Procedures for every project, Life Insurance of worker is also mandatory clause of the contract agreement in Pakistan but normally not implemented in letter and sprite. This article will be useful to assist constructors in developing Emergency Response Procedures. Detailed Emergency Plan helps to minimize the human suffering and economic losses that can result from emergencies.…

    • 2157 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The patient is a 81-year-old female who presented to the ED after a fall several days ago. The patient when she fell was found by the daughter on the floor and was taken to the emergency room at St. Joe's, evaluated and then sent home and since that time the daughter has found that the mother is needing more assistance with dressing and ambulation and other simple chores. There is a definite change in her ability although prior to that she was somewhat limited. Her past medical history calls for a number of allergies, hypertension, dyslipidemia, and some anxiety disorder. The only things on the physical is that she very pleasant but confused. She is in no apparent distress. She is tachycardic, blood pressure is stable. There is no major…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States currently depends on approximately 1.1 million fire fighters to protect its citizens and property from losses caused by fire. Of these fire fighters, approximately 313,000 are career and 823,000 are volunteers. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) and the U.S. Fire Administration estimate that on average, 100 fire fighters die in the line-of duty each year. In fiscal year 1998, Congress recognized the need for further efforts to address the continuing national problem of occupational fire fighter fatalities and funded NIOSH to implement a fire fighter safety initiative.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Civil Engineers build significant structures that can last more than a century, some of these structures such as Burj Khalifa, pyramids and evil towers in France can be considered as landmarks, because of its history and its beauty of design. Civil Engineers study the four factors of building structures to determine which tools and materials they will use in order to build permanent structures. Although engineers studying the factors and take the determination, there is some disasters occurred in many places because of many reasons. Nick Spurrier said “There will always be failures or disasters as engineers and designers push the boundaries by building taller buildings, longer bridges, or by reaching further into space”. In this outline I will show some of engineering disasters that happened before and what are the reasons.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The hotel was equipped to conduct an open concept atrium,conference hall and more with 40 story hotel tower. Inside the architecture, the second,third and fourth floor was connected with three walkways and it was 50 feet height,17 feet width and 145 feet long. The project was initiated on 1976 with Gollum-Colaco International Incorporation (G.C.E) as the structural engineering team and the construction was begun in spring of 1978 and in early December the project started to erect the atrium. By the following February, Havens steel company modified the design on connection rod of second and fourth floors walkway from a single rod to double rod to enhance the strength. On the consecutive October during the construction, the part of atrium collapsed and an inspection team was made for the investigation regarding the incident and G.C.E cleared all the steel connections at the premise and it was open on 1980 to public. After that on 1981,July 17 at an eve the hotel witnessed a loud crack at second and fourth floor walkways and it crashed down to the ground floor.There were about 2000 at the premise for a dance competition, in that 114 were put to death and more than 200 were severely injured.The failure occurred because of the several reasons and with a combination of things and the most thing was the design of walkway.The proposed design was…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The city group center was a unique example that shows what engineers can accomplish. The location where the group of engineers was trying to locate the building already had a church at that location. Instead of demolishing the church, they built around it. In the beginning they decided that the building will be built on columns that will raise the building above the level of the church. Normally a raise building would have large columns on the four corners. Unfortunately, one of the corners would be directly through the church. Engineers define ways to move the column to the middle of the side of the building while still maintaining the structural integrity of the building. LeMessurier later found out that if the wind blows quarterly the building is not going to be protected, by the time the large wind blows. The additional loads will be brought down an imaginatively designed trussed frame, which incorporated wind braces on the outside of the tower. By the time when LeMessurier discovered the problem had to act quickly. He decided to step up and face the mistake, even though the price to deal with the problem could be outrageous.…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Construction is the largest industry in the world, benefiting all stakeholders. Improved productivity thought virtuous collaborating will help in bringing to the owner a quality facility, in a shorter time, at lower cost. When we look to ethics in the area of construction quality, time and cost are the area of concern to focus. The architect/engineer focuses on the value-added design activity rather than spending effort to resolve a problem arise between the disappointed owners and the contractors. Contractors focus on their strengths of quality of work and efficient building execution in general.…

    • 4564 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Riba Design

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Construction strategy needs to be cinsidered including offsite fabrication and develop health and safety strategy. Sustainability strategy is the strategy for delivering the sustainability aspirations. Maintenance and operational strategy is the strategy for the maintenance and operation of a building, including details of any specific plant required to replace components. Handover strategy and risk assessments have already been defined. Research and development is project-specific research and development responding to the initial project brief or in response to the concept design as it develops. Project execution plan is produced along with the project lead and lead designer. The construction strategy is a strategy which considers certain aspects of a design that may affect the building or logistics of a construction project or possible the health and safety aspects. The health and safety strategy covers all aspects of health and safety on a project. The sustainability checkpoint for this stage is 2 and the information exchanges demand the concept design including defined structural and building services design, related project strategies, preliminary cost information and final project…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This assignment was to investigate the constructor’s role so I want to talk about that a little bit. After learning about how this project failed I realized how important it is for construction managers to have a basic understanding of structural design. Had the construction manager on this Hartford Civic Center job understood the need for a structural engineer I might not be writing this paper. How he overlooked the deflection is shocking, that is a huge red light to get some structural help, especially on a job of this magnitude. In looking at the construction process a little broader than that of the construction manager; everyone involved, from the architect and engineer, to the sub-contractors doing the labor need to group together and work as a unit so failures like this don’t occur. It seems like there was a huge lack of communication between parties involved. Communication is a huge part of achieving and accomplishing a project successfully. This cannot happen or problems and failures like this will…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These were usually non-seismically engineered residential structures, in which the walls were not designed to resist the significant lateral loads created by the heavy tile roofs during shaking (EQE). The more engineered building structures, particularly reinforced concrete and some steel reinforced concrete (SRC) construction will be examined in this report. There was also damage to steel structures; they generally performed better due to their flexibility, but failure and collapse of steel buildings coincided with lack of code development as will be discussed regarding concrete buildings.…

    • 1963 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Citicorp Center , today known as the Citigroup Center, is one of the most identifiable characteristics of the New York City skyline. The story of Citicorp Center’s structural engineer, William LeMessurier is a very enlightening story in engineering ethics and very educational to every design engineer . In fact, Le Messurier inventive use and positionning of the big columns bent a "design marvel" (Hegarty) , but those very fundamentals might have been the source for a collateral disaster and engineering scandal. Capitalizing on good fortune, the ruinous end of LeMessurier’s profession was prevented and, as a substitute, his importance in the design professional society increased to new heights. In this essay we shall examine how Le Messurier failed or succeeded to abide by the legal responsibilities and the ethical codes of engineering.…

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One of the major reasons for the collapse of the West Gate Bridge was the inappropriate selection of the management for a project of that scale. Thus management should be laid stress upon.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Out of all the issues present, one of the biggest problems in this whole situation is lack of communication. The departments were lacking goals and planning process due to lack of direction from leadership. The engineering department was unsure of the future workload, leading them to feeling anxious for their future workload. The roles and responsibilities seem unsure between the public works director and city engineer. There is a lot of miscommunication or lack of communication taken place to implement all the changes at once.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It is the belief of OSHA that if these regulations were followed the tragic accident could have been avoided. The legal issue is whether or not the courts and the construction company itself should up hold the violations of specific OSHA standards.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays