Preview

Banning the Burqa in Europe

Best Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2367 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Banning the Burqa in Europe
Banning the Burqa in Europe:
European Society’s Attempt to Prohibit Islamic Religious Expression
Jeannine Peters
Excelsior College
SOC 332 – Religion and Society
Dr. Thomas Russell
December 15, 2010

Abstract

Tensions between the Muslim population in Europe and the dominant European society have risen to the point that riots and protests have resulted motivated by the resentment of the other party. To intensify these tensions, a ban on the burqa, a form of religious expression for Muslim women, has been discussed or put into effect in many European countries. It is concluded that this ban is a form of oppression and subjugation of the Muslim population and functions to serve the interests of government officials and the dominant European society by attempting to protect national identity, blunt fundamentalism, and alienate the Muslim population to maintain their subjugation. Compromises and negotiations between the two varying cultures seem almost impossible and solutions will not be met unless there is greater initiative to stop what is truly causing such ideas of hate and racism towards the Muslim population, specifically negative portrayals of Muslims in the media.

Banning the Burqa in Europe:
European Society’s Attempt to Prohibit Islamic Religious Expression
Due to fear of losing national identity and rising fundamentalism, concern for human rights and security, and distrust and miscommunication between two extremely varying cultures, there has been conflict and debate amongst the dominant European society and the Muslim society in Europe over the right of Muslim women to wear the burqa, “a loose garment (usually with veiled holes for the eyes) worn by Muslim women especially in India and Pakistan,” in public places (WordNet, n.d.). This debate has stirred controversy and raised tensions amongst these varying cultures and has caused the emergence of the argument, Is banning the burqa an attempt to protect the human rights and dignity of



References: WordNet. (n.d.). Definition of Burqa. Retrieved December 15, 2010 from http://wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn?s=burqa Prybuok, Benn. (2007). The Changing Demographics of Europe & their Political Implications for the 21st Century French Riots: Nights of Rage and Fire. (2006). CBC News. Retrieved December 15, 2010 from http://newsinreview.cbclearning.ca/wp-content/uploads/2006/01/riots.pdf Marquand, R. (2010, July 6). In land of few burqas, France debates a ban. Christian Science Monitor, p 2010). Running for cover. Economist, 395(8682), 66-67. Retrieved from Academic Search Complete database Colemen, Isobel Fatima, Mariam, Nagham, Sitara, & Yun. (2010). Behind the Muslim Veil: a Qualitative Analysis of Pakistani Female Students’ Views towards Veiling. Cross-Cultural Communication, 6 (1). Retrieved from All Academic database. Amiraux, Valerie Gopalan, Sandeep. (2010). Behind the Burqa. New York Times, A1+. Retrieved from All Academic database.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Anne Applebaum’s "Veiled Insult" first appeared in the Washington Post in 2006. In this essay, Applebaum aims to convince her readers that it is disrespectful for Muslim women to wear their headscarves or niqabs (full bodied cloak) in our western society, just as it is disrespectful for our women to go to their society uncloaked. In delivering her message she also brings to attention the political issue of whether or not it is religious discrimination to allow, or not allow muslim women to wear their cloaks, and in the end she gives us her opinion, “it isn’t religious discrimination or anti-Muslim bias to tell her that she must be polite to the natives, respect the local customs, try to speak some of the local patois -- and uncover her face.” Applebaum uses her personal experiences combined with her American worldview to convince her readers (the American public) that for Muslim women to wear their cloaks in American culture is disrespectful and insensitive. Although those techniques may have worked, her strongest argument is perhaps playing on the emotions of the still sensitive and emotionally scarred, post 9/11…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    I think we can all agree, shirtless, old men in short-shorts are not a pretty sight. Hairy thighs and sweaty beer bellies—it’s practically blinding. I’d rather they all wear burkas. Burkas might have originated from oppressing roots, but they do promote modesty. It’s a universal fact: old, shirtless men could use some modesty. Don’t you agree? In a similar fashion, Diana Wagman uses popular opinion and cleverly chosen words to prove her points in her article, “First They’ll Come for the Burkas.” Wagman laces her article with relatable words and phrases—“Every summer when the temperature goes up, people start stripping down… Toddlers look cute in just a pair of shorts. Middle-aged men…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Khan, S. (2011, December 14). Hate it if you want, but don 't ban the niqab. The Globe Mail.…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why wouldn’t we tolerate the faithfulness to their religion and their modesty? If we ban the burqa it would appear as we attack the religious tolerance in Australia and the tradition. Why would we ban it, its their traditional clothes showing she is modest and loyal to her husband. Even some people in this country are wearing almost nothing. If we can tolerance the inappropriate clothes in our country why wouldn’t we tolerate the modesty of someone? In this country, according to 2006 census, only 1.7 percent are muslim and only a few of them have a tradition to wear burqa, especially Afghanistan and some middle eastern country. So, this much people are Muslim and only, i would say 10 % of them are wearing burqa. Even though some muslim women are freely to wear what they want, there are still some muslim women who chose to wear the burqa. And they are only a few people. We should not be copying other’s nation’s style and thought to ban the burqa. Mr Moselmane stated, 'There is no urgency required to expedite further divisions amongst our harmonious multicultural…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Secondly, we also been conditioned to believe that a veiled woman is an oppressed woman. In truth women choose to wear or not wear their veils out of religious piety and social preference. These veils can also be used as a “tool of resistance” (Sensoy and Marshall, 124) “Women of Afghanistan documented the Taliban’s crimes against girls and women by hiding video cameras under their burqas and transformed the burqa from simply a marker of oppression to a tool of…

    • 1751 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Other types of head coverings that are the most recognizable include the niqab and the burqa. Both of these coverings completely conceal the hair and portions of the face but are slightly different. The burqa is recognized as a symbol of Islam around the world and wrongly associated with fundamentalist Muslim governments. A burqa is a garment that covers the body, head, and face. The wearer is able to see through a mesh panel in front of the face, but the fabric is thick enough that outside viewers cannot see the wearer’s face. The niqab is similar to the burqa because it conceals the head and body, but instead of a mesh panel in front of the face, there is a small slit that reveals the wearer’s eyes while the rest of the face is hidden by another piece of fabric. Although burqas have been required by some past extremist governments, they should not continue to be symbols of negativity for Muslim women. In order for the negative stereotypes involving Muslim head coverings to disappear, French society must understand that all Muslims do not represent terror groups or the fundamentalist side of the…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Banning Full-Face Veils would not only make Muslim women feel vulnerable to men as a sexual desire, it would also make them feel betrayed by the country or state they live in. Being told what to wear is like being told what to eat or who to hang out with, it is unjust. Muslim women should be able to dress how they would like without being judged or assaulted by anyone. The veil helps assure the women that they are not being looked at as a desire and in a way, wearing the veil helps make them feel closer to God. Enforcing laws against Full-Face Veils would be amiss because it would be stripping them of freedom of expression and religion.…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Beyond the Burqa

    • 274 Words
    • 1 Page

    The role of the Burqa is to conceal women’s bodies and/or face says Chris Moore whom wrote The Buirqa – Islamic or Culture?. Islamic men believe that women should wear the burqa as a sign of respect and loyalty to the family but where did they get this idea? Moore says many people would think it is Islamic religion but you can’t really say that and be completely accurate. The reason being is because of these facts Moore states he says that is you read the Quran ( the Muslim Bible) it doesn’t gives that as one of the laws that women specifically have to follow. Rather it says that both men and women should follow a dress code but does in fact say that women have to cover their chest, lengthen their garments to conceal their body as respect for themselves and for both men and women should wear the most important garment of all which is righteousness and modest conduct. Nowhere does it mention or require women to wear such garments as a burqa I feel that Quran just wants women in Muslim community to carry themselves in a respectable manner in society. With the information I got from the passage is that the only reason women have to wear the burqa is because men want to feel as if they have power and control over the women in their society I also feel that women should stand up for each other and make a change to stop this in their culture.…

    • 274 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 2011, my aunt Leila, who lives in Paris, was stopped by law enforcement because she was wearing a burqa, an outer garment worn to cover the entire body and face for religious and cultural reasons. She was fined 150 euros which is equivalent to about 205 U. S dollars, and such fines can be up to 200 euros. Leila was nearly arrested because she was resisting the force they were using against her to try to get her out of public by moving her to a more secluded location. Many others have experienced situations similar to what my aunt has, and the public debate has been going on for years before and after the law went into effect, continuing to fuel fire on both sides.…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Banning The Burqa Campaign

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages

    John Hirst’s article ‘Should we ban the burka?’ (2014) in The Australian newspaper provides us with some of the arguments for banning the burqa. It also contextualises society’s perceptions as it is a relatively representative position of many Australians both liberal and conservative. It is important to note though that The Australian newspaper’s editors are often critiqued by third-party scholars for an alleged bias as the newspaper often reflects the views of its owner, Rupert Murdoch a very wealthy Australian-born, American citizen with strong conservative ties. Observing this potential bias we can dissect Hirst’s arguments in favour of a burqa ban. Foremost in his argument is that wearing full body clothing is consistent with an attitude of “I can see you but you cannot see me”. He argues that this shows “contempt” for Australian values as it “discourages normal human interaction” on the basis that facial signals cannot be read (‘Should we ban the burqa?’, 2010, para. 3). This point seems fair in an open society such as Australia’s, however, this does not qualify as a reason for enforcing what women can or can’t wear. It may be a noble end but it is in no way a noble means. As outlined in earlier paragraphs the enforcement of such a ban denies the women it affects the agency to affect their own changes. The apparent neglect in addressing this point in the article is indicative of the accuracy of Mohanty’s argument that Western hegemonic discourse subjugates its…

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    With another outrage that happened not too long ago with Muslim women in Australia wearing their religious significance – the Burqa which is an outer garment worn in public covering majority of their bodies.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 2010, the controversial Bill 94 was introduced in Quebec. The bill would prohibit women wearing the niqab from accessing any public service and would allow them to be denied access to schools, non-emergency healthcare, daycare facilities, courtrooms and more. Furthermore, government employees would be banned from wearing the niqab to work. The Quebec government is petitioning to ban the niqab because they claim it is a symbol of oppression, that women only wear if forced by a male, and that their needs to be a law to protect women from being oppressed by male relatives. However, many women who choose to wear the niqab who have spoken to the media that what they wear was in fact their choice, (Reynolds, 2010). While only approximately 100…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Negative Liberty In Canada

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This initially sparked controversy when there was a flurry of reaction to Stephen Harper's remarks on Twitter. The most popular Islamic clothing is a hijab that covers the head-and-shoulders; piece of cloth that covers the face, and the niqab that covers the entire face with the exception of few countries like Saudi Arabia where it is the law to wear the niqab. However, it is entirely up to Muslim women whether they choose to wear it or not. This situation is best described according to Isaiah Berlin’s “two concepts of liberty” (Swift 2014, 58-60).…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Charter Of Rights Essay

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Illogically enough, this right is not compulsory all around the world. For instance, burkinis have been banned in fifteen towns in France, including Cannes and Nice. A burkini is a lightweight swimsuit worn by Islamic women that covers the entire body excluding the hands, face, and feet. Burqas, hijabs, and niqabs, also worn by Islamic women, have been banned in French towns as well. In one incident, just after the finalization of the burkini ban in Nice, a woman was confronted by French police for wearing a tunic. She was peacefully resting on a beach in Nice with her family. The unreasonable officers then forced the woman to humiliate herself by removing some of her clothing. They proceeded to give her a ticket, which unrightfully claimed that she was not “wearing an outfit respecting good morals and secularism.” The only component that is immoral about this situation is the infringement of a woman’s right to wear whatever she wants in public, and the harassment she faced in being coerced, with the threat of pepper spray, to undress. If this attack was actually about protecting secularism, then nuns would not be allowed to wear their religious habits in public, but they are. This ban is an attack on cultural…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Social tension was a regular factor culminating in the unrest in 2005, which is seen by some commentators “ as rebellion against police harassment, poverty and the racism of the French society” (Mooney 2008,p.111).…

    • 1967 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics