Preview

Analysis Of Fighting Your University By Mark Edmundson

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
928 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Fighting Your University By Mark Edmundson
Fighting Your University? The article "Who Are You and What Are You Doing Here? A Word to the Incoming Class" is written by Mark Edmundson who is an English professor at the University of Virginia. Edmundson's article is, as mentioned in the article title, a word to the incoming class. In this article, he reflects on what it means to get a proper or "real" education at a university or college. I will be focusing on what Edmundson means by getting a "real education" as this relates to me as a college student. In this reflection, I will be finding out why in order to get this type of education, you have to fight the university itself and why the university itself is a target for this fight. My examples that I picked to support this involve Edmundson …show more content…
What does he mean by this? Perhaps confronting your professors. Edmundson states, "If you want to get a real education, you're going to have to fight" (Edmundson 406). Here, he clearly states that if you want this so called "real education" you have to fight for it. The author emphasizes this idea of fighting a lot throughout the article and I believe that is him trying to prove that point. As a college student, I can relate a bit to this idea of having to fight. In the beginning of my first semester of college, My classes along with the professors were not the best. I think that Edmundson means that when you fight, you are not targeting the whole institute which you attend, but more specifically, the …show more content…
Edmundson states, ""professors don't pay full-bore attention to teaching, they don't have to work very hard-they've created a massive feather bed for themselves and called it a university" (Edmundson 408). I think by this, Edmundson means that professors feel like once their job is secure at their institute, they don't truly focus on the teaching aspect of their job. This is one problem that I have faced personally and another reason why I relate to this article. In the beginning of my first semester, I took a course where the professor would show up, lecture for the full duration, then dismiss us. The problem with this is that professors do not engage with their students, they lecture about the information but do not help us to understand this information that they are telling us. As Edmundson further explains, these types of professors are not ambitious, they secure their job at a university and feel as if they don't have to fully apply their teaching ability, just assign the course work on the syllabus and expect us students to get it done. If we were to "fight" our school, we would target those select teachers who feel that just lecturing in class would suffice as

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Teaching for Social Justice” is written by an English professor, community activist, student advocate and literary scholar, Carmen Carrasquillo Jay. She teaches all levels of composition and literature at Miramar College in San Diego. Carmen Carrasquillo Jay piece starts with her discussing a scene in the movie Good Will Hunting. She is unsettled with the scene that depicts community college students not being as committed or concerned about their education compared to the students who attend MIT, a prestigious university.…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Naomi Schaefer Riley use many effective rhetorical devices to strengthen her argument, she gets a little off topic towards the end of her article. The end of her essay lack the effective use of ethos and other rhetorical devices to keep the reader on track. The author keep coming back to Thiel’s idea which confuses the reader of her position in this argument. For example, she says, “so does Thiel’s offer suggest that a university diploma might be most useful lining a birdcage?” (10). By keep going back to Thiel’s plan for the students the article seems unprofessional and messy. It looks disorganized and takes away the intelligent tone she has established until this far in the article. By this unnecessary repetition the reader might…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Neal Gabler’s article “The myth that college is meritocracy” from The Week on January 22nd 2010 he talks about the way elite colleges operate with racial diversity. Colleges are widely perceived as racially diverse “meritocracy” says Gabler. The elite colleges must operate this way because it “benefits the people it is designed to benefit,” those atop “the prevailing social order.”…

    • 318 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In his book Why Teach?, Mark Edmundson has written an essay in which he approaches an argument about the paradoxical consumer culture surrounding education. The university professor takes a stance on the problems that he has both experienced in his own classroom and observed on campuses, and he assigns these problems—his claims—appropriate blames. Enough logic is used to make these “blames” more factual, and he often claims how things are and offers several reasons as to why. His essay, “Liberal Arts & Lite Entertainment,” originally written in 1997, begins with his own university before branching out to all those across the country, and it is followed by a deduction of student culture and professors. He gives hope to the idea of the acceptance and praising of “genius” (as opposed to the alienation students indorse so well) closer towards the end, narrowing his argument down to a more specific change…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    An exemplary example of how Edmundson wishes students should be is, Joon Lee. “Joon Lee is endlessly curious”(Edmundson 324), his personality and interests separate him from the crowd, who just “go with the flow”. Edmundson says that the only thing students care about are grades. Graff supports this by using the example of one of his undergraduates, when he asked her which course she prefers and she said, “Well, I’m getting an A in both”(Graff 328). This tells both authors that students don’t really care about learning but they only look after their own interests. In other words, they have lost a sense of curiosity. Graff goes on saying how students take classes that result in a “cognitive dissonance”. This means that students become confused by ideas presented to them in class that contradict themselves, but they never question authority. “Each course was challenging enough on its own terms, and to have raised the question of how they related would have only risked needlessly multiplying difficulties for myself” (Graff 340). Like Graff, Edmundson wishes students would challenge themselves and develop different interests on education. Students are satisfied by acquiring a good grade and then forget what they have learned right after. Both authors don’t support this way of thinking. Students can’t do anything about it, because the university has allowed this to…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this essay that came from Caroline Bird’s book “The Case Against College”, she claims that most students that are in school not because they want to be, but because it is now the thing to do or to get away from their parents. (Bird 647) She also goes on to say a little later essay that she notices when she goes on campus that the students look sad. She says, “I have been overwhelmed by the prevailing sadness on American campuses”. (Bird 469) Birds has very good arguments, from how expensive college is, why a lot of students fail out of class, to letting high school graduates make up their minds on whether or not they want to go to college or not.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    His first point expresses his distaste for the more “sensitive” academic environment that has come to be in recent years. “Because, with pure hearts and noble intentions, these educators are doing nothing less than presiding over what I will call the stupidification and…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis

    • 2324 Words
    • 10 Pages

    This essay argues that the Globe and Mail (G&M) article, ‘Don’t Teach Until You See the Whites of Their Eyes’ (18 August 2012), is persuasive with its primary target audience of G&M readers. Clifford Orwin, the author of this article, is a professor of political science at the University of Toronto. Furthermore, the main focus of this article deals with the fact that: “Real education requires real teachers and students, not disembodied electronic wraiths.” Through the rhetorical analysis of this editorial, this paper will demonstrate that its persuasiveness can be attributed to four key aspects: through an emphasis on the use of deliberative stasis; its use of ethos and logos; and through its effective use of rhetorical imagery. Before the case can be made for understanding how and why this article is persuasive, we need to begin with setting the context of the issue or exigence to which the article was responding and whether that response was timely and appropriate.…

    • 2324 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main problem I’ve had here were with professors who’ve gotten ahead or above themselves because of their level and tenure. I do agree, however, with Hacker and Dreifus when they said some professors “have no reasons to improve their teaching” (181).Some of my professors at Grambling State University are wonderful, were some aren’t as wonderful. Some professors come to class…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Education and Emerson

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Emerson says that schools drill things in your head, lose sight of what’s important and that they don’t inspire people to become better or be the next star of something like a musician, a poet, a reformer, someone like another genius. Schools don’t have many inventive masters they…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rose and Graff

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Two professors of different backgrounds, Mike Rose of California, and Gerald Graff, of Illinois, discuss the problems college students face today in America. Though similar in slight variations, both professors view the problem in different regards and prepare solutions that solve what they feel to be the heart of this academic problem.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For centuries institutes of higher education have been thought of as places where free speech and ideas can flow, free of restrictions. Universities and colleges alike served as hubs for people with different ideas to gather, argue, debate, and ultimately become more informed on various issues. However, over the past few years things have changed, and not for the better.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My mother never went to college. Despite—or perhaps [because] of—her lack of collegiate experience, she was a powerful influence on my ever-present desire for academic distinction. For her children, anything besides “extraordinary” was simply not an option. The constant pressure meshed painfully well with America’s flawed education system, which—not unlike my well-intentioned mother—continually creates an unhealthy environment of apathy in the face of competition. For the duration of my traditional education, I made intense efforts for a false, unfulfilling concept of academic success. I sacrificed my emotional well-being again and again for fleeting validation from any surrounding adults, in a desperate lifelong attempt to prove my worth…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many people can agree that with a good education, you can save yourself from working at a job that has a lot of hard labor, and can give yourself a career that you have always dreamed of having. In order to get a great education and relieve yourself from a job one wouldn’t want to have, one must attend a good school that is well operated, such in the way that they teach the right materials, and is properly funded so one can get the most out of the learning experience. Some schools may be funded differently because of their location and previous history on academics. Here in America, many schools are different from those from other countries. Authors such as Eleanor J. Bader, Jonathan Kozol, and Anu Partanen address issues about students and…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Is college For Everyone

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Since the first GI Bill was passed after World War II universities have been steadily increasing. Currently there are more than 4000 college like institutions in the United States. Public policy has been making higher education more reachable for example by creating federal student loan programs so everyone has a chance to attend college. But recently we have seen the cost of a four year degree drastically increase because Americans are seeing college as an obligation. “On “Real Education”” Robert T. Perry argues that we need more university and community college graduates. “Is College for Everyone” Pharinet is arguing that college is not for everyone. He states that there is too many students enrolled in school that don’t belong there. Roberts’s essay “On “Real Education”” is more persuasive because, not only did his writing appear on InsideHigherEd.com making him a more credible author but also because he argues his stance on college is for everyone using statistics and a believable explanation to back them up.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays