English 111
22 July 2013
American-Made Oppression
In “Evolution” by Sherman Alexie and “Ballad of Birmingham” by Dudley Randall both explain the suffrage and hardships their races had to endure. “Evolution” reveals the pressures that denatured the traditional culture of Native Americans. Where “Ballad of Birmingham” conveys a heartfelt message of a victimized child, whose mother’s efforts are not adequate to protect her child from racist hatred. Although both poems share a central theme of racial oppression and irony, Randall does a better job of conveying his message by creating a rhythmic flow and using simplicity; whereas, Alexie uses a contrasting method of prose and complexity.
Although the poems incorporate different racial groups, both ethnicities are antagonized by Caucasians. “Ballad of Birmingham” takes place during the Civil Rights Movement. During this era African Americans were mistreated, beat, tormented and even killed. The “Ballad of Birmingham” tells a story of a mother who lost her daughter as a result of racial hatred from whites. A similar occurrence happens in “Evolution”, where Native Americans become oppressed by whites. Originally, America was Native American’s homeland; however, white settlers tactically stripped them of their land and slaughtered many of them. “Evolution” tells of a white settler who befriended the Native Americans but used them for his own gain. In both poems they are abused by whites, but Randall’s poem is focused on racial hatred, while Alexie’s is also focused on exploitation. Not only do the whites harass the characters in both poems, but they eventually result in dark ironic deaths. Randall juxtaposes innocence and death by shocking the reader with a sorrowful ending. In his poem he makes the mother very cautious of her daughter’s safety and will not allow the daughter to protest in the freedom march. The mother is frightened at the thought of her daughter going to the freedom march because there will be, “clubs, and hoses, and guns and jails” (line 7 Randall). The only place the mother will allow her daughter to go is church. Churches are considered sanctuaries, they are places free of violence and are where people go to find peace. However, the poem ends with the church being bombed and the daughter being killed. Randall is referring to the 1963 Birmingham Church bombing that killed four children. Randall adds irony to his poem by having the freedom march seem dangerous; but, the church is actually where the violence occurs. Another specific example of irony within the poem is the fact that her mother dresses her in fancy church clothes, white gloves included, the same sort of attire in which one would be buried in.
Alexie distorts his poem by making the character “Buffalo Bill” seem as though he is helping the Native Americans. They all go to this white Buffalo Bill man for business and trade him all of their possessions. Historically, this commonly happened to Native Americans; they gave away their possessions in return for money. Many used this money to pay for the alcohol supplied by whites, eroding the economy of their culture. Alexie adds irony by having Buffalo Bill open a museum of these Native American’s bodies and items and charging their children admission to enter. In the end, Buffalo Bill symbolizes how some whites fostered Native American’s addiction to alcohol in order to make a better profit out of taking all their valuables.
The use of rhyme and repetition in “Ballad of Birmingham” allows Randall to exude an innocent appeal and remind the reader of key concepts in the poem. The use of rhyme is reminiscent of children’s poetry and gives the poem a pleasant tune. By making the poem rhyme it seems as though nothing can go wrong and it is somewhat predictable. However, Randall uses this as a tactic to give the reader a false sense of security, and then unexpectedly twists the poem with the daughter’s death: “Then lifted out a shoe… But baby where are you,” (line 32 Randall). This comes as a shock to the reader because the first impression of the poem is sweet and wholesome. This tactic allows the reader to grasp the change in the tone and recognize Randall’s underlying message of racial unfairness. Another device Randall uses is repetition: “No baby, no, you may not go,” (line 13 Randall). By repeating the phrase the reader can understand the mother’s persistency for her daughter’s safety. It shows that the mother in protective over her daughter and does not want her to get harmed. These literary devices make it easy for the reader to understand the significance of the mother’s concern and recognize the transition of innocence to death.
In order to easily allow the audience to comprehend how African Americans were oppressed, Randall constructs the poem in a very simplistic manner. Randall makes the poem very informative and comprehensible to the audience. The dialogue between the mother and daughter allow the reader to grasp the tension that is happening during this epoch. For example, the daughter asks her mother to, “March the streets of Birmingham…In a Freedom March today?” (Line 4 Randall). Since Randall includes Birmingham and tells that there will be a Freedom March the reader can understand a group of people are being plagued by injustice. The reader can infer that the group is African American because Birmingham is a region where many African Americans lived and fought for their rights. Another source that supports the identification of the group is that the girl’s hair is “night dark” (line 17 Randall) and her hands are “brown” (line 19 Randall). These small details show that there is a movement for rights taking place, and it is for a population of African Americans. The conflict can be seen when the mother rushes after she hears an explosion. After the destruction of the explosion, the mother searches through “glass and brick” (line 29) and finds her daughter’s shoe. These details show that the explosion killed her daughter who was inside the church. From all of these clues, an outsider can understand that there was a bombing in Birmingham that killed a black girl.
Alexie uses a prose like writing style in his poetry to convey his message in a straight forward manner. Prose is a form that rebels from standard poetic form. Instead of using rhyme schemes, meters, repletion and other literary devices, prose sticks to getting the point across in a simple unembellished way. This is beneficial because it doesn’t expend the reader’s energy on literary nuisances and focuses on the Indian’s misfortune. Because the ideas in the poem are complex it allows the audience to focus solely on piecing together the theme of the poem. Alexie also writes in tercets allowing details to stand out. It simplifies the poem so each stanza has a singular idea associated with it.
In order for one to grasp the meaning of “Evolution” Alexie made it complex: it is essential to have outside knowledge in order to understand the storyline. The poem’s main characters are “Buffalo Bill” and the Indians. If one does not understand or know the history behind Buffalo Bill, then they will not thoroughly comprehend the poem’s message. Buffalo Bill had a show called “Buffalo Bill’s Wild West” in the 1890s where he showcased a dramatized version of the Wild West, which frequently showed Native Americans as savages. Buffalo Bill is a symbol for white people’s mentality during this era. He was known as a supporter of Native Americans because he provided them with employment and worked closely with them. However, at the same time he deteriorated their native culture by displaying them in his shows as uncivilized and uneducated. Alexie refers to Buffalo Bill as the pawn owner who, “Takes everything the Indians have to offer,” (line 7 Alexie). Buffalo Bill takes their culture, modifies it, and resells it for his own profit. Another detail that may be obscure is that the pawn shop is “right across the border form the liquor store,” (line 2 Alexie). This is a reference to Native Americans being given alcohol in order for whites to negotiate better deals. When the history is known the reader can interpret Alexie’s message. Without this knowledge the audience would be left with the literal representation of a pawn shop, liquor store, and museum; with no conception of the Indian’s manipulation.
Both poets have similar messages that they want to exude but Randall does a better job by captivating the reader with his flow and details. Randall’s work is much less predictable than Alexie’s, making his ending much stronger and more emotional. Alexie’s prose style is closer to bullet points rather than a flowing poem which removes the artistic impact of a poem. Randall’s poems can also be relatable to many people, most parent’s worst fear is losing a child. The fact that the mother did her best to protect her daughter and ensure her safety, yet still loses her is positively horrifying to the audience, giving it the ultimate emotional appeal.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Richard Wright was determined to make a profound statement. In his novel, Native Son, he endeavors to present the “horror of Negro life in the United States” (Wright xxxiii). By addressing such a significant topic, he sought to write a book that “no one would weep over; that would be so hard and deep that they would have to face it without the consolation of tears” (xxvii). Native Son is a commentary on the poverty and helplessness experienced by blacks in America, and it illustrates the abhorrent ways that blacks were treated, describes their awful living conditions and calls attention to the half-hearted efforts offered by white sympathizers. Told from the perspective of his character Bigger Thomas, Wright crafts a story depicting the oppressive lives endured by Negroes and makes it so despicable that it grabs the attention of the reader and forces him to reevaluate the state of society. There is much in this novel that would cause a reader to cry, but, to Wright’s point, the topic is so significant that it resonates more deeply and elicits a deeper response.…
- 1364 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
“One of Bird's most serious charges against Alexie is that in Reservation Blues he ‘'prey[s]' upon’ his community and culture in perpetuating damaging stereotypes, including that of the drunken Indian. As she puts it, ‘Stereotyping native people does not supply a native readership with soluble ways of undermining stereotypes, but becomes a part of the problem, and returns an image of a generic 'Indian' back to the original producers of that image’ (49)” (Evans).…
- 1280 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
“Notes of a Native Son” is a first person narrative about James Baldwin who lived with his family in Harlem during a difficult time for the equal rights movement in America. Racism through Baldwin’s experience shows its potential to feed off of itself in a vicious cycle, with one person’s hate leading to someone else’s. He has first hand experience with this through his father, a man who, while considered free, felt the pressures of racism throughout his life. The hate Baldwin’s father had towards white people was a reflection of the current state of equal rights in the country. Baldwin finally understands his father’s feelings when he moves to New Jersey and sees racism for himself. He eventually comes full circle to realize the true problem with racism, but he is too late to reconcile with his father.…
- 964 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
For many years, this country has been unjust and humanity has not always been treated equally. Dudley Randall, who is most famous for his literary contributions, wrote a poem called "Ballad of Birmingham" representing the inequality and racism during the early 1960's (Encyclopedia.com). The main themes of the poem are racism and the struggle of African Americans around the time of the civil rights movement in 1964 (Encyclopedia.com). Randall's poem focuses on a child that lives in Birmingham, Alabama who wishes to participate in a freedom march. The mother refuses to let her go, because it is too dangerous for someone her age. Although the streets are not safe, the mother tells her daughter to go to the church believing nothing will harm her in the place of God. To her shock, the child was killied due to an explosion that happened while she was inside (Encyclopedia.com). In his poem "Ballad of Birmingham" Dudley Randall explores the themes of racism and struggle; ultimately, using elements of style such as repetition, irony, rhythmical patterns, and pattern of stresses, he argues that anything can happen, even when one least expect it (Encyclopedia.com).…
- 2078 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
The texts “Son of Mine” a poem by Oodgeroo Noonuccal and Other Word’s “Jim Crow Alabama” a graphic sketch by Khalil Bendib both explore conflicting perspectives in relation to racism. Noonuccal’s purpose is to respond to her son’s questioning of the racism he is subjected to, “My son, your troubled eyes search mine…” her views conflict within the text as she expresses two views, one of how white people treated Indigenous Australians and on how she as an Indigenous mother adopts a positive perspective with a view to a complementary change. Other Word’s “Jim Crow Alabama” observes how though the Jim Crow laws have been abolished they have in the illustrator’s view in fact returned in another form, this time discriminating against immigrants.…
- 706 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“Ballad of Birmingham” is a poem written by Dudley Randall about the bombing of a church in Birmingham. This poem shows us what happens to a mother’s little girl because someone didn’t like the changes that were happening in America when African American people wanted equal rights. Only the little girl wanted to protest because she wanted a better future for America. She aspired to be someone important when she grew older, not wanting to be treated differently because color of her skin. The end of the poem tells a sad story of how her dreams of being someone…
- 662 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The theme of this poem is life. We all deserve to live, despite the hardships we have faced or the wrongs we have committed. Randall writes, “Never conspire with death to set me free / but let me know such life as pain can give.” (3-4). Although his life has been painful and rough, he asks to not be set free. Despite all of his sufferings, he is asking for one gift – life. “Even though I turn such traitor to myself / as beg to die, do not accomplice me.” (9-10), here Randall is admitting to letting himself or another person down and wishes to die for his mistakes, but he knows that death is not the answer. The happenings throughout Randall’s life have made him calloused, soul-less:…
- 661 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many themes that are the same between the moviee and the poem. The first theme that’s the same is that they both have Judgment in them. They both have judgment in them by having the movie judge the blacks in most things that they do and in the poem they judge them by calling the blacks hogs instead of their real name. Another theme they both have in common is racism. The movie has it by the whites calling the blacks names and being disrespectful to them and we also see and read that in the poem. That’s just two of the many themes they have in common.…
- 968 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Racism is intolerance and hatred of another race. Many protest poems are used by composers in society to express their desire for social change. “Strange fruit” by Lewis Allen and “took the children away” by Archie Roach are haunting lyrics protesting against the area of racism. Both poets have been influenced by either personal events or events occurring in society. Both Allen and Roach effectively use strong poetic techniques and pursue subject matter to the audience through racism to create a desire for social change in the society.…
- 1246 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In the first stanza of the poem, the use of the word ‘child’ represents the innocence and lack of understanding African-American youth had on the issue of racial prejudice against blacks. The mother attempts to warn her child of the potential danger that would be at the Freedom March and explains, “‘clubs and hoses, guns and jails / Aren’t good for a little child.’” She believes that her daughter does not fully understand the implications of what the freedom march really is about. In this instance, the mother characterizes the status-quo of what has been the norm for many years; the segregation of African-Americans. While there had been opportunity to challenge their place in society, she is content with her life and the way things are. The daughter does not see the harm and explains, “But, mother, I won’t be alone. / Other children will go with me”. The use of ‘other children’ is the daughter’s claim that there are others of her age who share the same views of freedom and hope and want to make a change. She represents the youth and their eagerness to be a part of what is going on in society, even though some might see them as merely ‘children’ who don’t understand how their actions could impact the future.…
- 988 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Dudley Randall was born 14 January 1914 in Washington, D.C. Randall led a life full of intellectual exploration, service, and literary entrepreneurship. He started writing poetry at an early age, and filled notebooks throughout his years, drawing on the civil rights movement, work experiences, travels, and personal experiences for inspiration. In addition to serving his country in the Pacific theatre during World War II, Randall worked for Ford Motor Company, the U.S. Postal Service, and several libraries. In the 1960s, he built one of the most important presses in American history, Detroit Free Press, and went on to publish many works of art of African American authors, as well as several books of his own poetry, including some truly classic pieces. In the poem "Ballad of Birmingham," Randall uses a sad tone and irony to describe the events of one of the most vivid chapters from the civil rights movement, the bombing of a church in 1963 that wounded 21 and cost four girls their lives. The poem begins with a dialogue between mother and daughter during which, ironically, the mother forbids the daughter to march for freedom, fearing that street were unsafe and filled with violence. Instead, she gives permission for the daughter to sing in the children's choir at their church. How could the mother know, of course, that the streets, that day, might have offered some relative safety? The tragedy, a central feature of many ballads, becomes especially clear and poignant at the end, when the mother searches for her missing daughter.…
- 818 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Conor Mulroy Ms. Millar English 2 September 30, 2014 Native Son by Richard Wright In this story and in many others of Richard Wright’s books, he explains his main theme for racism over and over. In Native Son, he puts us into another persons point of view (Bigger Thomas) to explain the reasons for what they did. In the story, Bigger Thomas was a murderer.…
- 521 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the history of Afro-American literature, quite a lot of black writers put up with the same question: how can Afro-American writers react to racial discrimination? To sum up, there are two totally different opinions coexisting— one is mild and the other is radical. As to those two opinions, black writer Richard Wright serves as a watershed. Prior to Richard Wright, the heroes in black writers’ works are very obedient and obsequious. In 1940, Richard Wright published Native Son which created a completely new image of black people being filled with violence and hatred. Native Son is just like a bombshell making a stir in American literature and American society. The new generation of black people would rather die for dignity than live in disgrace. The background of this novel containing three parts—Fear, Flight, Fate, was based on Chicago in the 1930s. The novel gives an account of a black youth named Bigger and his life experience. Shortly after Bigger is hired by the white man Mr. Dalton, he kills his daughter Mary in accident. In order to escape the punishment, Bigger, with great fear, tries to calumniate the Communist Jan. After the truth is exposed, he has to escape and is captured by eight thousand white policemen later. In the end, he is sentenced to death. The reason why Native Son can occupy the important position in American literature is that the author uses the writing techniques of realism to reflect the furious…
- 2086 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In his poem “The Little Black Boy” from “Songs of Innocence,” William Blake exposes his white Christian audience to an innocent little black boy who narrates his own story. The little boy, sitting under a tree in his mother’s lap, learns a valuable lesson about color and God. This poem was written as the abolitionist movement was recently becoming known. Blake and other writers participated to advance the cause of this movement by exposing the white Christian audience to the message of change. Transcending color, the spiritual and divine love seems to be the overall theme of the poem, however, a deep examination of the poem reveals the quintessential theme. Seeking to move his readers and convince them to share his unique vision of the world, Blake successfully invokes the innocence of the little black boy in order to advance not only the message of change but more importantly to lay his argument for the "Universal Man." As a challenger to the religious and political authority and an fervent supporter of the American and French revolution, Blake‘s poem "The Little Black Boy" addresses the metaphysical question of the divine and what he calls the "Universal Man" from the perspective of the state of innocence of the human soul.…
- 1682 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Wright’s novel describe life of black people back in the 1930’s. wright’s has made an outstanding literature work revealing to the reader the racist persecution of the black with the help of naturalism. from the very beginning the influence on naturalism on this book can be easily observed. wright does not give us even a tiny hope the he will get an illusion of happieness he so much used to. wright is very suitable for the use of naturalism on his novel.…
- 976 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays