Preview

Article Rebuttal Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
789 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Article Rebuttal Analysis
Article Rebuttal
BCOM/275
July 21, 2013

Article Rebuttal

For the past 17 months, shown on every television news channel across the United States. The case of George Zimmerman, and the shooting death of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin. Like every year, the media will take a case and publicly turn the story into a circus. The rebuttal article for this paper is a story written by Oliver Knox of Yahoo.com titled, "Obama: Trayvon Martin could have been me 35 years ago." Further discussion will analyze the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by Oliver Knox, and identify any logical fallacies in the argument. The article is about President Barack Obama making his first public comments on the George Zimmerman acquittal.
…show more content…
News articles written and posted by Yahoo.com reports a straightforward message to their audience. Reporting stories down the middle, never too left or right with the occasional bias author either for or against a particular topic. Keeping political views down to a minimal. This particular article matches other similar articles written on the same news story. Second, Oliver Knox wrote the story on the statements and words of the president as he addresses the American public. Third, the genuine author of this story is President Barack Obama himself, Oliver Knox just wrote his statement. The audience that the president focused on in his address is the African American people. Using his own personal experiences, the president can relate to the ongoing outrage of the African American public. President Obama feels the pain and disappointments of the outcome of the …show more content…
This incident could easily be him 35 years ago as a young person dealing with racism in America. Concern that African Americans think that this case developed on race. A belief in the legal system would have a different outcome if Trayvon were white. Even after juror number B37 came out stating that race had no issue to the outcome of the case. Both the jury and legal experts stated that Zimmerman and Trayvon made poor judgment the night, which led to the death of Trayvon. Statements by the jury referring the only reason for Zimmerman 's acquittal because the way the "stand your ground" law is written. This article also provided some good highlighted points. The president encouraged his audience to support and encourage the young people of this country by helping them achieve and succeed in life. To be more influential and guide them on the right track. If the young people do not have the support from family, friends, neighbors, and the community, who will help them stay on the righteous path (Obama,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Trayvon Martin Article

    • 1161 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Dr. Brown’s article “Requiem for Trayvon Martin: When Will America Stop Destroying the Lives of Black Boys” moved me as I was thoroughly reading it. I felt a sense of anger and disbelief running through my mind without realizing till I finished. The anger came from the verdict of Trayvon Martin’s case against George Zimmerman. And the disbelief came from the fact that white people tried to justify George Zimmerman’s actions by stating that historically black men are violent creatures so you can never be “too careful”. The main argument of the article is that blacks are arrested, prosecuted, and sentenced more harshly than whites, for similar criminal offenses. It still amazes me how the skin color you are born with can ultimately define your life, lifestyle, or whether you deserve to die or not.…

    • 1161 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Author David Horowitz has written an article called African-American Lynch Mob. In the article Mr. Horowitz is expressing his frustration with the way African –American civil rights leaders, namely Reverend Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton are inciting a lynch mob mentality in regards to the death of Trayvon Martin. Trayvon Martin, who was a 17 year old African-American male, was shot to death by George Zimmerman who happens to be Hispanic.…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In January, the Philadelphia Inquirer reported that the United States government stated that in December, 2012 “The number of unemployed, 12.2 million, was little changed, and the 7.8 percent unemployment rate has been at, or near, that level since September [2012]”. (Loyd, 2013) I have always found these statistics somewhat suspect and misleading as they do not take into consideration those that stopped looking for jobs, fell off the unemployment rolls, or took jobs at a much lower pay scale then they were at previously in order to re-enter the workforce.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Trayvon Martin Shooting

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When Zimmerman was taken in to questioning he told the police that when he was going back to the car Trayvon attack him, and he got punch in his nose and his had banged in the…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ^ "Barack Obama at the DNC Winter 2007 Meeting" (video), Democratic National Committee, February 2, 2007…

    • 12427 Words
    • 50 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trayvon Martin

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many people reacted with so many emotions because this trial was a voice for the many killings and other crimes that happen daily but aren’t recognized by the police or justice system. This trial could have been an opportunity for the black community, specifically to get the lawfulness that they rightfully deserve. Some may say that this trial is not a reflection upon race but in reality it is because George Zimmerman brought race into it when he was on the phone with the 911 operator. After identifying and telling the 911 operator that Trayvon was black, Zimmerman stated that “these assholes always get away”. By categorizing Trayvon, a black male, as an asshole and saying these, race became apart of the trial. After hearing the recording, people were outraged that race wasn’t brought up in this trial because George Zimmerman clearly showed signs of outrage toward the “black assholes” and he felt the need to make sure they don’t get away again. Why was Zimmerman able to get away with what I would describe as a hate crime because he pursued Trayvon after realizing that he was black? If our justice was for equality then race would have been brought up during the trial, but once again it was not and a murderer was able to walk. This demonstrates how our justice…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trayvon Martin

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages

    February 26, 2012 at approximately 7:06pmEST Zimmernan placed a call to Florida Stanford police department stating Martins behavior was suspicious because he was cutting in between the houses. (wikipedia, 2012) It has also been heard and stated on a recorded call to the Florida Stanford police as Zimmernan is describing Trayvon as a suspicious black male up to no good, and used the racial slur "fucking coons" which is why this is no longer being called a self-defense case but is now being called a hate crime. October of 2009 the Matthew Shepard act was passed into law by President Barack Obama in response to the killings Matthew Shepard and James Byrd. Matthew was tortured and killed because he was perceived as a homosexual and James was tied to a truck and dragged by two white supremacists and was decapitated because he was African American. Both cases were determined to be hate crimes.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The flu shot. Should you or shouldn’t you get one? That is a very common question to ask as flu season quickly approaches. The Mayo Clinic offers an article on their website stating that the best way to avoid the flu is primarily by means of vaccination. Does this mean one cannot avoid the flu if they don’t receive the immunization? What happens to the people who cannot afford the shot, or those who cannot access the places to receive one? Is one to be plagued by sickness if they were to go against injecting the inoculation?…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In her article, she comments that “on the whole, people tend to take prisons for granted. It is difficult to imagine life without them” (Davis 15). Going back to Grewal’s argument, prisons are built with the purpose to ensure the safety of society. For security reasons, people tend to blindly trust the justice system, in the hopes that crimes will stop. One perfect example that shows the blind trust towards the criminal justice system is when Casper asks a white woman about the unfairness of the Zimmerman verdict, and in response the white women comments, “We need to trust the justice system” (Casper). George Zimmerman was found not guilty for the death of Martin Trayvon, a seventeen- year-old African-American high school student, who didn’t do anything other than looking suspicious in the eyes of the law enforcement. This again, goes back to the binary system of the “Us” versus “Them,” portraying delinquents as people of color. The mentally that criminals are people of color allows law enforcement to use racial profiling or suspecting of someone having committed a crime based on their race and ethnicity. Thus, people of color who live in poverty end up being the victims of…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A few weeks ago the media covered the riots in Baltimore due to the death of Freddie Gray. There was constant media coverage of buildings burning, stealing, and attacks on Baltimore Police Department and its property. However, there was hardly any coverage on the peaceful protesting in the Baltimore area and African-Americans speaking out against the destruction and violence in the city. Protestors were called “thugs” and “criminals” even by the president himself. However, President Obama did speak briefly on the peaceful riots in his speech; I find his term of the protestors a little harsh. I think this was the climax of the anger African-Americans have toward America and its law regarding the lives of young black men and women. If one thinks…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The front cover of TIME magazine, issued on December 10, 2007 was taken before the start of the presidential campaign in America, and the man on the front cover is Barack Obama – who was a favourite at the time. The bias of the picture, the cover’s anchorage and the article altogether show that the underlying purpose of this magazine’s issue was to influence readers to side with TIME and vote for this man. This cover resembles a famous picture taken of Martin Luther King Junior and serves to link Obama with the American Civil-Rights hero in order to influence the reader’s position towards Obama. This cover can be seen as a metaphor of the rise of the African American in society, as well as politics.…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What occurs in public is more than often presented in the media, without further explanation or opposing views. Similar incidents may occur, but race will play the factor of how the case is carried out. Trayvon Martin a seventeen year old African- American who was a victim of stereotyping due to the color of his skin. He was walking through a neighborhood with a hood on at night. Apparently, he looked suspicious, so instead of staying away like orders were given, Zimmerman shoots Trayvon and calls it self-defense. All of this could have been avoided if Zimmerman didn’t carry a perception that all black men were criminals or bad individuals. “While Zimmerman was armed with a gun, Trayvon met Zimmerman with only a cellphone, a bag of skittles, and a can of tea to shield himself” (Bell 89). He didn’t resemble no harm, but the color of…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Zimmerman Case

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Zimmerman Case has had its verdict yesterday and I would have written then, but I was busy building my thoughts. What I should cover first is why the Zimmerman Case is significant. It is not significant because of race, or the right to defend one's self. In defense of my position on the race aspect, the media has tried to portray Zimmerman as white, when, in fact he is Hispanic or as my wife is adamant about, Latino. Apparently, you can't call Hispanics Hispanics any more and you have to call them Latino. Ok, sure fine I don't really care what people want to be called; it has no bearing to me on the individual other than personal preference. So, if the media is not really sure what race Zimmerman is, the issue of race becomes moot, but it does show that there are other motivations in doing so as someone's race is a pretty big way of describing an individual to the public. I suspect that this has more to do with the Immigration Issue than race despite the media is trying to make be seen that way. Showing Latinos as white would go a long way toward naturalizing immigrants in the public's mind. The right to defend one's self, is not an issue either, in that it is a personal responsibility to do so. Following someone does not justify aggression if that person is acting within a prescribed and legal role, in this case, as a member of the community watch. They say Martin was just going out for Skittles and some sort of drink and that was all he had on him when he was being followed out of the area by Zimmerman. If he was going out to get these items, then why did he have these items on him when he was leaving. This seems suspect to me, but actually has little bearing on the point I am trying to make with this.…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Artikel Oppapers

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Leaders express their conviction clearly and emphasize the importance of trust. Whenever something happens, like Fox News reporters who were beaten in Tahrir Square (1.1), the disaster with the mines in Virginia (1.2) and something nice like a soccer championship (1.3) Obama shows that he supports people and he encourages people to continue their good work. He also emphasizes that everybody is family, so he stimulates the group feeling. This shows that Obama’s conviction is that people are equal and he has a lot of trust in people.…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Facebook

    • 1769 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Social Media is one aspect of technology that has recently taken the world by storm, affecting others’ lives as well as my own. One of the first and most influential texts I have ever encountered is the social media website Facebook. From this outlet of technology, I learned more about what was going on in the world and how people of all ages reacted to significant events and even led me to form my own opinions about the subjects. Facebook is also a very appealing website to me, allowing expression of one’s feelings and offering the ability to stay in contact with others. This social media giant has also become an addiction to my generation and has been allowed to define us in some ways. Although Facebook also has its disadvantages due to a lack of privacy and face-face interaction, all of these aspects of Facebook have impacted my life and the world as I have come to know it.…

    • 1769 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays