Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Administrative Law - Paper

Powerful Essays
2491 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Administrative Law - Paper
Administrative law simply means that the branch of public law which deals with the organization and powers of administrative and quasi administrative agencies and prescribes the principles and rules by which an official action is reached and reviewed in relation to individual liberty and freedom. Technically, from the definition it is clear to state that administrative law is bound and founded to determine the legality of the government action, the nature and scope of the powers conferred to the government official through checking abuse of administrative power.
Meanwhile, the study of administrative law can be explained in broader after pondering the red light and green light theories, in which the red light theory views primarily that objective of administrative law is to consider the law and control the state power and desires to minimize the encroachments of the state on the rights of individual whereby this is monitored and controlled by judiciary. In connection to that, Green theory relies much in operation of the state in the sense that it allows the intervention of the state in larger public interest ensuring right of citizen and well being of society as whole and this can be achieved through freedom of information, active involvement, positive deliberation, effective consultation and other similar action at the level of administration.
In the same vein, the issue raised, if the means are not trustworthy, how the end could be? Just or unjust. In the light of the control mechanism discussion hereunder is considering intensively how far the means which are not trustworthy could result to unjust end.
POLITICAL PARTIES; as per the political parties Act ,is defined as any organized group formed for the purpose of forming a government or local government authority within the united republic through election or for putting up or supporting candidate to such election .
Now, the modern political thoughts tends to accept the notion that political parties are absolute essential to democracy so far the political parties try to crystallize many shades of opinion into one coherent policy unify many diverse element into one manageable unit. The political parties are manifested from the right of freedom of assembly as stipulated in the constitution .The political parties are mechanism to perform an important function of interest articulation, whereby an individual finds out the open channels to express their interest and needs, and also performing function of interest aggregation ,where peoples demands converted into general policy alternatives. Therefore in modern democracy ,it has always been necessary to guarantee and protect the freedom of assembly ,in that line it is one of the platform for attainment of social development and nurturing of democratic advancement in a given society. But the situation contrary to our country today, the right is restricted and its enjoyment subjected to the laws of the land, the problem comes in the course of interpretation and ,implementing the realization of this right.
Experience can be drawn respectively from Tanzania, that the state limits the occupation of political parties so as to enhance the sustainability of state powers, there various laws and aspect which curtails the freedom of association for political parties and its operation .Starting with:-
Cumbersome procedures for the registration of Political parties. it is a requirement of the law under political parties Act that any political party upon the request for registration must have at least 200 members from ten different region in the country. this number is too large and unrealistic especially in Tanzania where democracy is at infant stage. this provision denies the nourishment of democracy.Forinstance the denial of CCJ(chama cha jamii).Also under the same act it is provided that any political party ,by its constitution advocates the break up of union between Tanganyika and Zanzibar shall be disqualified and denied registration. again this provision limits the scope for scope discussion and will of the people towards union.
The system of permanent national voters registration under the national election Act where without being registered the constitutional right to vote and being voted is vanished. in 2010,some irregularities in the system contributed good number of citizen not to vote due to typographic errors, double entry, false inclusion of alive in the list of deceased. Mere technicalities defeated the rights of citizens.
Denial of independent candidate; one should not be compelled to join a political party in order to enjoy political right. the right to participate in governance of state includes right to vote and be voted. Also the practices shows that the ruling party during election used the government resources in the campaign.forinstance using of government vehicles and converting the government plans to political promises. this act are against free and fair election which is fundamental aspect of democracy.
The role of police force; basically the police force does not guarantee the right to freedom of assembly but merely regulates the enjoyment of the right. on the ground of national security or public safety the police have the power to prohibit the assembly , however ,Lugakingira J,viewed that the law does not operate to take away the right to hold assembly or procession ‘it only empowers the police and magistrate to step in far the preservation of peace and order. but the police used such discretion power contrary even where is not necessary and sometimes used in favour of ruling party. To underscore this, refer the case of Mabere N yaucho Marando&another Vs Attorney General where it was held that ‘’in order to maintain public order and security during political rallies ,it was important for permit to be issued. however that discretionary power to issue permit had to be exercised judicially which required that all political parties get same and equal treatment…
Therefore, the above means seems to be not trustworthy ,hence bars the growth of democracy which is the spirit of our constitution, and participation of people in a matter and due political process fear to face the iron bar of law enforcers. Hence this will defeat the interest of change and justice in community.
ACCESS TO JUSTICE; this emanates from the cardinal principle of law that every person is equal before the law. Regardless of political stands ,religious affiliation, all should be treated alike without affording unnecessary privileges and exemption. Right to access justice is fundamental principle of rule of law. As in the case of Mwl.Paul john mhozya Vs Attorney General held that everyone and every institution or organization in this country is enjoined to pay respect to the principle of supremacy of the law.
Access to justice should be devoid of undue technicalities which defeats the end of justice, the procedure of taking government to court is very cumbersome .this is supported by the case of Peter Ng’omango Vs Gerson Mwangwa and Attorney General held that the right of an individual to have free access to the court is well recognized by constitution. the requirement of the consent of the minister before one can sue the government as imposed in section 6 of government proceeding Act infringes constitution “therefore this law is arbitrary and oppressive since it does not subjected to any control, therefore offends proportionality test.
Also access to justice goes further to the speedy in dispensation of justice. As in the case of Hussanaira Kharton Vs Home Secretary State of Bihar held that delay in trial by itself constitutes denial of justice.
In some circumstances citizens are denied the right o be heard ,while one has to be heard so as to access justice, failure to heard a party constitutes the violation of natural justice which is the spirit of the law. As in the case of Judge in charge of Arusha &Attorney General Vs Munuo that ‘’no one should be condemned unheard’’.
On the other hand, independence of judiciary and impartiality of it determine highly the proper access and attainment of justice. But number of means such as judicial appointment, poor remuneration, and judicial infrastructures denies a number of people not to meet justice. also some enactments such as civil procedure code on the issue of security for cost and election Act on requisite for money so as to launch an appeal of election., denies the access of justice .refer Francis ndyanabo Julius ishengoma Vs Attorney general.
Therefore, justice should not be commercialized ,but should be done though heaven falls. Through easy entry to judicial system, availability of legal representation, equality before the law, our means will be trustworthy and end will be just.
HIGHER ADMINISTRATIVE AUTHORITIES; These include president, ministers ,civil service, higher institutions, and boards, these bodies ought to comply with the principle of natural justice in the course of discharging their duties. the principle are to give reason(s) for any decision made, to hear both sides. And should not be dominated with the personal interest but public interest.
The failure of decision maker to take into account a relevant consideration in making administrative decision is one of the instance of abuse of power and discretion, this would entitle a party with sufficient stand to seek for judicial review of ultravires administrative actions. Now, proper procedures must be followed and decision maker not be biased.
In supporting the above arguments ,the following cases are material. in the case of Mohamed Jawad Mrouch Vs Minister for home affair held that discretionary power must be exercised fairly, and this requires adherence of the rules of natural justice .Also the case of Said juma muslim shekimweri Vs Attorney General held that I this country,civil servant are dismissed for misconduct only and not pleasure of president. and when civil servant dismissed cause must be assigned.
Therefore, in the light of the case of James Gwagilo Vs Attorney General where Mwalusanya J(as he then was)held that ‘’there is no doubt that the absence of reasons would render the constitutional right of appeal and judicial review ineffective and illusionary” I have come in the view that the administrative authority must comply with legality and proportionality test.
ORDINARY JURISDICTION; The matter of jurisdiction is not a mere technicality but fundamental. And independence of judiciary is the spirit of the jurisdiction of the court.by the virtue of Article 107 of constitution, the court is conferred jurisdiction to provide justice.
Independence of judiciary rely on the basis of condition of service and tenure, manner of appointment of judges and discharge of their duties, and degree of stability and logistical protection against outside pressure and harassment .but judges are appointees of President from another pillar, remunerations comes from executive, this is ridiculous.
Also application of law must be of retroactively, and each case must be adjudicated objectively and on merit and not self interest of judges, and impartiality is paramount important. Refer the case of James Bita Vs Iddi kambi held that the judiciary is an instrument of state set up to adjudicate impartiality disputes between subjects and subjects or subjects and government. Judicial officer at any level should not flinch from performing this sacred duty.
Therefore ,the court should not be subjected to the means which are not trustworthy and unreliable so as to enable this temple of justice to be free and dispense justice and justice only without fear.
WRIT JURISDICTION;This includes writ of mandamus,prohibition,certiorari,and habeas corpus., as stipulated under the law reform (fatal accident and miscellaneous provision)Act .The citizen may be aggrieved with the actions and decisions of administrative authorities and request upon the high court to make review and issue an order which is prayed.
However, the court writ jurisdiction is oustered by other laws and cause the court to remain dumb in case of the abuse of of power by public authorities. Article 41(7) enshrines that there shall be no challenge from any person and no any court shall have the power to investigate or entertain the issue of legality of president who announced by National electoral commission.
The court of law is jealous of its jurisdiction ,as held in Mtenga Vs UDSM that it is trite to observe that the court is and has to be for the protection of public ,jealous of its jurisdiction and will not lightly finds its jurisdiction oustered.
Also presence of undue technicalities such as one can not ask for the judicial review unless he/she has obtained leave. This mean leave could defeat the interest of justice; frankly this is not proper approach to justice. in the case of Timothy Mwakilasa Vs Principal secretary held that it is an admitted fact that applicant has not obtained any leave from this court to make his application. That being so, the purported application is incompetent in law and this court ca not entertain it.
Court of law is guardian of citizen rights and it is a temple of justice in which everyone is free to access and attain justice. The means to reach it should not be complex but smooth and trustworthy so as to arrive at the peak of justice.
PUBLIC OPINION AND MASS MEDIA; This two aspects are underscored under the article 18 , and constitutes a primary element of democratic society .It cannot be conceivable without free debate and freedom of media.
However the freedom of collecting and publishing newspapers,magazines,books,bulletins are hampered by the government through the laws which are not trustworthy.Minister ,in his opinion on the ground of public interest may decide to bann any newspaper in the land .Forinstance banning of Mwanahalisi newspaper.this law ousters the jurisdiction of the court ,in which the court is jealous on it.
Also according to Africa media barometer report, Tanzania communication regulatory authority(TCRA) is not entirely independent since both board chairman and director general are presidential appointees. This situation can compromise impartiality of media.
Harassment and killings of the journalists;wherejournalist tend to shock the higher authority by publishing some news ,entered in hostility with the power.On February 2010,journalist Asraj mvungi and others were arrested by police officer following the order from district officials that they instigate land conflict. in connection to that ,killing of one Daud Mwangosi (journalist)draws a road towards the killing of freedom of media. And another challenge is that media is owned by politicians, tycoons and religious institution, hence editorial freedom demises.
Therefore ,the laws that regulates enhancement and betterment of the media is subjected to the absolute discretion of government authorities. This is ridiculous and peril towards transparency and accountability of the government of the day.Hence,with this path the end shall not be just.
As I arrive to the conclusion ,I am of the view that trustworthy means and procedures are cornerstone towards a good end, and always an end justifies the means.therefore,it is high time for us to look back on our laws making bodies and interest of justice for the purpose of modifying them.it is my humble opinion that citizen and government has to respect and adhere constitutionalism and democracy.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Political Parties

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Political Party-A group of political activists who organize to win elections, operate the government, and determine public policy.…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Unit 47 P3

    • 3550 Words
    • 11 Pages

    A political party is an organisation of people who seek to achieve goals that members feel are particularly important, such as giving people better opportunities, creating fairer society, and protecting the environment. The opposition party is Labour party. The UK has here main political parties among many, which are Conservative, Labour and Liberal Democrat. These three parties work in both the House of Lords and House of Commons.…

    • 3550 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Government Paper

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The fundamental goal of political parties is to elect their candidates into office, gain control of the government, and pass their legislation. A political party is a political organization that seeks to attain political power within a government, usually by participating in electoral campaigns. Political parties fight their battles through the electoral process, and they run their candidates for office.…

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Law 531

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages

    * Administrative Law - federal, state, and local level. Administrative law is made by administrative agencies that define the intent of the legislative body that passed the law.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    First Continental Congress

    • 2052 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Administrative law: The law governing the organization and operation of administrative agencies (including executive and independent agencies) and the relations of administrative agencies with the legislature, the executive, the judiciary and the public. Administrative law is divided into three parts: (1) the statutes endowing agencies with powers establishing rules of substantive law relating to those powers; (2) the body of the agency-made law, consisting of administrative rules, regulations, reports, or opinions containing findings of fact, and orders; and (3) the legal principles governing the acts of public agents when those conflict with private rights.…

    • 2052 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Administrative Law

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages

    You are a legislative aide to a state legislator who wishes to introduce legislation creating a new state department of drug enforcement. It is intended that, among other authorities, this new administrative agency will have authority to establish a list of controlled drugs, establish rules regarding penalties for possession or use of controlled drugs, establish a process for adjudicating cases involving violators of the rules, and enter into contracts with a private agency or agencies to establish and manage a system of one or more incarceration facilities to which violators of these rules may be sentenced upon a finding of guilt.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A political party is an organization that seeks political power by presenting and electing its candidates to office so their philosophy and positions become public policy. During and between elections, a political party plays a fundamental roles in strengthening democratic regimes.…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    |Main point(s) made by |The author defines political parties as 'a range of organised political groups with different support base, objectives and |…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    American Political Parties

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages

    There have been many different political parties since the beginning of the American political system. A political party is made up of a group of people that share common goals and ideals, and these people work together to help elect people to offices that share these goals to represent them. Political parties work to try to control the government and their ultimate goal is to win as many elections and to gain as many offices as possible.…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    ENV320Final

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages

    3. What is administrative law and how is it implemented (one sentence for each question)? Administrative laws are laws created by departments and agencies of the government. After Congress passes and puts a law into effect, it is implemented by the agency that will be the best to enforce the law and develop further regulations for the law.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Political Socialization

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Political Party: an organization devoted to winning office in elections and exercising control over policy making…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hyperpluralism

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages

    16. A political party can be defined as a faction whose purpose is to win elections in order to get their demands heard.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why Parties John Aldrich

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the United States political parties and elections are the basis for forming our democratic way of life. A party is a group of people that share common ideas and direction within the government. Generally a party nominates a candidate whom they feel will do the best to ensure the principles and values of their party are reflected in government. Political parties are then responsible for campaigning their candidate and then voting him/her into position of power.…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nowadays great majority of people live in a society where you have an opportunity to voice your opinion on any area you wish. People have rights that guaranteed in Constitution, it means that every individual can make his ideas known to the community.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Political Parties are organizations that try to get their candidates elected and influence the government with their beliefs. There are multiple political parties but among them it is common to have two that stand out. In the US this major political parties will be Republican Party and Democratic Party. Between this two parties is focused the competition and for that reason, we can see the spread of power in government within this two parties. For this reason is that in the past years there was a unified government in which the presidency and the congress was controlled by the Republican party, and recently we could see a divided government when president Obama took the presidency being a Democratic Candidate while the congress was controlled…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics