Preview

abolitionist stance of prisons

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
4809 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
abolitionist stance of prisons
Catherine Giguère
5246389

Term Paper #3

Work submitted to
Professor Justin Piché
In the course Abolitionism and the Criminal Justice System (CRM 4302)

Department de Criminology
University of Ottawa
December 11th 2012
Many individuals believe that the criminal system and its institutions are flawed. These critiques have been brought on by the ineffectiveness of prisons to reform individuals, the ineptness of the system to reduce crime rates, the lack of focus on victims of crimes, as well as the racist, classist and sexist practices existing in these institutions. Therefore, we can ask ourselves if the elimination of the current penal system and the implementation of alternatives would better allow resolve of societal conflict? The following paper will explain why activist and scholars have rejected reliance upon the current penal system and it’s structures to put forth alternatives that they find will be more successful and less repressive. The first part of this paper will focus on key arguments that abolitionists have advanced for the abolition of prison. The second part will focus on arguments advanced by abolitionist for total penal and carceral abolitionism. The last part will focus on the strategies and alternatives that abolitionists have mobilized in their pursuit of prison, penal and carceral abolition. The main works used to support these arguments will be of Davis, Mathieson, Beauchesne, Kappeler, Dyches, Guanipa, Elliot, Morris, Montur-Angus and Beck.
To begin, activist and scholars have advanced in arguing for the abolition of prisons with three key arguments: First, prisons fail at general prevention of crimes, one of the main objectives the institution has set for itself; Second, this institution has failed at rehabilitating those who have been incarcerated; Third, this institution causes more harm than good with a multitude of collateral consequences. The works of Mathieson, Richie, Clear, Beauchesne and



Bibliography: BEAUCHESNE. L. (2004) Les drogues: Les Coûts Cachés de la Prohibition. Montreal. Lanctôt. 333 p. CLEAR, T DALY, E. (2000). Transformative Justice, Charting a Path to Reconciliation, http:// center .theparentscircle.org/images/c7cc6db3dfbd429cb06ea0132d1b60db.pdf, 183p. DAVIS, A. (2003). Are Prisons Obsolete?, New York: Seven Stories Press. 128 p. DUBÉ, R DYCHES, Richard (2009) “Prisoners’ Families: The Forgotten Victims”, the Journal of Prisoners on Prisons, 18 (1&2): 72-80. ELLIOT, E. (2011) Restorative Justice : A Vision of the Good, in Security with Care : Restorative Justice and Healthy Societies, Halifax, Fernwood Press, pp 63-79. GEORGE, A GUANIPA, Y. ( 2011). Commentary on Imprisonment, Prison Labour and Re-entry, Journal of Prisoners on Prisons, 20 (1): p. 23-34. HORII, G KAPPERLER. V. (2000) The Mythology of Crime and Criminal Justice. Prospect Heights: Waveland Press, Inc. (Chap. 1) MATHIESEN, T MENDALOWITZ, A. ( 2008) Restorative Justice : Intergrating Peacemaking in Modern America, http://www.nyc.gov/html/oath/pdf/Mendelowitz.pdf, 14p. MONTURE-ANGUS, P MORRIS, R. (2000) What is Transformative Justice?, in Stories of Transformative Justice, Toronto : Canadian Scholars’Press, pp. 3-22. O’CONNELL, P PASCAL. D. (2012). Tortures et Sociétés (CRM 3715). University of Ottawa, Winter term 2012) PELAEZ, V PICHÉ, J. & STRIMELLE, V. ( 2007) Restoratve Justice Program Evaluation Frameworks : A Site of Pitfalls and Oppurtunities, International Journal of Restorative Justice, 3(2) : 40-56 POLLOCK, S RICHIE, B. (2002) “Families and Incarceration”, in Marc Mauer and Meda Chesney-Lind, Invisible Punishment: The collateral Consequences of Mass imprisonment, New York: The New press, pp.136-149. SUDBURY, J. (2009) Building a Movemenrt to Abolish Prisons : Lessons from the U.S., Journal of Prisonners, 18 ( 1&2) 177- 184 TAYLOR, I., WALTON, P WRIGHT, V. (2010) The sentencing project, consulted October 6th 2012.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The concept of restorative justice is not clearly defined; often referred to as a ‘movement,’ and presented as an option to the mainstream of criminal justice. Rather than harsh punishment to the offender, restorative justice will attempt to establish a connection between the victim and the offenders (Sharpe, 1998). RJ attempts to repair the harm the offender caused the victim(s). This concept initiated in the 1970s, to allow dialog between the victim and offender. In the 1990s, the program expanded to include the community, families and friends (Sharpe, 1998).…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    References: Merlo, Alida and Benekos, Peter. (1999) “Prison over crowding creates a Need for Prison Alternatives”. Article 15. Opposing viewpoints on Prisons.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Historical Prison Eras

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Correctional institutions emerged gradually from the Big House. In this new era harsh discipline and repression by officials became less-oppressive features of prison life. Correctional institutions did not abolish the pains of imprisonment; one might classify most of these prisons as Big Houses “gone soft” (Seiter, 2011). These institutions offered more recreational privileges such as more-liberal mail, different visitation policies, and more amenities including educational, vocational, and therapeutic programs. Something that promoted peace and more stability was…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The core of restorative justice is comprised on fundamental guiding values such as respect, individual dignity, inclusion, responsibility, humility, mutual care, and the reparation of harms (Pranis, 2007). Guiding values evoke individual values including respect, honesty, compassion, open-mindedness and patience, so as to maximize peace while considering the needs of the victim, offender, community and all other stakeholders (Zehr, 2002). Restorative justice is an alternative approach to the traditional punitive justice system that extends the definition of crime as existing beyond one specific violent act (Pepinsky, 2000). Contrary to what is considered in Western society’s view of crime,…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Restorative Justice

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the restorative justice (RJ) city case study; Ed, David, and Mildred, had an unusual encounter. In this story about two young men breaking into a women’s home and violating her rights. In RJ city were this crime took place, the city has a very unique way of dealing with crime by using restorative justice. The restorative justice process emphasizes on repairing harm that is cause by crime. This repair includes the victim, the offender, and the members of the community. All these entities have to work together to create a way to repair the damage done by crimes in this city.…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Restorative Justice

    • 1371 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This week’s assignment is a paper on the Restorative Justice Process. The instruction is to “review the RJ City case study regarding Ed and David Brooke, (http://www.rjcity.org/the-project/documents/Case%20Study% 2030-10-09.pdf). This report will give an explanation of the restorative justice process, identifying the crime, the effect the crime had that went beyond the harm it inflicted on the victim. In addition, a comparison between the restorative justice system and the contemporary justice system will be reviewed. Finally, after reflecting on the restorative process the report will show the benefit it provided David, Mildred and the community.…

    • 1371 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In modern America, prisons have become a controversial topic that is prevalent throughout various forms of media, political debates, and social discussions. During the numerous debates of the 2016 presidential primaries, politicians argued about how the prison population has grown rapidly to approximately two million people. In news programs and newspapers, there are extensive reports about the quality of the conditions in various prisons. In several popular television shows and movies, there are diverse sets of characters who struggle to survive daily life in prison. Although there are several conversations about prisons, an aspect that is frequently forgotten is the rights of current and former prisoners. Because of certain laws, when an individual is convicted of a crime, he or she loses…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The concept of restorative justice has many different branches that one must understand in order to fully grasp the reasoning and objectives of restorative justice. There are many different theories that helped mold the structure and belief in the theory of restorative justice. In this paper we will discuss:…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    5. According to Angela Y. Davis the hegemonic understanding of prisons that non-incarcerated people get via various media outlets is based on the portrayal of prisons as necessary institutions that simultaneously keep drug addicts, the mentally ill, and violent individuals away from society. In a sense, prisons operate as a filtration system that can remove or obscure the unwanted members of society in order to maintain social integrity and order.…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Restorative Justice

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Restorative justice is a mediation amongst the victim, offender and the community, the objective of the mediation consists of reparation, reconciliation and rehabilitate the offender. This essay will also compare and contrast a number of restorative justice initiatives and retributive approaches to determine which is more effective.…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Pros Of Incarceration

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There is much more behind prisons bars than the already public expression of “crime and punishment,” it is not just a law enforcement or a form of social punishment by restricting the freedom of the individual. Prison is closely linked (pv) to the way society develops and is a reflection of social standards, opportunities and the way the government “selects” what to punish. In the United States, there is a program called welfare that benefits people who are destitute with a government subsidy, from 1975 to 2000 the number of individuals helped by this program fell sharply while the prison population increased in a similar proportion. This picture shows a new social reformulation within the country, a new selection of prisoners. Incarceration…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Perfecting the Prison System Thesis: Davis’ reforms can help alleviate philosophical prison problems by preparing students to become better adults and providing the necessary care and help to those in need before it is too late, such as those with mental illness and drug problems. Foucault, Guenther, and Alexander’s Views Over the Prison System: While the prison system is supposed to punish offenders for their crimes and help rehabilitate offenders to return to society as functional individuals, there are a number of issues with the prison system. According to recent statistics, studies have shown the United States to have the highest rate of incarceration compared to any other country in the world, at 750 incarcerated for every 100,000…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abolitionists advocate drastically limiting the role of criminal law. We do this not because we wish to encourage certain behaviour, but because we realize that criminal sanctions are not an effective way of dealing with social problems. There are far too many laws on the books. It would be prohibitively expensive to enforce them all. This results in unjust and arbitrary law enforcement. Powerless persons are imprisoned while more powerful persons go free. People of colour, first nations and poor people bear the brunt of unequal law enforcement.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Restorative justice is an approach to justice that focuses on the needs of the victims and the offenders, as well as the involved community, instead of satisfying abstract legal principles or punishing the offender. Restorative Justice approaches to crime date back thousands of years. The word restorative justice has appeared in written sources since the first half of the nineteenth century. In Restoring Justice –An Introduction to Restorative Justice, Daniel W. Van Ness and Karen Heetderks Strong say that the term “restorative Justice” was likely coined by Albert Eglash in 1958 when he distinguished between three approaches to justice: (1) “retributive justice”, based on punishment. (2) “Distributive justice” involving therapeutic treatment of the offenders; and (3) “restorative justice,” based on restitution with input from the victims and offenders. Author Howard Zehr stated that “with crime, restorative justice is about the idea that because crime hurts, justice should be healed. It follows that conversations with those who have been hurt and with those who…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Incarceration Vs Prison

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There is a plethora of research surrounding the phenomena of incarceration, however, the predominant theme is either the prisoner or prisons (Light & Campbell, 2006). This is also consistent with the myopic views of the media. Headlines surrounding incarceration typically use shock tactics to manipulate society's attention to crime and punishment. What isn't considered is the network of parents, siblings, partners and children who have existed in the shadows throughout every stage of the adjudication process; serving a metaphorical sentence of their own (....,...). ..... refers to this group of people as the 'forgotten victims of crime' . The first study on prisoner's families was conducted by Morris (1965). During this time the prison population…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics